Table 1. Comparison of target trial and emulated trial using ALSWH data.
Target trial | Emulation with ALSWH | |
---|---|---|
Eligibility criteria | Women aged 47–52 years with unimpaired physical functioning and prepared to accept an intervention to meet physical activity guidelines | Women in the ALSWH cohort aged 47–52 years with unimpaired physical functioning who either did or did not meet physical activity guidelines |
Trial arms | Intervention: Women adhering to meet physical activity guidelines over a 15-year period | Intervention: Women meeting physical activity guidelines over a 15-year period (referred to hereafter as “exposed”) |
Control: Individuals caused to not meet physical activity guidelines | Control: Individuals not meeting physical activity guidelines | |
Assignment procedures | Random assignment to either intervention or control arm at recruitment | Adjustment for confounding using TMLE |
Follow-up period | 15 years of intervention period (6 triennial waves of follow-up), plus 3 years postexposure for measurement of outcome | 15 years of exposure (6 triennial waves of follow-up), plus 3 years postexposure for measurement of outcome |
Outcomes | Health-related quality of life assessed using the SF-36 | Health-related quality of life assessed using the SF-36 |
Causal effect measure | The difference in means of outcomes in the intervention versus the control arms of the study | ATE estimated as the difference in conditional expected mean under treatment versus conditional mean under control |
ALSWH, Australian Longitudinal Study on Women’s Health; ATE, average treatment effect; SF-36, 36-item Medical Outcomes Study short-form survey; TMLE, targeted maximum likelihood estimation.