Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 12;11(2):221–241. doi: 10.1016/j.ajur.2022.11.005

Table 1.

Advantages and limitations of NMR compared to MS in metabolomics applications.

Metabolomics technique Advantage Disadvantage Applicable substance
NMR spectroscopy
  • -

    High reproducibility, straightforward sample preparation, preservation of molecular integrity, potential sample reuse, cost-effectiveness, and greater ease of identification compared to MS [14]

  • -

    Lower detectable metabolites in urine sample and lower sensitivity compared to MS [14]

  • -

    Body fluids, in vivo and in situ studies [13]

GC-MS
  • -

    Higher specificity and sensitivity, available for comparison with a standard, and can be used for both targeted and nontargeted analyses compared to NMR spectroscopy [12]

  • -

    The manipulation of low volatile molecules can present difficulties [12]

  • -

    Heat stable, volatile, medium, and low polar molecules [14]

LC-MS
  • -

    Higher specificity and sensitivity, available for comparison with a standard, and can be used for both targeted and nontargeted analyses compared to NMR spectroscopy [12,14]

  • -

    Low retention for hydrophilic molecules and no complete database to compare with a standard [14]

  • -

    Most compounds, including those that exhibit heat-lability, nonvolatility, and resistance to derivatization [12]

MS, mass spectrometry; GC, gas chromatography; LC, liquid chromatography; NMR, nuclear magnetic resonance.