Table 3.
| ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CRITERIA USED | RHD ANY n, % | MITRAL REGURGITATION, n (%) | MITRAL STENOSIS (ANY), n (%) | AORTIC REGURGITATION (ANY), n (%) | AORTIC STENOSIS (ANY), n (%) | |
| ||||||
Studies using Portable or Handlehd Echocardiography | ||||||
| ||||||
Otto 2011 | WHO consensus statement 2001 | Any: 16 (4.6%) Definite: 8 Nondefinite: 8 |
Any: 12 (3.6%) Mild: 7 Mid/Moderate: 2 Moderate: 2 Moderate/Severe: 1 |
0 | Any: 6 (1.7%) Mild: 6 |
0 |
| ||||||
Beaton 2019 | WHF | Any: 51 (1.5%) Mild: 31 Moderate: 14 Severe: 6 |
Any: 45 (1.3%) Mild: 28 Moderate: 15 Severe: 2 |
Any: 3 (0.1%) Mild: 2 Moderate: 1 |
Any: 7 (0.2%) Mild: 5 Moderate: 1 Severe: 1 |
0 |
| ||||||
Nascimento 2021 | Adapted ASE criteria for major heart disease | Any: 12 (1.1%)* | Any: 12 (1.1%) Mild to moderate: 11 Moderate: 1 |
Any: 1 (0.1%) Mild: 1 |
Any: 3 (0.3%) Mild: 3 |
Any: 1 (0.1%) Mild: 1 |
| ||||||
Snelgrove 2021 | WHF | Any: 3 (0.5%) | Any: 1 (0.2%) Moderate: 1 |
Any: 2 (0.33%) Severe: 2 |
Any: 1 (0.2%) Moderate: 1 |
0 |
| ||||||
AlSharqi 2022 | ASE/EACVI recommendations | Any: 20 (6.6%) | ‘mitral valve involvement’: 20 (6.6%) | Significant: 17 (5.6%) | ‘aortic valve involvement’ 3 (1%) | Significant: 1 (0.3%) |
| ||||||
Screening using standard echocardiography or nonspecified echocardiographer | ||||||
| ||||||
Selvarani 2014 | NA | Any: 17 (1.5%) | Any: 1 (0.1%) | Any: 14 (1.2%) | Any: 3 (0.03%) | NA |
| ||||||
Bacha 2019 | WHF | Significant: 9 (2.3%) |
Any: 4 (1%) Moderate to Severe: 2 NS: 2 |
Moderate to Severe: 3 (0.8%) | Moderate to Severe: 2 (0.5%) | Moderate to Severe: 2(0.5%) |
| ||||||
Gomathi 2019 | NA | Any: 12 (4.0%) | Any: 4 (1.3%) | Any: 4 (1.3%) Moderate: 3 Not specified: 1 |
Any: 1 (0.3%) Not specified: 1 |
Any: 1 (0.3%) Not specified: 1 |
| ||||||
Bozkaya 2020 | WHF | Any: 26 (2.9%) | Any 24 (2.7%) Mild: 20 Moderate: 4 |
Mild: 2 (0.2%) | 0 | 0 |
| ||||||
Patel 2021 | NA | 61 (0.4%) | Any: not specified; ‘mitral valve involvement’: 61 | Number not specified, but ‘90% were mild to moderate, and 67% had Wilkins score <8’ | NA | NA |
|
*RHD on screening was suspected in 36 women (3.2%), but only 56 of the 100 women who screened positive had a confirmatory echocardiogram.