Table 6:
Selection Type | Selection Strategy | Clinical | Chemical | Biomedical | Dataset Avg. | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
REL | FAITH | REL | FAITH | REL | FAITH | REL | FAITH | ||
Random | – | .220 | .180 | .081 | −.038 | .028 | .061 | .110 | .068 |
Quality Based | Extreme | .263 | .152 | .049 | −.168 | .039 | .002 | .117 | −.005 |
Average | .028 | −.080 | .015 | .056 | .030 | .025 | .024 | .000 | |
Min | .193 | −.022 | .069 | −.049 | .039 | −.012 | .100 | −.027 | |
High | .218 | .095 | .056 | −.029 | .019 | .004 | .098 | .023 | |
Margin Based | Max | .235 | .210 | .062 | .031 | .032 | −.011 | .110 | .077 |
Min | .158 | −.115 | .028 | .080 | .014 | .015 | .067 | −.007 | |
Diversity Based | Max | .274 | .151 | .054 | −.166 | .015 | −.011 | .114 | −.009 |
Min | .275 | .091 | −.049 | −.114 | .020 | −.037 | .082 | −.020 | |
Likelihood Based | Extreme Beam | .260 | .140 | .029 | −.158 | .030 | −.008 | .106 | −.009 |
Top Beam | .287 | .142 | .066 | −.042 | .030 | −.008 | .128 | .031 | |
Bottom Beam | .101 | .125 | .059 | .085 | .025 | −.002 | .062 | .069 | |
Spurious Correlates | Max Length | .255 | .150 | .051 | −.095 | .017 | −.027 | .108 | .009 |
Min Length | .181 | .243 | .042 | .052 | .033 | .022 | .085 | .106 | |
Avg. Across Strategies | .211 | .104 | .044 | −.040 | .027 | .001 | .094 | .022 |