Table 2.
Study | RT program performed before the engagement in the study | Exercises performed | TRAD intervention | ADV intervention | Progression of training loads | Quantification of training load |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Amirthalingam 2017 | Not reported | Flat bench press; lat pull-down; incline bench press; seated row; crunches; leg press; dumbbell lunges; leg extensions; leg curls; calf raises; shoulder press; upright row; triceps pushdowns; biceps curls; sit-ups with a twist | 5 sets of 10 rep with 60–80% 1RM and 60−90s of rest interval (only in 6 exercises) | GVT. 10 sets of 10 rep with 60–80% 1RM and 60−90 s rest interval (only in 6 exercises). | Loads were adjusted by 5–10% once the participants were able to complete 10 repetitions on the final set of each exercise | Only the initial and final VL for 3 exercises |
| ||||||
Angleri 2017 | Participants reported training lower limbs at least 2 d.wk.−1 and performing leg press 45° and leg extension | Leg press; leg extension | 3–5 sets of 6–12 rep with 75% 1RM and 120 s of rest. Training occurred according to pre-established VL. | VL of DS and CP were equalized with TRAD. DS: sets were performed until failure, with a drop load of ∼20% on each failure until reaching the prescribed VL. CP: 3–5 of 6–15 rep with 65–85% 1RM and 120 s rest interval. | Initial VL was defined as 120% of the VL that each participant performed in the 2 weeks before the study. The number of sets and repetitions was adjusted every time that the VL was increased (∼7% every 3 weeks). | Total VL reported for the whole RT program |
| ||||||
Branderburg 2002 | Not reported | Preacher curl; supine elbow extension | 4 sets of ∼10 rep with 75% 1RM | EO. 3 sets of ∼10 rep with 75% 1RM on concentric and 110–120% 1RM on the eccentric phase. | The load was adjusted when the average number of repetitions performed per set in a training session became greater than 10 | Not reported† |
| ||||||
Enes 2021 | Not reported | Barbell back squat; 45° leg press; seated knee extension; stiff-leg deadlift; seated knee flexion | 4 sets of 12 rep with 70% 1RM and 120 s of rest interval | DS. 3 sets of 10 with 70% 1RM and 3 additional sets of 6 rep with 55% 1RM with 120 s of rest between sets and no rest before additional sets (only 3 of 5 exercises). RP. 3 sets of 10 with 75% 1RM and 3 additional sets of 6 rep with 75% 1RM with 120 s of rest between sets and 20 s before additional sets (only 3 of 5 exercises). | The load was adjusted by 5% in the fifth week | Total VL reported for the whole RT program |
| ||||||
Fisher 2014 | Previous experience with PE system | Chest press; leg press; pull-down; pectoral fly; leg extension; pull-over; abdominal flexion; lumbar extension | TRAD: one set of ∼12RM and 60 s of rest. Control∗: one set of ∼12RM and 60 s of rest. | PE: one set of ∼12RM and 60 s of rest between sets and 5 s between isolated and compound exercises | Once participants were able to perform more than 12 repetitions before achieving failure, the load was adjusted by 5% | Not reported |
| ||||||
Fisher 2016 A | Participants reported having done single-set training until failure for multiple exercises including most major muscle groups 2 d.wk.−1 | Leg extension, leg curl; leg press; overhead press; chest press; pec-fly; pull-over; pull-down | One set of 8–12 reps with 75% 1RM with 120 s of rest interval between exercises and cadence of 6 s per rep | EO: one set of 8 reps with 105% 1RM with 60 s of rest interval between exercises and cadence of 10 s per rep (only one session; the other was realized identical to TRAD). SS: one set of 6 reps with 75% 1RM with 60 s of rest interval between exercises and cadence of 12 s per rep. | Once participants were able to perform more than desired repetitions, the load was adjusted by 5% | Not reported |
| ||||||
Fisher 2016 B | Participants reported having done single-set training until failure for multiple exercises including most major muscle groups 2 d.wk.−1 | Chest press; leg press; pull-down; overhead press; adductor; abductor; abdominal flexion; lumbar extension; pec-fly; pullover; leg extension; dips; biceps curl; seated calf raise; leg curl; core torso rotation | One set of 8−12RM | DS: one set of 8−12RM with additional set with reduction of ∼30% on load (only 3 exercises; 12 exercises of 15 were realized identical to TRAD). HDS: one set of ∼4RM with an additional set with two reductions of ∼20% on load (only 3 exercises; 12 exercises of 15 were realized identical to TRAD). | Once participants were able to perform more than 12 repetitions before achieving failure, the load was increased by 5% (only reported for TRAD) | Not reported |
| ||||||
Hackett 2018 | Participants reported training at least 3 d.wk.−1 | Flat bench press; lat-pulldown; incline bench press; seated row; crunches; shoulder press; upright row; triceps pushdowns; biceps curl; sit-ups with a twist | 5 sets of 10 reps with 60–80% 1RM and 60–90 s of rest interval (only in 6 exercises) | GVT: 10 sets of 10 reps with 60–80% 1RM and 60−90 s of rest interval (only in 6 exercises) | When participants were able to complete >10 repetitions on the final set, the load was increased by approximately 5–10% | Average VL for only 2 exercises (a total of 15 exercises were utilized) |
| ||||||
Prestes 2019 | The subjects were accustomed to training 3–5 days per week with split-body training routines and 3-4 sets of 8−12RM per exercise with the objective of muscle hypertrophy | Barbell bench press; dumbbell incline press; cable cross; military press; lateral raise; triceps pulley; barbell triceps extension; squat; 45° leg press; leg curl; front lat pull-down; seated row; dumbbell lateral row; standing barbell elbow curl; preacher curl | 3 sets of 6 rep with 80% 1RM and 120−180 s of rest interval | RP: one set of 18 rep with 80% 1RM (performed with intra-set rests of 20 s) and 120 s of rest between exercises | No progression or adjustments were reported | Not reported |
| ||||||
Walker 2016 | Not reported | Bilateral leg press; unilateral knee extension; unilateral knee flexion | 3 sets of 6RM or 10RM with 120−180 s of rest interval | EO: 3 sets of 6RM or 10RM with +40% of the load in eccentric phase and 120−180 s of rest interval | The load was adjusted to provide muscle failure in at least one of three sets | Not reported |
Rep: repetitions; 1RM: one-repetition maximum test; GVT: German volume training; VL: volume load; DS: drop-set; CP: crescent pyramid; TRAD: traditional resistance training; EO: eccentric overload; RP: rest-pause; RM: repetition maximum (performed until failure); PE: pre-exhaustion; SS: super slow; HDS: heavy DS; ∗ = groups were not considered in the calculation of standardized mean difference. †= programmed volume load (calculated as sets × repetitions × percentage of 1RM) was reported to be equal between protocols.