Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 6;10(7):e29193. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e29193

Table 3.

Risk of bias.

Study Sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding of participants/personnel Blinding of assessors loss to follow-up/ITT analysis reported Free of selective reporting Free of other bias sources Appraisal of quality Comment
Backman et al. Yes Unclear No No Unclear Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for one or more key domains
Bade et al. Unclear unclear No No Unclear yes Unclear High Risk High and unclear RoB for one or more key domains
Baglia et al. Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear risk High RoB in only 1 domain
Cantarero et al. Yes unclear No Yes Yes Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for one or more key domains
Chatterjee et al. Yes Unclear No Yes Yes Yes Unclear High risk Unclear and high RoB for one or more key domains
Cormie et al. Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes unclear Unclear risk High and unclear RoB in only 1 domain
Dimeo et al. Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Fields et al. Yes Yes No No Unclear Yes unclear High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Galveo et al. Yes Unclear No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Hayes et al. Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes unclear Unclear risk High and unclear RoB in only 1 domain each
Irwin et al. Yes Unclear No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High and unclear RoB for one or more key domains
Knols et al. Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear risk High RoB in only 1 domain
McNeely et al. 04 Yes Unclear No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Mijwel et al. Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Unclear High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Nyrop et al. Unclear No No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High RoB for one or more key domains
Park et al. Unclear Yes No Yes Yes Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Paulo et al. Unclear Unclear No No Yes Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Rief et al. Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Rief et al. (a) Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Rief et al. (b) Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Schmidt et al. Yes Yes No No Unclear Yes Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Van Waart et al. Yes Unclear No No Yes Yes Yes High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain
Yeo et al. Yes Unclear No No Yes Unclear Unclear High risk High and unclear RoB for more than key domain