Skip to main content
. 2024 May 9;2024(5):CD014715. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014715.pub2

1. Impact of potential sources of heterogeneity on the sensitivity of a first‐trimester scan in detecting fetal structural anomalies.

Impact of potential sources of heterogeneity on the sensitivity of a first‐trimester scan in detecting fetal structural anomalies
Covariate First‐trimester scan
Sensitivity estimate(95% CI) P value
Fetuses affected Anomalies Fetuses affected Anomalies
1. Study period*
1999 31.6
(19.2 to 44.0) 29.5
(18.1 to 40.9)
2009 37.6
(30.8 to 44.3) 38.7
(32.2 to 45.2)
2019 44.0
(29.1 to 58.9) 48.7
(35.7 to 61.8)
Beta 0.3
(‐0.03 to 0.08) 0.04
(‐0.01 to 0.09) 0.311 0.08
2. Reported prevalence of isolated ventricular septal defects
≤ 1.7 per 1000 41.0
(32.8 to 48.1) 41.3
(32.6 to 50.0) 0.195 0.429
< 1.7 per 1000 31.9
(22.3 to 41.6)
35.7
(25.2 to 46.2)
3. Anatomical screening protocol
Basic 39.4
(36.2 to 27.5) 39.7
(27.8 to 51.6) 0.915 (basic vs detailed)
0.810 (basic vs not reported)
0.845 (basic vs detailed)
0.896 (basic vs not reported)
Detailed 36.2
(27.5 to 58.3) 38.2
(28.7 to 47.7)
Not reported 36.4
(27.5 to 45.0) 41.1
(23.7 to 58.5)
4. Cardiac screening protocol
Basic 39.5
(30.5 to 48.5) 39.1
(29.0 to 49.2) 0.915 (basic vs extended)
0.277 (basic vs not reported) 0.567 (basic vs extended)
0.591 (basic vs not reported)
Extended 38.7
(26.7 to 50.7) 44.0
(30.5 to 57.4)
Not reported 30.9
18.7 to 43.1) 34.7
(22.5 to 46.8)
5. Country
LIC 67.7
(49.7 to 85.8) 67.9
(48.5 to 87.3) 0.002** 0.006**
HIC 34.4
(29.2 to 39.6) 36.5
(30.5 to 42.5)
CI: confidence interval; LIC: low‐ or lower‐middle‐income country; HIC: high‐ or upper‐middle‐income country
*Study period was defined by the year in which the study period ended. The impact of the study period on the estimated sensitivity was investigated as a continuous variable through meta‐regression.
**P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.