Table 2.
Author | Study Type | Year | Laser | Therapy Parameters | Fitzpatrick Scale | No. of Cases | Clinical Outcome | Adverse Events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Imagawa et al. [24] | Prospective comparative study | 2023 | 550-ps 755 nm and 50-ns 755 nm lasers | Clinical endpoint for fluence choice was immediate whitening, with fluence ranging from 2.33 to 3.36 J/cm2 for ps laser and 5.5 to 7 J/cm2 for ns laser. PD: 550 ps and 50 ns for respective lasers; 2.5–3 mm spot | III–IV | 10 | Ps laser had superior efficacy, requiring fewer average sessions (4.2) than ns-laser (5.4) | Hyper- and hypopigmentation occurred in the ns group. The ps group had no side effects. |
Yang et al. [25] | Retrospective study | 2022 | ps-755 nm Alexandrite laser | Fluence 1.96–2.08 J/cm2, 3.5–4.0-mm spot | III-IV | 86 | 96.5% of patients achieved >95% clearance in an average of 4.3 sessions. Early onset of lesions (<5 months of age) and darker skin types (type IV vs. III) significantly increased the number of sessions required for clearance. Age at first treatment, sex, and nevus color had no significant effect. | Transient hyper- and hypopigmentation |
Koh et al. [20] | Retrospective review | 2020 | Picosecond 755-nm laser | For NO, the average fluence was 2.02 J/cm2, and for HN, it was 2.08 J/cm2 | III/IV | 29 | In the NO group, mean pre-and-post-treatment Physician global assessment scores were 3.1 and 1.3, respectively (1.8-point change, p = 0.0002). In HN group, mean pre-and-post-treatment PGA scores were 2.6 and 1.1, respectively (1.5-pt change, p = 0.004) | Eleven patients (37.9%) experienced post-laser erythema, and 1 (3.4%) developed transient post-laser hypopigmentation. |
Ge et al. [27] | RCT (Split-lesion study in nevus of Ota) | 2020 | Ps-755-nm Alexandrite laser versus ns-QS 755-nm Alexandrite laser | Each lesion was treated with single-pass method in up to 6 sessions at 12-week intervals. ps-laser: 2–4 mm spot, 1.59–6.37 J/cm2, 5 Hz. Ns-laser: 3 mm spot, 5–7 J/cm2, 5 Hz. | III–IV | 56 | Higher efficacy, decreased pain scores, and post-inflammatory hyper/hypopigmentation in the ps laser-treated group. | There was an improved clearance, with fewer side effects and more patient satisfaction in the ps-laser arm. |
Hu et al. [28] | Retrospective study | 2021 | Ps-755-nm Alexandrite laser | Fluence 2.73–3.98 J/cm2, spot size 2.9 to 2.4 mm, PD 650-ps, 1 to 4 sessions. | III–IV | 36 | 88.89% of patients had moderate to marked improvement. | Transient swelling and erythema. Transient PIH (in two patients) and hypopigmentation (in one patient) that resolved in 6 weeks. |
Yu et al. [29] | RCT (Split-face study in Hori’s nevus) | 2018 | ps 755-nm Alexandrite laser vs. ns-QS 755-nm Alexandrite | 12-week interval. ps-laser: 2–2.5 mm spot, 4.07–6.37 J/cm2, 2.5 Hz. Ns-laser: 3 mm spot, 6–8 J/cm2, 2 Hz. | III–IV | 30 | The PSAL-treated area achieved significantly better clearance (3.73 vs. 2.4) with less severe pain (4.47 vs. 5.16) | the PSAL and QSAL treatments, lasting for nearly one and a half months |
Belkin et al. [23] | Retrospective case series | 2018 | QS lasers (Ruby 694 nm in type IV and QS Nd:YAG 1064 nm in types V, VI) | Patients were treated without general anesthesia or sedation; corneal shields were used where appropriate. | IV–VI | 24 (children <18yrs) | Excellent response (76–100% improvement) in 70% of patients and good to excellent response (51–100% improvement) in 86%. Fewer sessions/lesser fluence required and fewer complications in younger patients. | Two patients (8%) had post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, one of whom also had focal hypopigmentation. |
Nam et al. [30] | Retrospective study | 2017 | Multiple QS laser modalities | Settings varied for different laser machines. | / | 67 | An average of 19 sessions (range 10–27, p = 0.001) is required for 95% clearance. | Two patients (3%) had persistent side effects, e.g., atrophic scarring, though not mentioned how many sessions these patients underwent. |
PD Pulse Duration; NO Nevus of Ota; HN Hori’s Nevus; / refers to detail not mentioned in study.