Abstract
Background
Rectal cancer is a disease in which cancer cells form in the rectum, which has the primary function of temporarily storing feces, controlling defecation, and maintaining continence. Surgery is the most common treatment for rectal cancer; surgical approaches include open, laparoscopic, and robotic assisted. We conducted an expedited summary of the clinical evidence for robotic-assisted surgery for rectal cancer, which included an evaluation of effectiveness and safety.
Methods
We performed a systematic literature search of the clinical evidence to retrieve systematic reviews and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). We assessed the risk of bias in the included systematic reviews using AMSTAR 2 (A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, version 2), and we assessed the risk of bias in the included RCT using the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool for Randomized Trials, version 1. We reported the quality of the body of evidence as evaluated in the included systematic reviews according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group criteria if it was evaluated.
Results
We included 14 studies in the clinical evidence review (12 systematic reviews and 1 RCT on robotic-assisted vs. laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery and 1 systematic review on robotic-assisted vs. open rectal cancer surgery). Compared with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar overall survival; similar rates of conversion, blood transfusion, and readmission,· reduced blood loss; shorter length of stay; and improved quality of life. Compared with open rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar overall survival, reduced blood loss, and shorter length of stay.
Conclusions
Robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar or improved clinical outcomes compared with laparoscopic and open rectal cancer surgery.
Objective
This expedited summary of the clinical evidence evaluates the effectiveness and safety of robotic-assisted surgery for rectal cancer.
Background
Health Condition
Rectal cancer is a disease in which cancer cells form in the rectum, which, in an adult, makes up about the last 6 inches of the large bowel and connects the colon to the anus. Its purpose is to temporarily store feces, control defecation, and maintain continence.
Rectal cancer is often grouped with colon cancer, referred to collectively as colorectal cancer. Rectal cancer may be found during colorectal cancer screening or based on suspected symptoms. Signs and symptoms of rectal cancer may include change in bowel habits, rectal bleeding, blood in the stool, abdominal pain, narrow stool, fatigue, and unexplainable weight loss.1 Risk factors for rectal cancer include age, family history, smoking, eating processed meats, and obesity.
Tests to diagnose and stage rectal cancer may include colonoscopy, biopsy, computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and positron emission tomography (PET).2 The stages of rectal cancer range from 0 (limited to the rectum lining) to 4 (advanced cancer that has spread to other areas of the body).3
Clinical Need and Population of Interest
According to a 2022 report on cancer statistics from Ontario Health (Cancer Care Ontario), colorectal cancer accounted for about 11% of all newly diagnosed cases of cancer in Ontario, making it the third most common cancer after breast and lung cancer.4 Colorectal cancer also represented 11% of all cancer deaths and is the second leading cause of death from cancer after lung cancer. About 1 in 15 people in Ontario are expected to develop colorectal cancer in their lifetime.
Rectal cancer is the second most common cancer in the large intestine after proximal colon cancer.5 According to US data from 2013 to 2019, the 5-year survival rate is about 90% for localized rectal cancer, about 74% for regional rectal cancer, and about 18% for distant rectal cancer.6
Current Treatment Options
Prognosis and treatment for rectal cancer depend on many factors, including tumour location, size, and stage; overall health; and personal preferences regarding treatment.7 Treatments for rectal cancer include surgery, chemotherapy, radiation therapy, targeted drug therapy, and immunotherapy.
Surgery is the most common treatment for all stages of rectal cancer. Types of rectal cancer surgery include transanal local excision (the removal of small cancers from inside the rectum), low anterior resection or proctectomy (the removal of all or part of the rectum), and abdominoperineal resection (the removal of the rectum, anus, part of the colon, and nearby tissue and lymph nodes).8
Chemotherapy or radiation therapy may be used as the primary treatment for advanced rectal cancer or if surgery is not an option.8 Radiation therapy and/or chemotherapy may also be used before surgery to reduce tumour size or after surgery to destroy remaining cancer cells and reduce the chance of cancer recurrence.
Health Technology Under Review
Robotic surgical systems are typically composed of 3 integrated elements: a surgeon console, a patient side cart with interactive robotic arms connected to the surgical instruments, and a video tower, which consists of a high-definition 3-dimensional vision system. The most commonly used robotic surgical system worldwide is Intuitive Surgical's da Vinci Surgical System; however, other systems are available, including the Hugo RAS system (Medtronic), the Senhance Surgical System (Asensus), and the hinotori Surgical Robot System (Medicaroid).
The benefits of robotic-assisted surgery include improved ergonomics for surgeons, better visualization owing to 3-dimensional imaging, elimination of physiologic tremors, improved dexterity owing to the flexible surgical instruments, and improved ability to navigate narrow spaces such as the pelvis.9 However, limitations may include loss of haptic feedback, longer surgical procedure times, increased cost, and decreased accessibility.
Regulatory Information
Four robotic surgical systems are currently licensed by Health Canada (Table 1).
Table 1:
Robotic Surgical Systems Licensed by Health Canada
| Robotic surgical system | Manufacturer (location) | Device class | Licence number | Date of first issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Da Vinci Si Surgical System | Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (Sunnyvale, CA) | IV | 81353 | December 3, 2009 |
| Da Vinci Xi Surgical System | Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (Sunnyvale, CA) | IV | 97378 | July 27, 2016 |
| Da Vinci X Surgical System | Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (Sunnyvale, CA) | IV | 103348 | July 26, 2019 |
| Hugo RAS System | Medtronic (Minneapolis, MN) | III | 107066 | December 3, 2021 |
Several versions of the da Vinci Surgical System have been introduced: the da Vinci Si was launched in 2009, the da Vinci Xi in 2014, and the da Vinci X in 2017. The Hugo RAS system was launched in 2021.
The various versions of the da Vinci Surgical System have been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and have received the Conformité Européenne (CE) mark in Europe. The Hugo RAS System received the CE mark in March 2022. However, at the time of writing, the Hugo RAS System has not been approved by the FDA.
Expedited Summary of the Clinical Evidence
Research Question
What are the effectiveness and safety of robotic-assisted surgery compared with open or laparoscopic surgery for the treatment of rectal cancer?
Methods
Appendix 1 provides the full methods for the expedited summary of the clinical evidence, and Appendix 2 provides our literature search strategy.
Results
Clinical Literature Search
The database search of the clinical literature yielded 247 citations published between January 1, 2019, and November 7, 2023, including grey literature searches and after duplicates were removed. We identified no additional eligible studies from other sources or from database alerts (monitored until January 15, 2024). In total, we identified 14 studies (12 systematic reviews and 1 randomized controlled trial [RCT] on robotic-assisted vs. laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery and 1 systematic review on robotic-assisted vs. open rectal cancer surgery) that met our inclusion criteria. There was a high degree of overlap for the primary RCTs included in the systematic reviews and less overlap for the included comparative observational studies. Appendix 3 provides a list of selected studies excluded after full-text review. Appendix 4, Figure A1, presents the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA)10 flow diagram for the clinical literature search. Appendix 5 provides a summary of the characteristics of the included systematic reviews (Table A1) and RCT (Table A2).
Risk of Bias in the Included Studies
We assessed the risk of bias of the included systematic reviews using AMSTAR 2 (A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, version 2)11 and found that the included systematic reviews were of low to moderate quality (Appendix 6, Table A3). Most systematic reviews did not assess publication bias or state conflicts of interest, and none included a list of excluded studies. All systematic reviews assessed the risk of bias in the included primary studies using a validated tool. In the primary comparative observational studies, risk of bias was reported as generally ranging from low to moderate; for the primary RCTs, risk of bias was reported to be higher.
We assessed the risk of bias of the included RCT using the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool for Randomized Trials12 as generally low (Appendix 6, Table A4). However, it should be noted the RCT was ended prematurely because of difficulty recruiting participants, resulting in an underpowered study with reliability concerns.
Robotic-Assisted Versus Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery
Twelve systematic reviews compared robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery.13-24 Most systematic reviews broadly included any type of rectal cancer and any type of rectal cancer surgery. Limited information was provided on the patient characteristics and surgical procedures of the primary studies. The longest follow-up for an outcome of interest was 5 years; this was for overall survival. We found no systematic reviews that evaluated positive margin rate, recovery time, or time to return to normal activity.
Overall Survival
Seven systematic reviews evaluated overall survival for robotic-assisted and laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery (Table 2).13,15-20 In general, overall survival was found to be similar between groups.
Table 2:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Overall Survival
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202313 | Not specified | 13 studies Robotic: 2,050 Laparoscopic: 2,044 |
3-year overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic RR 0.79 (95% CI: 0.65 to 0.97), P = .023 |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 14 studies Robotic: 1,578 Laparoscopic: 1,487 |
90-day mortality, laparoscopic vs. robotic All study types: OR 1.13 (95% CI: 0.30 to 4.20) RCTs only: OR 1.23 (95% CI: 0.29 to 5.18) Prospective observational studies only: OR 0.74 (95% CI: 0.03 to 18.61) |
| Liu et al, 202116 | Not specified | 5 studies Robotic: 943 Laparoscopic: 1,138 |
Mortality, robotic vs. laparoscopic RR 0.75 (95% CI: 0.34 to 1.62), P = .46 |
| Ryan et al, 202117 | Total mesorectal excision | 30 studies Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 |
Overall survival, laparoscopic vs. robotic HR 1.0 (95% CrI: 0.65 to 1.7) |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 | Resection surgery | 42 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
Survival to hospital discharge or 30-day overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic 99.6% vs. 98.8%; OR 2.10 (95% CI: 1.00 to 4.43), P = .05 1-year overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic 100% vs. 90.3%; OR 10.68 (95% CI: 0.56 to 204.84), P = .12 3-year overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic 86.3% vs. 87.1%; OR 1.02 (95% CI: 0.56 to 1.83), P = .96 5-year overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic 85.6% vs. 87.6%; OR 0.87 (95% CI: 0.61 to 1.23), P = .43 |
| Seow et al, 202319 | Total mesorectal excision | 32 studies Robotic: 479 Laparoscopic: 3,289 |
3-year overall survival, robotic vs. laparoscopic (GRADE: Low) HR 1.1 (95% CrI: 0.72 to 1.5) Perioperative mortality within 30 days, robotic vs. laparoscopic (GRADE: Low) RR 0.44 (95% CrI: 0.035 to 4.6) |
| Tang et al, 202120 | Not specified | 7 studies Robotic: 507 Laparoscopic: 516 |
Perioperative mortality, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.79 (95% CI: 0.15 to 4.12), P = .78 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI, credible interval; GRADE, Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation; HR, hazard ratio; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RR, risk ratio.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
Only 1 systematic review assessed the quality of the body of evidence reported in the included studies according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group criteria.15 This review found the certainty of evidence for 3-year overall survival to be low.
The RCT found no mortality in either the robotic or laparoscopic group within 30 days post-surgery.25
Conversion Rate
Six systematic reviews evaluated conversion rate (i.e., the rate at which a robotic-assisted or laparoscopic procedure is switched to an open procedure) (Table 3).13,15,18-21 In general, conversion rate was found to be statistically significantly lower in the robotic group.
Table 3:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Conversion Rate
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202313 | Not specified | 50 studies Robotic: 4,809 Laparoscopic: 5,636 |
Robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.34, P < 0.001 |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 17 studies Robotic: 1,760 Laparoscopic: 1,679 |
Laparoscopic vs. robotic All study types: OR 3.13 (95% CI: 1.87 to 5.21) RCTs only: OR 2.35 (95% CI: 1.46 to 3.77) Prospective observational studies only: OR 3.36 (95% CI: 1.11 to 10.18) |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 | Resection surgery | 42 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
Robotic vs. laparoscopic 2.6% vs. 7.3% OR 0.35 (95% CI: 0.26 to 0.46), P < .001 |
| Seow et al, 202319 | Total mesorectal excision | 32 studies Robotic: 479 Laparoscopic: 3,289 |
Laparoscopic vs. robotic (GRADE: Low) RR 0.23 (95% CrI: 0.034 to 0.70) |
| Tang et al, 202120 | Not specified | 7 studies Robotic: 507 Laparoscopic: 516 |
Robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.61 (95% CI: 0.35 to 1.07), P = .08 |
| Yao et al, 202326 | Surgeries for mid- to low rectal cancer | 8 studies Robotic: 1,350 Laparoscopic: 1330 |
Robotic vs. laparoscopic MD 0.49 (95% CI 0.29 to 0.84), P = .009 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI, credible interval; GRADE, Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RR, risk ratio.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
The RCT found conversion rate to be similar between the robotic and laparoscopic groups (0.7% vs. 1.4%, respectively, P = .534).25
Reoperation Rate
Eight systematic reviews13,15-18,20-22 evaluated reoperation rate, but only 113 noted the time period for reoperation (Table 4). In general, reoperation rate was found to be similar between the robotic and laparoscopic groups.
Table 4:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Reoperation Rate
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202313 | Not specified | 50 studies Robotic: 4,809 Laparoscopic: 5,636 |
90-day reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.93 (95% CI: 0.69 to 1.26), P = .595 |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 12 studies Robotic: 1,324 Laparoscopic: 1,290 |
Reoperation rate, laparoscopic vs. robotic All study types: OR 1.69 (95% CI: 1.10 to 2.62) RCTs only: OR 1.82 (95% CI: 1.10 to 3.02) Prospective observational studies only: OR 1.28 (95% CI: 0.46 to 3.51) |
| Liu et al, 202116 | Not specified | 5 studies Robotic: 478 Laparoscopic: 541 |
Reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic RR 0.85 (95% CI: 0.46 to 1.54), P = .58 |
| Ryan et al, 202117 | Total mesorectal excision | 30 studies Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 |
Reoperation rate, laparoscopic vs. robotic RR 0.32 (95% CrI: 0.039 to 1.6) |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 | Resection surgery | 42 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
Reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic 6.3% vs. 7.1%; OR 0.87 (95% CI: 0.61 to 1.25), P = .46 |
| Tang et al, 202120 | Not specified | 7 studies Robotic: 507 Laparoscopic: 516 |
Unscheduled reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.91 (95% CI: 0.26 to 3.20), P = .89 |
| Wang et al, 202022 | Not specified | 17 studies Robotic: 1,554 Laparoscopic: 1,639 |
Reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.53 (95% CI: 0.27 to 1.04), P =.07 |
| Yao et al, 202321 | Surgery for mid- to low rectal cancer | 8 studies Robotic: 1,350 Laparoscopic: 1,330 |
Reoperation rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic MD 0.71 (95% CI: 0.40 to 1.25), P = .23 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI: credible interval; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RR, risk ratio.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
Transfusion Rate and Estimated Blood Loss
Only 2 systematic reviews evaluated transfusion rate, which was found to be similar between groups (Table 5).17,18 Seven systematic reviews evaluated estimated blood loss and found similar or less estimated blood loss in the robotic group.13,15,18,20-23 Limited information was provided on the surgical techniques used in the included studies.
Table 5:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Transfusion Rate and Estimated Blood Loss
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202313 | Not specified | 50 studies Robotic: 4,809 Laparoscopic: 5,636 |
Estimated blood loss (mL), robotic vs. laparoscopic SMD −0.12 (95% CI: −0.32 to 0.43), P < .001 |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 9 studies Robotic: 1,196 Laparoscopic: 1,347 |
Estimated blood loss (mL), laparoscopic vs. robotic All study types: MD 20.47 (95% CI: 7.57 to 33.36) RCTs only: MD 18.48 (95% CI: 5.51 to 31.45) Prospective observational studies only: MD 390.66 (95% CI: −302.59 to 1083.91) |
| Ryan et al, 202117 | Total mesorectal excision | 30 studies Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 |
Tranfusion rate, laparoscopic vs. robotic RR 0.87 (95% CrI: 0.28 to 2.7) |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 | Resection surgery | 42 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
Transfusion rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic 3.7% vs. 2.1% Estimated blood loss (mL), robotic vs. laparoscopic 224 ± 327.6 vs. 210.7 ± 305.2 MD −0.94 (95% CI: −30.11 to 28.22), P < .001 |
| Tang et al, 202120 | Not specified | 7 studies Robotic: 507 Laparoscopic: 516 |
Bleeding, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.89 (95% CI: 0.27 to 2.97), P = .85 |
| Wang et al, 202022 | Not specified | 17 studies Robotic: 1,554 Laparoscopic: 1,639 |
Estimated blood loss (mL), robotic vs. laparoscopic MD −0.08 (95% CI −0.31, 0.15), P = < .0001 |
| Yao et al, 202321 | Surgeries for mid- to low rectal cancer | 8 studies Robotic: 1,350 Laparoscopic: 1,330 |
Estimated blood loss (mL), robotic vs. laparoscopic MD −15.72 (95% CI: −23.18 to − 8.26), P < .0001 |
| Zhang et al, 202123 | Intersphincteric resection | 5 studies Robotic: 273 Laparoscopic: 237 |
Estimated blood loss (mL), robotic vs. laparoscopic MD −23.31 (95% CI: −41.98 to −4.64), P = .01 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI, credible interval; MD, mean difference; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized controlled trial;
RR, risk ratio; SMD, standardized mean difference.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
The RCT found estimated blood loss to be similar between the robotic and laparoscopic groups (mean 118.0 ± 151.5 mL vs. 112.3 ± 162.0 mL, respectively, P = .756).25
Length of Stay and Readmission Rate
Seven systematic reviews reported on length of stay, and all found that length of stay was significantly shorter for the robotic approach (Table 6).16-19,21-23 None of the systematic reviews mentioned length of stay for readmission, but four reported on readmission rate,16,18,21,22 which was found to be similar between groups.
Table 6:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Length of Stay and Readmission Rate
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202313 | Not specified | 50 studies Robotic: 4,809 Laparoscopic: 5,636 |
Length of stay (days), robotic vs. laparoscopic SMD 0.22 (95% CI: 0.33 to 0.11), P < 0.001 |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 18 studies Robotic: 1,937 Laparoscopic: 3,008 |
Length of stay (days), laparoscopic vs. robotic (GRADE: Low) All study types: MD 0.00 (95% CI: −0.55 to 0.54) RCTs only: MD 0.26 (95% CI: −0.33 to 0.86) Prospective observational studies only: MD −1.18 (95% CI: −2.86 to 0.50) |
| Liu et al, 202116 | Not specified | 4 studies Robotic: 2,730 Laparoscopic: 5,502 |
Readmisison rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic RR 1.17 (95% CI: 0.75 to 1.83), P = .48 |
| Ryan et al, 202117 | Total mesorectal excision | 30 studies Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 |
Length of stay (days), laparoscopic vs. robotic MD 0.16 (95% CrI: −1.5 to 1.9) |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 | Resection surgery | 42 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
Length of stay (days), robotic vs. laparoscopic 8.0 ± 5.3 vs. 9.5 ± 10.0; MD −2.01 (95% CI: −2.90 to −1.11), P < .001 Readmission rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic Robotic vs. laparoscopic: 10.3% vs. 9.8%; OR 1.14 (95% CI: 0.82 to 1.60), P = .44 |
| Seow et al, 202319 | Total mesorectal excision | 32 studies Robotic: 479 Laparoscopic: 3,289 |
Length of stay (days), robotic vs. laparoscopic and open (GRADE: Low) Laparoscopic: MD 1.7 (95% CrI: − 1.1 to 4.4) Open: MD 3.3 (95% CrI: 0.12 to 6.0) |
| Wang et al, 20 2022 | Not specified | 17 studies Robotic: 1,554 Laparoscopic: 1,639 |
Readmission rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic OR 0.80 (95% CI: 0.48 to 1.34), P = .40 |
| Yao et al, 202321 | Surgeries for mid- to low rectal cancer | 8 studies Robotic: 1,350 Laparoscopic: 1,330 |
Length of stay (days), robotic vs. laparoscopic MD − 0.97 (95% CI: − 1.11 to − 0.83), P < .00001 Readmission rate, robotic vs. laparoscopic MD 0.95 (95% CI: 0.56 to 1.63), P = .86 |
| Zhang et al, 202123 | Intersphincteric resection | 5 studies Robotic: 273 Laparoscopic: 237 |
Length of stay (days), robotic vs. laparoscopic MD −1.52 (95% CI: −2.10 to −0.94), P < .00001 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI, credible interval; GRADE, Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation; MD, mean difference; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RR, risk ratio; SMD, standardized mean difference.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
The RCT found length of stay to be similar between the robotic and laparoscopic groups (median [interquartile range] 8 [7–10] vs. 8 [6–10], respectively, P = .895).25
Health-Related Quality of Life and Patient Functioning
Four systematic reviews evaluated quality of life (Table 7).14,17,24,26 Yang and Zhou evaluated urinary and sexual function using the International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), the International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF), and the Female Sexual Function Index (FSFI).26 The IPSS is used to measure the severity of lower urinary tract symptoms, with higher scores indicating more severe symptoms. The IIEF assesses erectile function over the preceding four weeks, with higher scores indicating mild or no erectile dysfunction. The FSFI assesses female sexual function, with higher scores indicating greater levels of sexual functioning. Yang and Zhou found significantly improved urinary and sexual function among those in the robotic group.26 However, Ryan et al found no significant difference between groups for sexual dysfunction.17
Table 7:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic Rectal Cancer Surgery—Health-Related Quality of Life and Patient Functioning
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Resultsa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202214 | Not specified | 14 studies Robotic: 462 Laparoscopic: 470 |
Male sexual function, robotic vs. laparoscopic (11 studies)b
|
Female sexual function, robotic vs. laparoscopic (3 studies)c
|
|||
Overall sexual function, robotic vs. laparoscopic (2 studies)d
|
|||
Urinary function, robotic vs. laparoscopic (11 studies)e
|
|||
Bowel function, robotic vs. laparoscopic (3 studies)g
|
|||
Quality of life, robotic vs. laparoscopic (3 studies)g
|
|||
| Martins et al, 202324 | Not specified | 7 studies Robotic: 429 Laparoscopic: 440 |
Global EORTC QLQ-C30 score, robotic vs. laparoscopic MD −0.43 (95% CI: −3.49 to 2.62) EORTC QLQ-C30 functioning scale scores, robotic vs. laparoscopic Physical functioning: MD 1.92 (95% CI: 0.97 to 2.87) Role functioning: MD −3.99 (95% CI: −8.19 to 0.21) Emotional functioning: MD 1.22 (95% CI: −0.58 to 3.01) Cognitive functioning: MD 0.18 (95% CI: −1.04 to 1.40) EORTC QLQ-C30 symptom scale scores, robotic vs. laparoscopic Fatigue: MD −0.81 (95% CI: −4.13 to 2.52) Nausea and vomiting: MD −0.58 (95% CI: −1.33 to 0.16) Generalized pain: MD −0.58 (95% CI: −3.63 to 2.47) |
| Ryan et al, 202117 | Total mesorectal excision | 30 studies Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 |
Sexual dysfunction, robotic vs. laparoscopic RR 0.72 (95% CrI: 0.39 to 1.5) |
| Yang and Zhou, 202326 | Not specified | 11 studies Robotic: 790 Laparoscopic: 888 |
Change in IPSS score from baseline, robotic vs. laparoscopic 3 mo: WMD −1.21 (95% CI: − 1.8 to −0.62) 6 mo: WMD − 1.13 (95% CI: −1.74 to − 0.52) 12 mo: WMD −0.93 (95% CI: −1.59 to − 0.26) Change in IIEF score from baseline, robotic vs. laparoscopic 3 mo: WMD 3.36 (95% CI: 1.28 to 5.44) Change in FSFI score from baseline, robotic vs. laparoscopic 3 mo: WMD 1.31 (95% CI: 0.87 to 1.76) 6 mo: WMD 2.36 (95% CI: 1.93 to 2.79) 12 mo: WMD 1.67 (95% CI: 0.41 to 2.93) |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; CrI, credible interval; EORTC QLQ-C30, European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire; FSFI, Female Sexual Function Index; IIEF, International Index of Erectile Function; IPSS, International Prostate Symptom Score; MD, mean difference; OR, odds ratio; RR, risk ratio; WMD, weighted mean difference.
P-values presented only when reported in the included studies.
8 studies used IIEF or a modified IIEF; 3 studies used other questionnaires.
All 3 studies used FSFI or a modified FSFI.
1 study used IIEF and FSFI; the other study used another questionnaire.
8 studies used IPSS or a modified IPSS; 3 studies used other questionnaires.
1 study used the Wexner score (also known as the Cleveland Clinic Fecal Incontinence Severity Scoring System [CCIS]) to assess fecal incontinence (a higher score indicates a greater level of incontinence); 2 studies used other questionnaires.
2 studies used the EORTC QLQ-C30; 1 study used other questionnaires.
Martins et al24 specifically evaluated quality of life using the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30), which assesses the quality of life of people with cancer. A higher score represents a higher response level (i.e., higher global quality of life, higher level of functioning, higher level of symptoms). The authors reported that physical functioning was superior among those in the robotic group but found no significant difference between groups in global quality of life, nausea and vomiting, pain, fatigue, or psychosocial subdomains (i.e., emotional, cognitive, role, and social functioning).
Flynn et al14 found that those in the robotic group reported either similar or slightly better scores for sexual function, urinary function, and some dimensions of quality of life compared with those in the laparoscopic group but found no significant difference for bowel function between groups. In contrast to the other systematic reviews, the primary studies included by Flynn et al used a variety of questionnaires to assess outcomes.
In the RCT, at 6 months post-surgery, global health status was found to be significantly impaired compared with the baseline period for both groups, but both groups had recovered by 12 months postsurgery.25
In the RCT over the course of 24 months, no significant differences were found between groups for global health status (EORTC QLQ-C30 score; P = .518), anal sphincter function (Wexner score; P = .450), female sexual score (FSFI score; P = .354), or urinary function (IPSS score; P = .404).25 Also over 24 months, male sexual function was not significantly different between groups compared with baseline (IIEF-5 score; P = .190). However, IIEF-5 scores at 24 months were significantly higher for the robotic group than for the laparoscopic group (8.1 vs. 4.6, P = .010). Also at 24 months, anal sphincter function scores remained significantly higher than at baseline for both groups (robotic: 3.3 vs. 8.4, P < .001; laparoscopic: 3.6 vs. 7.7, P < .001), indicating that normal function had not recovered by 24 months in either group.
Neither the included systematic reviews14,17,24,26 nor the RCT25 specifically evaluated low anterior resection syndrome (a collection of symptoms or issues people may experience after resection or removal of the rectum, including frequency, urgency, incontinence, and constipation).
Robotic-Assisted Versus Open Rectal Cancer Surgery
One systematic review by Khajeh et al,15 which included 4 studies (2 RCTs and 2 prospective observational studies), compared robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery (N = 265) with open rectal cancer surgery (N = 982). This systematic review reported a subgroup analysis based on study design (RCTs vs. prospective observational studies) but reported only on overall survival, estimated blood loss, and length of stay.
Overall Survival
Overall survival was reported only in 1 primary study (N, robotic: 65; N, open: 55) included in the systematic review by Khajeh et al.15 One-year overall survival for both groups was 98%. At 3 years, overall survival was 93% for those in the open group and 87% for those in the robotic group. Confidence intervals, standard errors, and P-values were not reported for either time period. Perioperative mortality was not reported.
Estimated Blood Loss
Transfusion rate was not reported.15 However, for all study types, estimated blood loss was found to be statistically significantly lower in the robotic group compared with the open group (Table 8).
Table 8:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Open Rectal Cancer Surgery—Estimated Blood Loss
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 1 study Robotic: 315 Open: 268 |
All study types: MD 156.63 (95% CI: 62.36 to 250.91), P = .001 RCTs only: MD 161.36 (95% CI: 8.61 to 314.11), P < .00001 Prospective observational studies only: MD 149.37 (95% CI: 5.99 to 292.74), P < .00001 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; MD, mean difference; RCT, randomized controlled trial.
Length of Stay
For all study types, length of stay was found to be statistically significantly lower in the robotic group (Table 9).15
Table 9:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Open Rectal Cancer Surgery—Length of Stay
| Author, year | Procedure | N, included studies N, total participants |
Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Khajeh et al, 202315 | Not specified | 1 study Robotic: 315 Open: 268 |
All study types: MD 2.51 (95% CI: 0.35 to 4.67), P = .02 RCTs only: MD 3.21 (95% CI: −1.19 to 7.61), P < .00001 Prospective observational studies only: MD 2.19 (95% CI: 1.20 to 3.18), P < .0001 |
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; MD, mean difference; RCT, randomized controlled trial.
Ongoing Studies
We found 3 ongoing studies (2 prospective observational studies and 1 RCT) that have potential relevance to our research question (Appendix 7, Table A5).
Discussion
Our expedited summary of the clinical evidence summarizes the most recent systematic reviews and RCTs on robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery compared with laparoscopic or open rectal cancer surgery. However, our findings are limited to what was reported in the systematic reviews. Twelve of the 13 included systematic reviews compared robotic-assisted with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery; just 1 systematic review compared robotic-assisted with open rectal cancer surgery. In the primary comparative observational studies, risk of bias was reported as generally ranging from low to moderate; for the primary RCTs, risk of bias was reported to be higher. There was a high degree of overlap for the primary RCTs included in the systematic reviews and less overlap for the included comparative observational studies. Based on the findings of the included systematic reviews, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar or improved outcomes compared with the laparoscopic approach and may result in reduced blood loss and shorter length of stay compared with the open approach.
However, the included RCT found no significant differences in outcomes between the robotic and laparoscopic groups, but these findings should be interpreted with caution because the study was underpowered owing to difficulty recruiting participants, which negatively affects the reliability of the results.
Potential differences in patient population, intervention, comparator, and outcomes between studies may limit comparability and generalizability. Most systematic reviews did not comment on the patient characteristics of the primary studies or whether there may have been differences between groups. Clinical heterogeneity may exist between primary studies (e.g., cancer severity, patient comorbidities) and thus may have affected the appropriateness of meta-analysis.
In addition, none of the included systematic reviews specifically evaluated potential subpopulations of interest, particularly those with a narrow pelvis and those with a high body mass index (BMI). Narrow pelvis and high BMI may pose surgical challenges, and other studies have suggested that the robotic-assisted approach may benefit these subpopulations. For example, a systematic review on robotic-assisted colorectal cancer resection for people with obesity found a higher rate of conversion to laparotomy (open abdominal surgery) for those with obesity compared with those without obesity (odds ratio [OR] 1.99 [95% CI: 1.54 to 2.56], P < .001).27 Blood loss and length of stay were found not to be significantly different between those with and without obesity.
Most included systematic reviews did not report the type of surgical system used within the primary studies. Although the most widely used robotic surgical system is the da Vinci Surgical System, there are 3 versions of this system currently in use (the da Vinci Si, X, and Xi), and other systems are also used in Ontario (i.e., the Hugo RAS System) and available internationally.
Most included systematic reviews also broadly included rectal cancer surgery and included different surgical techniques or procedures (e.g., anterior resection, total mesorectal excision).
The included systematic reviews did not assess the impact of surgeons’ experience with robotic or laparoscopic surgical approaches. However, other studies have found that conversion and complication rates may be lower for the robotic approach compared with the laparoscopic approach for experienced laparoscopic surgeons.28 There may also be a short learning curve as surgeons transition from the laparoscopic to the robotic approach.29
The time point at which reoperation and readmission rates were assessed was unclear in some of the included systematic reviews. Not all primary studies used the outcome definition or score or consistently reported results from the same time point, which made meta-analysis difficult within the systematic reviews. Meta-analysis was also sometimes conducted despite high statistical heterogeneity, and only 2 systematic reviews15 evaluated the certainty of the evidence using the GRADE criteria.
We did not find any systematic reviews that assessed the impact of the uptake of robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery on the number of open procedures performed. However, a cross-sectional study from the United States found that the proportion of rectal cancer surgeries performed using the robotic approach increased from 15% (95% CI: 13% to 16%) in 2018 to 22% (95% CI: 20% to 24%) in 2020.30
Conclusions
We examined the peer-reviewed published and grey literature to determine what is known about the effectiveness and safety of robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery compared with the laparoscopic and open approaches and found the following.
We identified 12 systematic reviews and 1 RCT that compared robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery
-
Compared with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in the following:
-
∘
Similar overall survival, conversion rate, transfusion rate, and readmission rate
-
∘
Reduced blood loss
-
∘
Shorter length of stay
-
∘
Improved health-related quality of life or patient functioning
-
∘
We identified 1 systematic review comparing robotic-assisted versus open rectal cancer surgery
-
Compared with open rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in the following:
-
∘
Similar overall survival
-
∘
Reduced blood loss
-
∘
Shorter length of stay
-
∘
None the included systematic reviews specifically evaluated potential subpopulations of interest (e.g., those with a narrow pelvis, those with a high body mass index)
None of the included systematic reviews evaluated positive margin rate, recovery time, or time to return to normal activity
Acknowledgments
This report was developed by a multidisciplinary team from Ontario Health. The clinical epidemiologist was Myra Wang, the primary medical librarian was Genevieve Forsyth, and the secondary medical librarian was Corinne Holubowich.
The medical editor was Kara Cowan. Others involved in the development and production of this report were Emma Tolmie, Claude Soulodre, Caroline Higgins, Susan Harrison, Sarah McDowell, Andrée Mitchell, and Nancy Sikich.
Citation
Ontario Health. Robotic-assisted surgery for rectal cancer: an expedited summary of the clinical evidence. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser [Internet]. 2024 Apr;24(3):1-45. Available from: https://hqontario.ca/Portals/0/documents/evidence/reports/robotic-assisted-surgery-for-rectal-cancer.pdf
Abbreviations
- AMSTAR 2:
A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, version 2
- BMI:
body mass index
- CE:
Conformité Européenne
- CI:
confidence interval
- CrI:
credible interval
- CT:
computed tomography
- EORTC QLQ-C30:
European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire
- FDA:
US Food and Drug Administration
- FSFI:
Female Sexual Function Index
- GRADE:
Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation
- HR:
hazard ratio
- IIEF:
International Index of Erectile Function
- IPSS:
International Prostate Symptom Score
- MD:
mean difference
- MRI:
magnetic resonance imaging
- NR:
not reported
- OR:
odds ratio
- PET:
positron emission tomography
- PRISMA:
Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses
- RCT:
randomized controlled trial
- RR:
risk ratio
- SMD:
standardized mean difference
- WMD:
weighted mean difference
Appendices
Appendix 1: Evidence Methods
Clinical Literature Search
We performed a clinical literature search on November 7, 2023, to retrieve studies published from January 1, 2019, until the search date. We focused on studies published within the last 5 years to capture the most recent literature on the topic. We used the Ovid interface in the following databases: MEDLINE, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.
A medical librarian developed the search strategies using controlled vocabulary (e.g., Medical Subject Headings) and relevant keywords. Methodological filters were used to limit retrieval to systematic reviews, meta-analyses, health technology assessments, and randomized controlled trials. The final search strategy was peer-reviewed using the PRESS Checklist.31
We created database auto-alerts in MEDLINE and monitored them until January 15, 2024. We also performed a targeted grey literature search of the International HTA Database, the websites of health technology assessment organizations and regulatory agencies, and clinical trial and systematic review registries following a standard list of sites developed internally. See Appendix 2 for our literature search strategy, including all search terms.
Eligibility Criteria
Studies
Inclusion Criteria
English-language full-text publications
Studies published between January 1, 2019, and November 7, 2023
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses with a literature search date of 2020 or later, that follow PRISMA reporting guidelines, and that report a risk-of-bias assessment for all included primary studies
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) not included in any included systematic reviews or meta-analyses
Exclusion Criteria
Animal and in vitro studies
Nonsystematic reviews, narrative reviews, abstracts, editorials, letters, case reports, and commentaries
Participants
Inclusion Criteria
-
Adults with rectal cancer
-
∘
Subpopulations of interest: elevated body mass index (BMI), narrow male pelvis, very low rectal cancer, rectal sigmoid cancer, distal rectal cancer, locally advanced rectal cancer
-
∘
Exclusion Criteria
Adults with colorectal cancer
Interventions
Inclusion Criteria
Robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery (e.g., anterior resection, abdominal perineal resection, proctectomy, coloanal or intracorporeal anastomosis, total or transanal mesorectal excision, intersphincteric resection)
Exclusion Criteria
Robotic-assisted surgery for other indications
Comparators
Inclusion Criteria
Rectal cancer surgery using an open or laparoscopic approach
Exclusion Criteria
Comparisons of robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery using different surgical systems or surgical techniques
Outcome Measures
Overall survival
Positive margin rate
Conversion rate
Reoperation rate
Transfusion rate and estimated blood loss
Length of stay (including readmission and follow-up visits)
Recovery time or time to return to normal activity
Health-related quality of life (e.g., experience of low anterior resection syndrome, patient functioning)
Impact of uptake of robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery on the number of open rectal cancer surgeries performed
Literature Screening
A single reviewer screened titles and abstracts using Covidence32 and obtained the full texts of studies that appeared eligible for review according to the inclusion criteria. The same reviewer then examined the full-text articles and selected studies eligible for inclusion. The reviewer also examined reference lists for any additional relevant studies not identified through the search.
Data Extraction
We extracted relevant data on study characteristics and risk-of-bias items using a data form to collect information on the following:
Source (e.g., citation information, study type)
Methods (e.g., study design, study duration and years, participant allocation, allocation sequence concealment, blinding, reporting of missing data, reporting of outcomes, whether the study compared two or more groups)
Outcomes (e.g., outcomes measured, number of participants for each outcome, number of participants missing for each outcome, outcome definition and source of information, unit of measurement, upper and lower limits [for scales], time points at which the outcomes were assessed)
Critical Appraisal of Evidence
We assessed risk of bias using AMSTAR 2 (A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, version 2)11 for systematic reviews and the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool for Randomized Trials, version 1,12 for the included RCT (Appendix 6).
We reported the quality of the body of evidence as evaluated in the included systematic reviews according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group criteria33 if it was evaluated. The body of evidence was assessed based on the following considerations: risk of bias, inconsistency, indirectness, imprecision, and publication bias. The overall rating reflects the systematic review authors’ assessment of the certainty of the evidence.
Appendix 2: Literature Search Strategy
Literature Search
- Search date:
November 7, 2023
- Databases searched:
Ovid MEDLINE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials
- Database segments:
EBM Reviews - Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials <September 2023> EBM Reviews - Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews <2005 to November 1, 2023> Ovid MEDLINE(R) ALL <1946 to November 06, 2023>
Search strategy:
-
1
Robotic Surgical Procedures/17447
-
2
Surgery, Computer-Assisted/21377
-
3
Video-Assisted Surgery/2483
-
4
Robotics/29123
-
5
(((procedur* or surg* or techni* or excis*) adj5 (robot* or comput* assist*)) or (robot* adj3 assist*) or remote* surg*).ti, ab, kf. 45154
-
6
(da vinci* or davinci or hugo* or versius* or ottava*).ti, ab, kf. 6645
-
7
or/1-6 85005
-
8
Rectal Neoplasms/51029
-
9
((rectal* or rectum* or rectosigmoid* or recto sigmoid* or rectalsigmoid*) adj3 (cancer* or neoplas* or tumo?r or carcinoma* or adenocarcinoma* or carcinogen* or malignan* or metasta* or oncolog*)).ti, ab, kf. 49580
-
10
Proctectomy/1619
-
11
(proctectom* or anterior resection* or APR or TME or ((abdominoperineal* or abdomino perineal* or abdominal* perineal* or intersphincteric* or inter* sphincteric* or rectum* or rectal* or mesorectal* or meso rectal* or rectosigmoid* or recto sigmoid* or rectalsigmoid*) adj3 (surg* or operat* or procedure* or excision* or resection* or re section* or recision* or dissection* or anastomo*))).ti, ab, kf. 49418
-
12
or/8-11 97648
-
13
7 and 12 2053
-
14
(robot* adj3 (anterior resection* or proctectom* or APR or TME or ((abdominoperineal* or abdomino perineal* or abdominal perineal* or intersphincteric* or inter* sphincteric* or rectum* or rectal* or mesorectal* or meso rectal* or rectosigmoid* or recto sigmoid* or rectalsigmoid*) adj3 (surg* or procedure* or operat* or excision* or resection* or re section* or recision* or dissection* or anastomo*)))).ti, ab, kf. 1054
-
15
13 or 14 2084
-
16
(Systematic Reviews or Meta Analysis).pt. 189330
-
17
Systematic Review/or Systematic Reviews as Topic/or Meta-Analysis/or exp Meta-Analysis as Topic/or exp Technology Assessment, Biomedical/370596
-
18
((systematic* or methodologic*) adj3 (review* or overview*)).ti, ab, kf. 344301
-
19
(meta analy* or metaanaly* or met analy* or metanaly* or meta review* or metareview* or health technolog* assess* or HTA or HTAs or (technolog* adj (assessment* or overview* or appraisal*))).ti, ab, kf. 315226
-
20
(evidence adj2 (review* or overview* or synthes#s)).ti, ab, kf. 50289
-
21
(review of reviews or overview of reviews).ti, ab, kf. 1267
-
22
umbrella review*.ti, ab, kf. 1680
-
23
GRADE Approach/116
-
24
((pool* adj3 analy*) or published studies or published literature or hand search* or handsearch* or manual search* or ((database* or systematic*) adj2 search*) or reference list* or bibliograph* or relevant journals or data synthes* or data extraction* or data abstraction*).ti, ab, kf. 307364
-
25
(medline or pubmed or medlars or embase or cinahl or web of science or ovid or ebsco* or scopus).ab. 359179
-
26
cochrane.ti, ab, kf. 154578
-
27
(meta regress* or metaregress*).ti, ab, kf. 15670
-
28
(((integrative or collaborative or quantitative) adj3 (review* or overview* or synthes*)) or (research adj3 overview*)).ti, ab, kf. 19714
-
29
(cochrane or (health adj2 technology assessment) or evidence report or systematic review*).jw. 39764
-
30
((comparative adj3 (efficacy or effectiveness)) or relative effectiveness or ((indirect or indirect treatment or mixed-treatment) adj comparison*)).ti, ab, kf. 33427
-
31
or/16-30 837857
-
32
15 and 31 213
-
33
15 use coch 1
-
34
32 use medall, cctr 212
-
35
or/33-34 213
-
36
exp Animals/not Humans/5171182
-
37
35 not 36 213
-
38
limit 37 to english language 204
-
39
limit 38 to yr=“2019 -Current” 122
-
40
Clinical Trials as Topic/238361
-
41
controlled clinical trials as topic/6087
-
42
exp Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic/209627
-
43
controlled clinical trial.pt. 95446
-
44
randomized controlled trial.pt. 602616
-
45
Pragmatic Clinical Trial.pt. 2268
-
46
Random Allocation/130401
-
47
Single-Blind Method/57690
-
48
Double-Blind Method/331742
-
49
Placebos/61413
-
50
trial.ti. 709067
-
51
(random* or sham or placebo* or RCT*1).ti, ab, kf. 2934182
-
52
((singl* or doubl*) adj (blind* or dumm* or mask*)).ti, ab, kf. 519375
-
53
((tripl* or trebl*) adj (blind* or dumm* or mask*)).ti, ab, kf. 4440
-
54
or/40-53 3539353
-
55
15 and 54 379
-
56
15 use cctr 176
-
57
55 use medall, coch 255
-
58
or/56-57 431
-
59
exp Animals/not Humans/5171182
-
60
58 not 59 431
-
61
limit 60 to english language 405
-
62
limit 61 to yr=“2019 -Current” 199
-
63
39 or 62 272
-
64
63 use medall 196
-
65
63 use cctr 75
-
66
63 use coch 1
-
67
remove duplicates from 63 251
Grey Literature Search
Performed: November 7-9, 2023
Websites searched:
Alberta Health Evidence Reviews, Alberta Health Services, BC Health Technology Assessments, Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health (CADTH), Institut national d'excellence en santé et en services sociaux (INESSS), Institute of Health Economics (IHE), Ontario Health Technology Assessment Committee (OHTAC), McGill University Health Centre Health Technology Assessment Unit, Centre Hospitalier de l'Universite de Quebec-Universite Laval, Contextualized Health Research Synthesis Program of Newfoundland (CHRSP), Health Canada Medical Device Database, Health Technology Assessment Database, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Evidence-based Practice Centers, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Technology Assessments, U.S. Dept of Veteran Affairs, Institute for Clinical and Economic Review, Oregon Health Authority, Washington State Health Care Authority Health Technology Assessment Findings, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), NHS England, Healthcare Improvement Scotland, and Health Technology Wales.
robot, robot-assisted surgery, robotic assisted surgery, robotics, rectal, rectal cancer, rectal neoplasms, mesorectal, proctectomy, proctectomies, da vinci, davinci, rectale, proctectomie, chirurgie robotique
Clinical results (included in PRISMA): 1
Appendix 3: Selected Excluded Studies
For transparency, we provide a list of studies that met our literature search criteria (published between January 1, 2019, and November 7, 2023) but had a literature search date of 2019 or earlier and were thus excluded:
Bilgin IA, Bas M, Aytac E, Benlice C, Esen E, Kirbiyik E, et al. Operative and long-term oncological outcomes in patients undergoing robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer. Int J Med Robot. 2020; 16(6):1–10.
Butterworth JW, Butterworth WA, Meyer J, Giacobino C, Buchs N, Ris F, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of robotic-assisted transabdominal total mesorectal excision and transanal total mesorectal excision: which approach offers optimal short-term outcomes for mid-to-low rectal adenocarcinoma? Tech Coloproctol. 2021; 25(11):1183–98.
Conticchio M, Papagni V, Notarnicola M, Delvecchio A, Riccelli U, Ammendola M, et al. Laparoscopic vs. open mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: are these approaches still comparable? A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2020; 15(7):e0235887.
Eltair M, Hajibandeh S, Hajibandeh S, Nuno A, Abdullah KH, Alkaili-Alyamani A, et al. Meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis of robotic versus laparoscopic total mesorectal excision in management of rectal cancer. Int J Colorectal Dis. 2020; 35(8):1423–38.
Gavriilidis P, Wheeler J, Spinelli A, de'Angelis N, Simopoulos C, Di Saverio S. Robotic vs laparoscopic total mesorectal excision for rectal cancers: has a paradigm change occurred? A systematic review by updated meta-analysis. Colorectal Dis. 2020; 22(11):1506–17.
Grass JK, Chen CC, Melling N, Lingala B, Kemper M, Scognamiglio P, et al. Robotic rectal resection preserves anorectal function: systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Med Robot. 2021; 17(6):e2329.
Grass JK, Perez DR, Izbicki JR, Reeh M. Systematic review analysis of robotic and transanal approaches in TME surgery - a systematic review of the current literature in regard to challenges in rectal cancer surgery. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2019; 45(4):498–509.
Guo Y, Guo Y, Luo Y, Song X, Zhao H, Li L. Comparison of pathologic outcomes of robotic and open resections for rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2021; 16(1):e0245154.
Han C, Yan P, Jing W, Li M, Du B, Si M, et al. Clinical, pathological, and oncologic outcomes of robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic proctectomy for rectal cancer: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies. Asian J Surg. 2020; 43(9):880–90.
Hoshino N, Sakamoto T, Hida K, Sakai Y. Robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: an overview of systematic reviews with quality assessment of current evidence. Surg Today. 2019; 49(7):556–70.
Hoshino N, Sakamoto T, Hida K, Takahashi Y, Okada H, Obama K, et al. Difference in surgical outcomes of rectal cancer by study design: meta-analyses of randomized clinical trials, case-matched studies, and cohort studies. BJS Open. 2021; 5(2):zraa067.
Huang YJ, Kang YN, Huang YM, Wu AT, Wang W, Wei PL. Effects of laparoscopic vs robotic-assisted mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: an update systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Asian J Surg. 2019; 42(6):657–66.
Kowalewski KF, Seifert L, Ali S, Schmidt MW, Seide S, Haney C, et al. Functional outcomes after laparoscopic versus robotic-assisted rectal resection: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Surg Endosc. 2021; 35(1):81–95.
Lam J, Tam MS, Retting RL, McLemore EC. Robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a comprehensive review of oncological outcomes. Perm J. 2021; 25(12):14.
Liao G, Zhao Z, Deng H, Li X. Comparison of pathological outcomes between robotic rectal cancer surgery and laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: a meta-analysis based on seven randomized controlled trials. Int J Med Robot. 2019; 15(5):e2027.
Liu C, Li X, Wang Q. Postoperative complications observed with robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for the treatment of rectal cancer: an updated meta-analysis of recently published studies. Medicine. 2021; 100(36):e27158.
Milone M, Manigrasso M, Velotti N, Torino S, Vozza A, Sarnelli G, et al. Completeness of total mesorectum excision of laparoscopic versus robotic surgery: a review with a meta-analysis. Int J Colorectal Dis. 2019; 34(6):983–91.
Muaddi H, Hafid ME, Choi WJ, Lillie E, de Mestral C, Nathens A, et al. Clinical outcomes of robotic surgery compared to conventional surgical approaches (laparoscopic or open): a systematic overview of reviews. Ann Surg. 2021; 273(3):467–73.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Colorectal cancer (update): [C3] optimal surgical technique for rectal cancer [Internet]. London: The Institute; 2020. [cited 2024 Jan 12]. Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng151/evidence/c3-optimal-surgical-technique-for-rectal-cancer-pdf-7029391218
Phan K, Kahlaee HR, Kim SH, Toh JWT. Laparoscopic vs. robotic rectal cancer surgery and the effect on conversion rates: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity-score-matched studies. Tech Coloproctol. 2019; 23(3):221–30.
Qiu H, Yu D, Ye S, Shan R, Ai J, Shi J. Long-term oncological outcomes in robotic versus laparoscopic approach for rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Surg. 2020; 80:225–30.
Rausa E, Bianco F, Kelly ME, Aiolfi A, Petrelli F, Bonitta G, et al. Systemic review and network meta-analysis comparing minimal surgical techniques for rectal cancer: quality of total mesorectum excision, pathological, surgical, and oncological outcomes. J Surg Oncol. 2019; 119(7):987–98.
Rubinkiewicz M, Witowski J, Zbroja K, Rozmus K, Krzywon J, Truszkiewicz K. A systematic review and meta-analysis of laparoscopic versus robotic rectal surgery with primary anastomosis. Pol Przegl Chir. 2019; 92(1):5–11.
Simillis C, Lal N, Thoukididou SN, Kontovounisios C, Smith JJ, Hompes R, et al. Open versus laparoscopic versus robotic versus transanal mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Ann Surg. 2019; 270(1):59–68.
Sun XY, Xu L, Lu JY, Zhang GN. Robotic versus conventional laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis. Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol. 2019; 28(3):135–42.
Wang L, Zhang Z, Gong L, Zhan Y, Li M, Li S, et al. A systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis: short-term and long-term outcomes of three surgery procedures following neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy for rectal cancer. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2019; 29(5):663–70.
Wang X, Cao G, Mao W, Lao W, He C. Robot-assisted versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020; 16(5):979–89.
Wang X, Zheng Z, Yu Q, Ghareeb WM, Lu X, Huang Y, et al. Impact of surgical approach on surgical resection quality in mid- and low rectal cancer, a Bayesian network meta-analysis. Front Oncol. 2021; 11:699200.
Wee IJY, Kuo LJ, Ngu JC. Urological and sexual function after robotic and laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression. Int J Med Robot. 2021; 17(1):1–8.
Yamamoto S. Comparison of the perioperative outcomes of laparoscopic surgery, robotic surgery, open surgery, and transanal total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: an overview of systematic reviews. Ann Gastroenterol Surg. 2020; 4(6):628–34.
Zheng B, Zhang X, Wang X, Ge L, Wei M, Bi L, et al. A comparison of open, laparoscopic and robotic total mesorectal excision: trial sequential analysis and network meta-analysis. Colorectal Dis. 2020; 22(4):382–91.
Appendix 4: PRISMA Flow Diagram
Figure A1: PRISMA Flow Diagram - Clinical Search Strategy.
PRISMA flow diagram showing the clinical search strategy. The database search of the clinical literature yielded 247 citations published between January 1, 2019, and November 7, 2023, including grey literature searches and after duplicates were removed. We screened the abstracts of the 247 identified studies and excluded 198. We assessed the full text of 49 articles and excluded a further 35. In the end, we included 14 articles in the qualitative synthesis.
Abbreviation: PRISMA, Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses.
Source: Adapted from Page et al.10
Appendix 5: Summary of Included Studies
Table A1:
Characteristics of the Included Systematic Reviews
| Author, year Country | Search date Literature searched | Study details | N, included studies N, total participants |
Risk of bias | Outcomes of interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flynn et al, 202214 United States | Up to February 3, 2021 Medline, PubMed, Embase, Cochrane library, Clinical Trials Register, grey literature, manual abstract searches from selected colorectal conferences, reference lists | Inclusion criteria: comparison of medium- and long-term (> 3 mo after surgery) functional outcomes between groups, English or Spanish language Exclusion criteria: no comparative data on ≥ 1 functional outcomes, reporting only immediate postoperative and short-term (< 3 mo) functional outcomes, reason to suspect possible overlap with another included article, included data from a national database |
14 studies (2 RCT, 12 observational) Robotic: NR Laparoscopic: NR |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB, Jadad scale Nonrandomized studies: NOS, ROBINS-I Included primary studies generally had low to moderate risk of bias |
Functional: sexual function, urinary function, bowel function, quality of life |
| Flynn et al, 202313 United States | Up to February 8, 2021 Medline, Embase, Cochrane databases, reference lists |
Inclusion criteria: comparison of laparoscopic vs. robotic TME (namely anterior resection or abdominoperineal resection) in adults with ≥ 1 outcome of interest, English language Exclusion criteria: case reports, case series, trials published only in abstract form |
50 studies (3 RCT, 3 prospective cohort, 31 retrospective cohort, 13 case-matched) Robotic: 4,809 Laparoscopic: 5,636 |
RCTs: Jadad scale Nonrandomized studies: NOS Included primary studies generally had low to moderate risk of bias |
Operation time, blood loss, conversion rate, length of stay, unplanned readmission, pathological and oncological outcomes (number of LNs harvested, CRM < 1 mm or incomplete TME graded by pathologist as involving the muscularis propria or intramesorectal plane), survival |
| Khajeh et al, 202315 Germany | Up to October 2022 Medline, Web of Science, CENTRAL, reference lists |
Population: adults with rectal cancer undergoing elective rectal resection Intervention: robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery Comparator: open or laparoscopic rectal resection Study design: RCT, prospective observational Exclusion criteria: data unsuitable for meta-analysis, retrospective studies, review articles, studies using cadavers or animals, studies that reported similar data on the same patient population |
26 studies (15 RCT, 11 prospective observational) Robotic: 5,348 Laparoscopic: 1,574 |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB 2 Nonrandomized studies: ROBINS-I Included primary studies generally had some concerns or high concerns for risk of bias |
Intraoperative outcomes (intraoperative complications, conversion rate, blood loss, operation time), postoperative surgical outcomes (histopathological outcomes, postoperative pain, postoperative complications, reoperation rate, length of stay, mortality up to 90 d), survival, cost |
| Liu et al, 202116 China | Search date not specified CENTRAL, Medline, Embase, Google Scholar, Web of Science, ClinicalTrials.gov |
Inclusion criteria: comparison of robotic vs. laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery, published after 2015, reported postoperative complications, dichotomous data, English language Exclusion criteria: studies not comparing robotic vs. laparoscopic, published before or during 2015, non-English language, postoperative outcomes not reported, studies repeatedly found in different search databases |
15 studies (2 RCT, 13 observational) Robotic: 9,178 Laparoscopic: 13,566 |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB Observational studies: NOS Included primary studies generally had moderate risk of bias |
Postoperative outcomes (overall complications, wound complications, anastomotic leak, anastomotic bleeding, stoma-related complication, postoperative ileus, intra-abdominal access, urinary retention, enterocolitis, urinary tract infection, readmission, reoperation, mortality) |
| Martins et al, 202324 United States | Up to February 20, 2022 Medline, Embase, Scopus, CENTRAL, manual searching, reference lists, grey literature |
Study design: observational or interventional clinical studies reporting original data Population: adults with rectal cancer Intervention: robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery Comparator: laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery Exclusion criteria: studies not administering a complete QoL tool, studies reporting QALYs |
7 studies (2 RCT, 4 prospective cohort, 1 retrospective cohort) Robotic: 429 Laparoscopic: 440 |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB 2 Nonrandomized studies: ROBINS-I Included primary studies generally had low risk of bias |
Quality of life |
| Ryan et al, 202117 Ireland | Up to January 1, 2020 Medline/PubMed, Embase, CENTRAL, Scopus, reference lists, ClinicalTrials.gov |
Inclusion criteria: people with rectal cancer, comparison of TME modalities, reported surgical and clinical outcomes of interest, clear research methodology and participant randomization, have the longest follow-up or largest sample size when 2 or more studies were reported by the same institution, English language Exclusion criteria: did not meet inclusion criteria, non-English language |
36 articles (30 trials with 6 updates) Robotic: 388 Laparoscopic: 3,072 Open: 2,207 |
NR | Primary: recurrence, development of distant metastasis, DFS, OS Secondary: pathological outcomes, intraoperative outcomes, patient recovery from surgery, short- to medium-term morbidity |
| Safiejko et al, 202118 Poland | Up to November 10, 2021 PubMed, Cochrane library, Web of Science, Scopus, Google Scholar, reference lists |
Population: adults diagnosed with rectal cancer and treated with rectal cancer surgery Intervention: robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery Comparator: laparoscopic or open rectal cancer surgery Outcomes: detailed information on survival or mortality Study design: RCTs, English language Exclusion criteria: no comparator, reviews, conference articles, editorials, letters, duplicate publications |
41 studies Robotic: 3,858 Laparoscopic: 5,408 |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB 2 Nonrandomized studies: ROBINS-I Included primary studies generally had low to moderate risk of bias |
Survival, DFS, length of stay, adverse events |
| Seow et al, 202319 Australia | Up to September 2020 Medline, Embase, CINAHL, CDSR, CENTRAL, DARE, WHO Registry Network, reference lists |
Inclusion criteria: RCTs of adults (age > 16 y) with rectal tumours stage ≤ 4 (≤ T4), direct comparison of ≥ 2 surgical approaches, RCTs evaluating efficacy based on ≥ 1 surgical and/or clinical outcome, English language Exclusion criteria: nonrandomized studies, participant age ≤ 16 y, rectal cancers grade ≥ T4, studies with operations other than colorectal resection, trials published only as abstracts, non-English language |
47 articles consisting of 32 RCTs Robotic: 216 Laparoscopic: 3,289 Open: 2,167 |
Cochrane RoB 2 Comparison-adjusted funnel plot for publication bias Included primary studies generally had low to moderate risk of bias |
Primary: rate of clear/negative CRM, rate of complete mesorectal excision Secondary: complete mesorectal excision, distance to distal margin, total LNs retrieved, conversion rate, incidence of anastomotic leakage, operating time, rates of diverting ileostomy and permanent colostomy, incidence of perioperative mortality, postoperative complications, locoregional recurrence, 3- or 5-y DFS and OS, length of stay, bowel function, bladder function, sexual function |
| Tang et al, 202120 China | Up to April 2020 PubMed, Embase, Cochrane library, CNKI, Wanfang Data Knowledge Service Platform, CBMdisc, reference lists |
Population: adults with primary rectal cancer Intervention: robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery Comparator: laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery Study design: RCT, English or Chinese language |
7 studies (all RCT) Robotic: 507 Laparoscopic: 516 |
Cochrane RoB, Jadad scale Included primary studies generally had low risk of bias |
Primary: postoperative complications within 30 d (overall and severe postoperative complications, anastomotic leakage, surgical site infection, bleeding, ileus, urinary complications, respiratory complications Secondary: conversion rate, TME completeness, number of harvested LNs, proximal margin, distal margin, unscheduled reoperation, perioperative mortality |
| Wang et al, 202022 China | Up to April 2020 PubMed, Embase, Cochrane library, Web of Science, reference lists |
Inclusion criteria: people with histologically diagnosed rectal cancer, comparative studies of robotic vs. laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery (RCTs and non-RCTs), studies that clearly reported grade of postoperative complications based on C-D classification, most recent studies or those with larger sample sizes were selected if studies reported on same study population Exclusion criteria: case reports, letters comments, conference proceedings, review articles, meta-analyses, abstracts only, studies that reported postoperative complications without C-D classification, studies including combined resection or Hartmann procedure, non-English language |
17 studies (1 RCT, 3 prospective cohort, 13 retrospective cohort) Robotic: 2,168 Laparoscopic: 3,328 |
RCTs: Cochrane RoB Nonrandomized studies: NOS Included primary studies generally had low to moderate risk of bias |
Postoperative complications within 30 d Primary: C-D grade III, IV, V, III to V (severe complications) Secondary: C-D grade I, I, III (minor complications), overall complications, individual complications, reoperation, readmission |
| Yang and Zhou, 202326 China | Up to November 4, 2021 PubMed, Embase, CNKI, Wanfang, Cochrane library |
Inclusion criteria: clinical studies comparing robotic-assisted with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery; primary endpoints of IPSS, IIEF, FSFI Exclusion criteria: letters, editorials, noncomparative studies, duplicate studies, nonhuman studies |
11 studies (2 RCT, 2 propensity-matched, 2 prospective cohort, 5 retrospective cohort) Robotic: NR Laparoscopic: NR |
NOS | Primary: IPSS Secondary: IIEF, FSFI |
| Yao et al, 202321 China | Up to July 2023 PubMed, Embase, Cochrane, Web of Science |
Inclusion criteria: studies comparing robotic-assisted with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery, tumour in the mid- to low part of the rectum, RCTs, cohort studies, case-control studies, the higher-quality study for authors or institutions reporting more than 1 study, sufficient data can be extracted Exclusion criteria: high rectal cancer or not rectal cancer, overlapping data, data could not be extracted, conference abstracts, case reports, reviews, comments |
8 studies (3 RCT, 5 retrospective cohort) Robotic: 1,350 Laparoscopic: 1,330 |
NOS | Estimated blood loss, number of LNs dissected, operation time, time to first flatus, time to first fluid test, length of hospital stay, complications |
| Zhang et al, 202123 China | Up to July 2021 PubMed, Embase, Cochrane library, Web of Science |
Inclusion criteria: people histologically diagnosed with low rectal cancer; robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery (experimental group) vs. laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery (control group); studies with data on feasibility, safety, clinical efficacy, short-term oncological outcomes; any language Exclusion criteria: duplicate articles, review articles, comments, correspondence, meta-analyses, irrelevant topics, case reports, unable to extract data on people with low rectal cancer, overlapping data |
5 studies (all retrospective cohort) Robotic: 273 Laparoscopic: 237 |
NOS | Intraoperative blood loss, operative time, number of LNs retrieved, CRM, distal resection margin, conversion rate, time to first flatus, time to resume regular diet, length of hospital stay, complications |
Abbreviations: CBMdisc, China Biology Medicine disc; CNKI, China National Knowledge Infrastructure; Cochrane RoB, Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool for Randomized Trials; CRM, circumferential resection margin; DFS, disease-free survival; FSFI, Female Sexual Function Index; IIEF, International Index of Erectile Function; IPSS, International Prostate Symptom Score; LN, lymph node; NOS, Newcastle-Ottawa Scale; NR, not reported; OS, overall survival; QALY, quality-adjusted life-year; RCT, randomized controlled trial; ROBINS-I, Risk of Bias in Non-randomised Studies - of Interventions; TME, total mesorectal excision.
Table A2:
Characteristics of the Included Randomized Controlled Trial
| Author, year | N | Study details | Age (y), mean ± SD | Male, n (%) | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Park et al, 202325 | Robotic: 151 Laparoscopic: 144 |
Inclusion criteria: Adult (≥ 18 y) with newly diagnosed middle or low rectal cancers without systemic metastases, rectal adenocarcinoma located < 10 cm from the anal verge Exclusion criteria: did not give informed consent; tumours invading adjacent organs (cT4b); severe concomitant diseases that might limit protocol compliance or completion; presented with an acute surgical emergency, including intestinal perforation or obstruction; history of any other malignancy |
Robotic: 65.5 ± 11.4 Laparoscopic: 67.2 ± 10.1 P = .170 |
Robotic: 97 (64.2%)25Laparoscopic: 99 (68.8%) P = .412 | 2 y |
Appendix 6: Critical Appraisal of Clinical Evidence
Table A3:
Risk of Bias in the Included Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR 2)
| Item Description | Flynn et al, 202214 | Flynn et al, 202313 | Khajeh et al, 202315 | Liu et al, 202116 | Martins et al, 202324 | Ryan et al, 202117 | Safiejko et al, 202118 | Seow et al, 202319 | Tang et al, 202120 | Wang et al, 202022 | Yang and Zhou, 202326 | Yao et al, 202321 | Zhang et al, 202123 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the components of PICO? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 2. Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the review methods were established prior to the conduct of the review and did the report justify any significant deviations from the protocol? | No | No | Partial yes | Partial yes | No | No | Partial yes | No | No | No | Partial yes | No | No |
| 3. Did the review authors explain their selection of the study designs for inclusion in the review? | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | Yes | No | No | No | No |
| 4. Did the review authors use a comprehensive literature search strategy? | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes |
| 5. Did the review authors perform study selection in duplicate? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 6. Did the review authors perform data extraction in duplicate? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 7. Did the review authors provide a list of excluded studies and justify the exclusions? | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
| 8. Did the review authors describe the included studies in adequate detail? | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes | Partial yes |
| 9. Did the review authors use a satisfactory technique for assessing the risk of bias in individual studies that were included in the review? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 10. Did the review authors report on the sources of funding for the studies included in the review? | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
| 11. If meta-analysis was performed did the review authors use appropriate methods for statistical combination of results? | Yes | No meta-analysis conducted | No | Yes | No meta-analysis conducted | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| 12. If meta-analysis was performed, did the review authors assess the potential impact of RoB in individual studies on the results of the meta-analysis or other evidence synthesis? | No | No meta-analysis conducted | Yes | No | No meta-analysis conducted | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | |
| 13. Did the review authors account for risk of bias in individual studies when interpreting/discussing the results of the review? | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | No | Yes | No |
| 14. Did the review authors provide a satisfactory explanation for, and discussion of, any heterogeneity observed in the results of the review? | No | No | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
| 15. If they performed quantitative synthesis did the review authors carry out an adequate investigation of publication bias (small study bias) and discuss its likely impact on the results of the review? | No | No meta-analysis conducted | Yes | No | No meta-analysis conducted | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
| 16. Did the review authors report any potential sources of conflict of interest, including any funding they received for conducting the review? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Overall | Low | Low | Moderate | Low | Moderate | Low | Moderate | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low |
Note: for further details on AMSTAR scoring, see Shea et al.11
Abbreviations: AMSTAR, A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, version 2; PICO, population, intervention, comparator, outcome.
Table A4:
Risk of Bias in the Included Randomized Controlled Trial (Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool)
| Author, year | Random sequence generation | Allocation concealment | Blinding of participants and personnel | Incomplete outcome data | Selective reporting | Other bias |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Park et al, 202325 | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Higha |
Note: The possible risk-of-bias levels are low, high, and unclear. For further details on the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias Tool, see Higgins et al.12
The RCT was ended prematurely owing to difficulty recruiting participants.
Appendix 7: Ongoing Studies
Table A5:
Robotic-Assisted vs. Laparoscopic or Open Rectal Cancer Surgery—Ongoing Studies
| ClinicalTrials.gov ID | Title | Comparator(s) | Country | Study design | Enrolment | Anticipated completion date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NCT04404673 | Urinary and Sexual Dysfunctions Evaluation After Rectal Resection (EURECA) | Laparoscopic, open | Italy | Prospective observational | Estimated: 1,172 | February 2024 |
| NCT03574493 | Rectal Surgery Evaluation Trial (RESET) | Laparoscopic, open | France | Prospective observational | Actual: 1,098 | December 2024 |
| NCT06105203 | RATME vs LATME in Middle and Low Rectal Cancer | Laparoscopic | China | RCT | Estimated: 1,026 | January 2026 |
Abbreviations: RCT, randomized controlled trial; LATME, laparoscopic total mesorectal excision; RATME, robotic-assisted total mesorectal excision.
Key Messages
What Is This Expedited Summary of the Clinical Evidence About?
Rectal cancer is a disease in which cancer cells form in the rectum, which has the primary function of temporarily storing feces, controlling defecation, and maintaining continence. Surgery is the most common treatment for rectal cancer.
Surgical approaches for rectal cancer include open rectal cancer surgery (an invasive procedure that involves a large surgical incision), laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery (a minimally invasive procedure that involves several smaller incisions and the use of smaller surgical tools), and robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery (a minimally invasive procedure that involves the use of a robotic system operated by the surgeon).
We examined published systematic reviews, meta-analyses, randomized controlled trials, and grey literature to determine what is known about the effectiveness and safety of robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery compared with the laparoscopic and open approaches.
What Did This Expedited Summary of the Clinical Evidence Find?
Compared with laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar overall survival and similar rates of conversion (i.e., when a robotic-assisted or laparoscopic procedure is switched to an open procedure), blood transfusion, and readmission; reduced blood loss; shorter length of stay; and improved quality of life. Compared with open rectal cancer surgery, robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery may result in similar overall survival, reduced blood loss, and shorter length of stay.
Contributor Information
Ontario Health:
Myra Wang, Genevieve Forsyth, Corinne Holubowich, Kara Cowan, Emma Tolmie, Claude Soulodre, Caroline Higgins, Susan Harrison, Sarah McDowell, Andrée Mitchell, and Nancy Sikich
About Us
We are an agency created by the Government of Ontario to connect, coordinate, and modernize our province's health care system. We work with partners, providers, and patients to make the health system more efficient so everyone in Ontario has an opportunity for better health and well-being.
For more information about Ontario Health, visit OntarioHealth.ca.
Equity, Inclusion, Diversity and Anti-Racism
Ontario Health is committed to advancing equity, inclusion and diversity and addressing racism in the health care system. As part of this work, Ontario Health has developed an Equity, Inclusion, Diversity and Anti-Racism Framework, which builds on existing legislated commitments and relationships and recognizes the need for an intersectional approach.
Unlike the notion of equality, equity is not about sameness of treatment. It denotes fairness and justice in process and in results. Equitable outcomes often require differential treatment and resource redistribution to achieve a level playing field among all individuals and communities. This requires recognizing and addressing barriers to opportunities for all to thrive in our society.
References
- (1).Mayo Clinic. Rectal cancer [Internet]. Rochester (MN): The Clinic; 2022 May 18. [cited 2024 Jan 12]. Available from: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/rectal-cancer/symptoms-causes/syc-20352884 [Google Scholar]
- (2).American Cancer Society. Tests to diagnose and stage colorectal cancer [Internet]. Atlanta (GA): The Society; 2024. [cited 2024 Feb 12]. Available from: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/types/colon-rectal-cancer/detection-diagnosis-staging/how-diagnosed.html [Google Scholar]
- (3).Canadian Cancer Society. Stages of colorectal cancer [Internet]. Toronto (ON): The Society; 2024. [cited 2024 Jan 12]. Available from: https://cancer.ca/en/cancer-information/cancer-types/colorectal/staging [Google Scholar]
- (4).Ontario Health (Cancer Care Ontario). Ontario cancer statistics 2022 [Internet]. Toronto (ON): Ontario Health; 2022. [cited 2024 Jan 12]. Available from: https://www.cancercareontario.ca/en/data-research/view-data/statistical-reports/ontario-cancer-statistics-2022 [Google Scholar]
- (5).Siegel RL, Wagle NS, Cercek A, Smith RA, Jemal A. Colorectal cancer statistics, 2023. CA Cancer J Clin. 2023; 73(3):233–54. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (6).American Cancer Society. Survival rates for colorectal cancer [Internet]. Atlanta (GA): The Society; 2024. [cited 2023 Jan 19]. Available from: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/types/colon-rectal-cancer/detection-diagnosis-staging/survival-rates.html [Google Scholar]
- (7).American Cancer Society. Treatment of rectal cancer, by stage [Internet]. Atlanta (GA): The Society; 2024. [cited 2024 Feb 12]. Available from: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/types/colon-rectal-cancer/treating/by-stage-rectum.html [Google Scholar]
- (8).Canadian Cancer Society. Treatments for rectal cancer [Internet]. Toronto (ON): The Society; 2024. [cited 2024 Feb 12]. Available from: https://cancer.ca/en/cancer-information/cancer-types/colorectal/treatment/rectal-cancer [Google Scholar]
- (9).Liu G, Zhang S, Zhang Y, Fu X, Liu X. Robotic surgery in rectal cancer: potential, challenges, and opportunities. Curr Treat Options Oncol. 2022; 23(7):961–79. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (10).Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021; 372:n71. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (11).Shea BJ, Reeves BC, Wells G, Thuku M, Hamel C, Moran J, et al. AMSTAR 2: a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions, or both. BMJ. 2017; 358:j4008. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (12).Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gotzsche PC, Juni P, Moher D, Oxman AD, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2011; 343:d5928. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (13).Flynn J, Larach JT, Kong JCH, Rahme J, Waters PS, Warrier SK, et al. Operative and oncological outcomes after robotic rectal resection compared with laparoscopy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. ANZ J Surg. 2023; 93(3):510–21. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (14).Flynn J, Larach JT, Kong JCH, Waters PS, McCormick JJ, Warrier SK, et al. Patient-related functional outcomes after robotic-assisted rectal surgery compared with a laparoscopic approach: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2022; 65(10):1191–204. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (15).Khajeh E, Aminizadeh E, Dooghaie Moghadam A, Nikbakhsh R, Goncalves G, Carvalho C, et al. Outcomes of robot-assisted surgery in rectal cancer compared with open and laparoscopic surgery. Cancers (Basel). 2023; 15(3):29. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (16).Liu C, Li X, Wang Q. Postoperative complications observed with robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for the treatment of rectal cancer: an updated meta-analysis of recently published studies. Medicine. 2021; 100(36):e27158. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (17).Ryan OK, Ryan EJ, Creavin B, Rausa E, Kelly ME, Petrelli F, et al. Surgical approach for rectal cancer: a network meta-analysis comparing open, laparoscopic, robotic and transanal TME approaches. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2021; 47(2):285–95. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (18).Safiejko K, Tarkowski R, Koselak M, Juchimiuk M, Tarasik A, Pruc M, et al. Robotic-assisted vs. standard laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer resection: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 19,731 patients. Cancers (Basel). 2021; 14(1):30. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (19).Seow W, Dudi-Venkata NN, Bedrikovetski S, Kroon HM, Sammour T. Outcomes of open vs laparoscopic vs robotic vs transanal total mesorectal excision (TME) for rectal cancer: a network meta-analysis. Tech Coloproctol. 2023; 27(5):345–60. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (20).Tang B, Lei X, Ai J, Huang Z, Shi J, Li T. Comparison of robotic and laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. World J Surg Oncol. 2021; 19(1):38. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (21).Yao Q, Sun QN, Ren J, Wang LH, Wang DR. Comparison of robotic-assisted versus conventional laparoscopic surgery for mid-low rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 2023; 149(16):15207–17. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (22).Wang Y, Liu Y, Han G, Yi B, Zhu S. The severity of postoperative complications after robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression. PLoS One. 2020; 15(10):e0239909. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (23).Zhang J, Qi X, Yi F, Cao R, Gao G, Zhang C. Comparison of clinical efficacy and safety between da Vinci robotic and laparoscopic intersphincteric resection for low rectal cancer: a meta-analysis. Front Surg. 2021; 8:752009. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (24).Martins RS, Fatimi AS, Mahmud O, Jahangir A, Mahar MU, Aamir SR, et al. Multidimensional quality of life after robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. World J Surg. 2023; 47(5):1310–9. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (25).Park JS, Lee SM, Choi GS, Park SY, Kim HJ, Song SH, et al. Comparison of laparoscopic versus robot-assisted surgery for rectal cancers: the COLRAR randomized controlled trial. Ann Surg. 2023; 278(1):31–8. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (26).Yang H, Zhou L. The urinary and sexual outcomes of robot-assisted versus laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Surg Today. 2023; 21:21. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (27).Suwa Y, Joshi M, Poynter L, Endo I, Ashrafian H, Darzi A. Obese patients and robotic colorectal surgery: systematic review and meta-analysis. BJS Open. 2020; 21:21. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (28).Crolla R, Mulder PG, van der Schelling GP. Does robotic rectal cancer surgery improve the results of experienced laparoscopic surgeons? An observational single institution study comparing 168 robotic assisted with 184 laparoscopic rectal resections. Surg Endosc. 2018; 32(11):4562–70. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (29).Kolehmainen CSJ, Ukkonen MT, Tomminen T, Helavirta IM, Laukkarinen JM, Hyoty M, et al. Short learning curve in transition from laparoscopic to robotic-assisted rectal cancer surgery: a prospective study from a Finnish tertiary referral centre. J Robot Surg. 2023; 17(5):2361–7. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (30).Giesen LJX, Dekker JWT, Verseveld M, Crolla R, van der Schelling GP, Verhoef C, et al. Implementation of robotic rectal cancer surgery: a cross-sectional nationwide study. Surg Endosc. 2023; 37(2):912–20. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (31).McGowan J, Sampson M, Salzwedel DM, Cogo E, Foerster V, Lefebvre C. PRESS peer review of electronic search strategies: 2015 guideline statement. J Clin Epidemiol. 2016; 75:40–6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- (32).Covidence (systematic review software) [Computer program]. Veritas Health Innovation; (Melbourne, Australia: ). Available at: https://www.covidence.org/home. [Google Scholar]
- (33).Schünemann H, Brożek J, Guyatt G, Oxman A, editors. GRADE handbook [Internet]. Hamilton (ON): Grade Working Group; 2013. [cited 2017 Dec]. Available from http://gdt.guidelinedevelopment.org/app/handbook/handbook.html. [Google Scholar]

