Table 1.
Method | Required training data sourcea | Features | Tuning parameters |
---|---|---|---|
Single-ancestry | |||
C + T | target ancestry | model-free | (p value threshold) |
LDpred2 | target ancestry | Bayesian (spike-and-slab prior) | (causal SNP proportion), (heritability) |
EUR C + T | EUR | model-free | (p value threshold) |
EUR LDpred2 | EUR | Bayesian (spike-and-slab prior) | (causal SNP proportion), (heritability) |
Multi-ancestry | |||
weighted LDpred2 | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | Bayesian (spike-and-slab prior), linear combination strategy | , weight of each ancestry-specific PRS in the final model |
PRS-CSx | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | Bayesian (Strawderman-Berger prior), linear combination strategy | (global shrinkage parameter), weight of each ancestry-specific PRS in the final model |
XPASSb | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | Bayesian (bivariate normal prior), infinitesimal model | – |
PolyPred+b | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | Bayesian, functional annotation, linear combination of SBayesR and PolyFun | parameters in SBayesR and PolyFun, weight of SBayesR PRS and PolyFun PRS in the final model |
CT-SLEB | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | empirical Bayes, EL via SL | (p value threshold), (genetic distance) for C + T step, parameters in the SL |
MUSSEL | ancestry-specific data from each available ancestry | Bayesian (multivariate spike-and-slab prior), EL via SL | , parameters in the SL |
All methods require three datasets to train the PRS model: (1) discovery GWAS summary data, (2) LD reference data, and (3) tuning data.
Results from PolyPred+ and XPASS on all simulated and real datasets (except for PAGE + UKBB + BBJ) were reported in Zhang et al.13