| MDA-MB-231 |
Variance in pressure required to initiate cavitation |
High speed camera and pressure gauge |
50 cells per mL culture medium suppl. with Jurkat cells |
— |
>40 minutes for RBC lysis; detection “within minutes” |
— |
— |
— |
— |
N/A |
158
|
| - Breast cancer |
| H1975 |
Dislocation herringbone μF geometry, immobilised anti-EpCAM Ab |
IF (CK 18+/CD45−) |
5 cells per mL whole blood |
20 μL min−1 for cells spiked in blood optimized flow rate |
No blood pre-processing; 5 hours per sample |
— |
H1975 87%, A549 78%, H460 72% |
99.6% |
— |
EpCAM |
116
|
| A549 |
| H460 |
| - Lung cancer |
| A549 |
Off-chip incubation with anti-EpCAM MNPs, μF on-chip magnetic capture |
UCL imaging |
10 cells/2 mL PBS |
1 mL h−1 optimized flow rate |
RBC lysis and 2 h incubation with anti-EpCAM MNPs; not detailed |
0.5 mL spiked whole blood, 5 mL patient blood sample |
>80% |
— |
80% release efficiency; released cells could be cultured for 7 days |
EpCAM |
118
|
| - Lung cancer |
| VcaP |
Immuno-modified MNPs, hydrodynamic separation on chip |
EChem oxidation of redox-active secondary Ab, IF validation |
2 cells per mL whole blood |
— |
20 min incubation with anti-EpCAM MNPs; ∼3 h to pump sample through, signal read out 1 min per sample, ∼1.5 h for IF |
— |
85% |
Average capture of ∼80 WBCs |
— |
EpCAM |
117
|
| - Prostate cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Hydrodynamic μF cell sorter with size exclusion membrane filter |
Single-cell western blotting |
23 cells/2 mL whole blood |
1.4 mL min−1
|
10 min RBC lysis, 15 min washing; not detailed |
7.5 mL blood sample |
87–98.5% |
89.92% |
Analysis of EMT in CTCs isolated from patient samples |
N/A |
41
|
| - Breast cancer |
| A459 |
| - Lung cancer |
| HeLa |
| -Cervical cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Antibody functionalised electrodes |
EIS, IF validation |
100 cells per mL PBS |
— |
RBC lysis; not detailed |
— |
— |
— |
— |
EpCAM, CD36 |
112
|
| - Breast cancer |
| SK-MEL-2 |
Abs on PANI modified carbon SPEs |
EChem reduction of solution redox probe |
1 cell/1 mL PBS suppl. with human cells |
1.5 mL min−1
|
Not detailed; not detailed |
— |
— |
— |
— |
MCR1 |
114
|
| - Skin cancer |
| A549 |
Off-chip incubation with daunomycin, AC field isolation on μF chip |
EChem oxidation of daunomycin |
7 cells per mL whole blood |
5 μL min−1 for 5 minutes followed by 2.5 μL min−1
|
40 min (30 min incubation with daunomycin, 5 min centrifuge); not detailed |
1 mL of whole blood |
Average of 95+–1.5% |
92+–0.5% |
— |
N/A |
54
|
| - Lung cancer |
| MDA-MB-231 |
| - Breast cancer |
| HeLa |
| -Cervical cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Off-chip incubation with immuno-modified magnetic beads, on-chip application of magnetic field |
IF (CD45−/HER2+/Hoechst 33 342+) |
10 cells/2 mL whole blood |
Optimal flow rate 90 μL min−1 for spiking and 1 μL min−1 for patient samples |
Dilution of whole blood, incubation with magnetic beads for unknown time; 240 min for entire process |
— |
93% |
— |
On-chip cell lysis for subsequent RNA-seq |
EpCAM |
121
|
| - Breast cancer |
| H446 |
Size based sorting in trap channel based on flow resistance |
IF (CD45−/CK+/DAPI+), additional IF of EpCAM and vimentin |
5 cells per suspension of 100 000 WBCS |
Optimized injection pressure of 10 mbar |
Ficoll-Paque processing; not detailed |
— |
92–99% depending on WBC count |
<80–92% depending on WBC concentration |
Achieved release efficiency of >97% |
N/A |
140
|
| - Small cell lung cancer |
| H1975 |
| - Non-small cell lung cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Size-selective vortex trapping with chip geometry |
Deformability cytometry (DC), IF for validation (CK+/CD45−/DAPI+) |
300 cells per unknown volume of 10× diluted blood |
8 mL min−1
|
10× dilution of blood in PBS; not detailed |
— |
25–35% |
35.1+–7.3% |
98.7+–1.5% of cells transfer from capture to assay region of chip |
N/A |
138
|
| - Breast cancer |
| MCF-7 |
1) Off-chip incubation with anti-EpCAM microbeads |
Signal amplification using DNA–Ab conjugates in RIDA |
50 cells/1 mL of whole blood |
Optimal flow rate of 1–3 mL h−1, 3 mL h−1 used for patient samples |
25-Minute centrifugation for WBC separation; not detailed |
— |
>85% |
20–40% |
Captured cells proliferated normally in culture |
EpCAM |
120
|
| - Breast cancer |
| BxPC-3 |
| -Pancreatic cancer |
| HeLa |
2) Inertial micro-flow system |
| - Cervical cancer |
| PANC-1 |
| -Pancreatic cancer |
| PC3 |
Dielectrophoresis on-chip |
Brightfield microscopy |
Not available |
Optimal flow rate of 3 μL min−1
|
Not detailed; not detailed |
— |
— |
— |
DEP buffer can have effects on cells' gene expression (>15 min) |
N/A |
142
|
| - Prostate cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Off-chip incubation with Ab-conjugated MNPs, magnetic ranking on-chip (MagRC chip) |
IF (DAPI+/CK+/CD45−) |
10 cells/1 mL unprocessed blood |
600 μL h−1
|
30 minute incubation with anti-EpCAM nanobeads; not detailed |
1 mL of blood used for patient samples |
SKBR3 97+–3%, PC-3 90+–2%, MDA-MB-231 90+–3% |
— |
92% recovery, 98% viable |
EpCAM, (plus HER2 and N-cadherin for SKBR3 cells) |
115
|
| SKBR3 |
| - Breast cancer |
| PC3 |
| - Prostate cancer |
| MDA-MB-231 |
| - Breast cancer (mesenchymal properties) |
| MDA-MB-231 |
Off-chip incubation with anti-HER2 MNPs, magnetic ranking on-chip |
IF of estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor (PR) |
— |
3 mL h−1
|
No experiments with patient samples conducted |
No experiments with patient samples conducted |
MDA-MB-231 65.3+–1.6%, BT-474 99.3+–0.4%, SK-BR-3 99.9+–0.1%, MCF-7 92.9+–1.8% |
— |
— |
HER2 |
122
|
| BT-474 |
| SK-BR-3 |
| MCF-7 |
| - Breast cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Size based isolation with CellSieve microfilter |
IF (CK8/18/19+, EpCAM+, DAPI+), H&E staining |
— |
5 mL min−1 for cells spiked in whole blood |
No blood pre-processing; not detailed |
— |
Approx. 90% |
>99.9% removal of WBCs from blood sample |
Cell lines adhered and grew on the microfilters, 97+–2% release efficiency of MCF-7 cells |
N/A |
137
|
| MDA-MB-231 |
| SK-BR-3 |
| - Breast cancer |
| PANC-1 |
| - Pancreatic cancer |
| A549 |
Size based isolation with PDMS membrane filter-based microdevice |
IF (CK-PE+/CD45-FITC−/DAPI+) |
1 cell/1.5 mL of whole blood |
Optimized flow rate of 10 mL h−1 for cells spiked in whole blood |
No blood pre-processing; not detailed |
— |
>92% for A549 and SK-MES-1 cells; 99% for H446 |
— |
— |
N/A |
139
|
| SK-MES-1 |
| H446 |
| - Lung cancer |
| PC-3 |
ODEP following IF identification of cells of interest |
IF (CD45−/Hoechst+/EpCAM+) |
10 cells per mL whole blood |
Optimized flow rate of 2.5 μL min−1 for cells spiked in whole blood |
No blood pre-processing; not detailed |
8 mL of blood for spiking experiments |
41.5% |
As high as 100% |
Detection occurs prior to isolation |
N/A |
149
|
| - Prostate cancer |
| SKBR3 |
SMART-chip; microchannels with immobilized anti-EpCAM Ab |
Impedance counting and viability of unlabelled single cells; IF (DAPI+/CD45−/Pan-CK+) |
— |
— |
No blood pre-processing; 3.5 h |
2 mL of blood processed for patient samples |
>80%; 73% for anti-EpCAM PC linker with SKBR3 cells in whole blood |
>85% |
Quick (2 min) and efficient (>90%) release of affinity-captured CTCs via photo release with visible blue light |
EpCAM |
119
|
| - Breast cancer |
| MCF-7 |
3D PDMS scaffold with immobilized anti-EpCAM Ab |
IF staining (DAPI+/CK+/CD45−) |
10 cells/1 mL whole blood |
Optimized flow rate of 100 μL min−1 for cells spiked in whole blood |
No blood pre-processing; ∼4.5 h |
1 mL of whole blood for spiking experiments |
Average capture efficiency of 88.4% |
— |
CTC clusters were also detected and imaged in patient samples |
EpCAM |
56
|
| - Breast cancer |
| MCF-7 |
Raman active nanoprobes (RANs) conjugated to Ab (anti-CD133, anti-EpCAM, anti-HER2, anti-MUC1) with biotinylated dsDNA for isolation |
In situ subtyping by Raman barcoding system |
— |
10 μL min−1
|
2× dilution with PBS, Ficoll-Paque processing, centrifugation for WBC exclusion, 30 min incubation with RANs; not detailed |
4 mL blood for spiking experiments |
90% |
— |
Detects circulating cancer stem cells (CCSCs) as well as CTCs, ability to release captured cells using restriction enzymes |
CD133, EpCAM, HER2, MUC1 |
113
|
| MDA-MB-231 |
| SK-BR-3 |
| - Breast cancer |
| A549 |
Windmill-like hole array for size-based isolation |
IF staining (DAPI+/CD45−/Ep-CAM+ CTC signature) |
<10 cells per mL blood |
2 mL min−1
|
Unspecified pre-treatment and dilution with 10 mL PBS; not detailed |
1–3 mL whole blood for patient samples |
93% for A549 cells; 90% for HeLa cells |
WBC depletion rate of 98.7% |
— |
N/A |
55
|
| - Lung cancer |
| HeLa |
| - Cervical cancer |
| A549 |
DEP |
EIS |
3 cells |
Flow rate of 1.2 μL min−1
|
Not detailed; electrical operation ∼10 min |
— |
Approx. 80% |
— |
Detection limit achieved at 50 kHz |
N/A |
146
|
| - Lung cancer |
| A549 |
SDAM |
FRET (peptide probe for MMP9 enzyme activity) |
Single cell |
— |
Diluted 10 mL blood (blood : PBS = 1 : 1) |
5 mL |
— |
— |
Evaluate EMT and cancer metastasis |
MMP6 enzyme activity |
141
|
| - Lung cancer |
| HGC-27 |
IMD composed of a spiral chip (using the DFF technique) and a DLD chip |
IF staining (EpCAM, YAP1, HER-2, CD45) |
1 cell/10 000 cells |
Optimized flow rate of 12 μL min−1
|
Ascites and peritoneal lavages |
N/A |
63% |
73% |
|
EpCAM |
159
|
| - Gastric cancer |
| SK-MEL28 |
ac-EHD with antibody modified chip |
Raman signature for MCSP, MCAM, ErbB3, and LNGFR (melanoma) and PD-L1 and EGFR (lung cancer) |
— |
Loaded immediately into the chip with ac-EHD applied for 10 min |
PBMCs suspended in 2.0 mL RPMI 2 h |
— |
60% |
N/A |
|
MCSP for melanoma cells |
160
|
| - Melanoma |
| NSCLC |
EGFR for lung cancer cells |
| - Lung cancer |
| A549 |
Microporous parylene membrane |
Raman intensity |
N/A |
Dropped onto the micropore membrane for filtration |
A549 cells in 100 μL culture medium into 400 μL blood |
— |
91% |
90% |
Aptamer probe selected for preferential binding to CTCs |
Size based filtration |
161
|
| - Lung cancer |
| SK-BR-3 |
3D electrode integrated within a microfluidic flow channel |
SWV |
— |
40 μL min−1
|
Not discussed |
— |
71% |
N/A |
|
EPCAM |
163
|
| - Breast cancer |