Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 16;13(4):364. doi: 10.3390/antibiotics13040364

Table A2.

Methodological Quality Assessment according to Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool and Jadad Scoring [46,55].

Study Random Sequence Generation Allocation Concealment Blinding Patients/Personel Blinding Outcome Assess Incomplete Outcome Select Reporting Other Bias Overall Jadad [0–5]
Bendel, 1988 [20] + + - - + + + 2 - =High Risk
Bendel, 1989 [19] ? + - - + + + 1
Bräunig, 1992 [36] ? ? ? ? + - + 1 + =Low Risk
Cohen, 2004 [18] + + + + ? + + 4
Forth, 1981 [17] + - - ? ? - ? 1 ? =Unclear
Freyer, 1974 [22] + - - - + + + 1
Goel, 2004 [38] + + + + + + + 5
Grimm, 1996 [23] + ? + + + + + 5
Hall, 2007 [24] + + + + ? ? + 4
Helbig, 1961 [25] ? - - - + + + 1
Jawad, 2012 [26] + + + + ? ? + 5
Kolev, 2022 [27] + - - + + + + 2
Berg, 1998 [21] ? + + ? + + + 3
Melchart, 1998 [15] + + - ? + + + 4
Ogal, 2021 [14] + + ? + + + + 5
O’Neil, 2008 [28] + + + + - + + 4
Osama 2020 [29] + + - - - + ? 1
Raus, 2015 [39] + + + + + + + 5
Schmidt 1990 [30] ? + ? ? + + + 4
Schulten, 2001 [40] + - + + + ? + 3
Spasov, 2004 [41] + - - - ? ? ? 2
Sperber, 2004 [31] ? ? + + + + + 3
Sumer, 2023 [37] + + ? ? + + + 4
Taylor03-Weber05 [35,42] + + + + + + + 5
Tiralongo, 2012 [32] + + + + ? + + 5
Turner, 2000 [33] ? ? ? + + + + 3
Turner, 2005 [16] + ? + + + + + 4
Yakoot, 2011 [43] + + + + + ? + 5
Zhang, 2003 [34] + + - - ? + + 3