. 2024 Apr 26;106:106887. doi: 10.1016/j.ultsonch.2024.106887

Table 1.

Box-Behnken design (BBD) with responses of the dependent variables obtained by sonoextraction from cocoa bean shell (CBS) and cocoa pod husk (CPH).

Runs	Experimental domains			Experimental responses
	X_A	X_B	X_C	CBS			CPH
	X_A	X_B	X_C	TPC	TEAC	FRAP	TPC	TEAC	FRAP
1	8	10	0	146.16 ^h	0.09^f	0.16^e	30.81ⁱ	0.02 ^h	0.04^ef
2	8	45	50	213.19^c	0.15^bc	0.23^bc	172.84^c	0.14^b	0.25^a
3	15	45	0	209.93^d	0.14 ^cd	0.23^c	43.15 ^h	0.03 ^g	0.04^e
4	8	45	50	254.80^b	0.21^a	0.26^a	153.92^e	0.12^c	0.23^b
5	8	80	100	10.15 ^l	0.04 ^g	0.02ⁱ	4.29^j	0.04^f	0.01 ^g
6	15	45	100	11.17 ^l	0.08^f	0.03ⁱ	5.53^j	0.04^f	0.01 ^g
7	1	45	100	8.12 ^l	0.03 ^g	0.02ⁱ	2.25^j	0.02 ^h	0.004 ^g
8	1	80	50	124.10ⁱ	0.08^f	0.10 ^g	132.53^f	0.10^d	0.17^d
9	1	45	0	62.61 ^k	0.04 ^g	0.08 ^h	33.30ⁱ	0.09^e	0.03^f
10	8	45	50	173.66^f	0.11^e	0.19^d	193.68^a	0.14^b	0.24^a
11	8	10	100	9.43 ^l	0.03 ^g	0.02ⁱ	2.68^j	0.02 ^g	0.005 ^g
12	1	10	50	109.73^j	0.07^f	0.11 ^g	131.92^f	0.10^d	0.17^d
13	8	80	0	186.88^e	0.13^d	0.18^d	50.61 ^g	0.03 ^g	0.04^e
14	15	10	50	155.21 ^g	0.16^b	0.15^f	158.04^d	0.12^c	0.19^c
15	15	80	50	263.69^a	0.22^a	0.24^b	190.42^b	0.15^a	0.25^a

X_A (Time, min), X_B (Amplitude, %), X_C (Ethanol, %), TPC (mg GAE/g sample), TEAC (mmol TE/g sample), FRAP (mmol FeSO₄/g sample). The different letters next to the means are significantly different (p < 0.05) according to Duncan’s multiple range test.