Skip to main content
. 2024 May 9;2024(5):CD014715. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014715.pub2
Sensitivity analyses
  Fetuses affected Anomalies
Studies Sensitivity
(95% CI) Studies Sensitivity
(95% CI)
First‐trimester scan
Summary estimate of all included studies 20 37.5
(31.1 to 44.3) 20 39.2
(32.5 to 46.2)
Summary estimate of studies that reported complete 2 x 2 tables 10 35.5
(27.0 to 45.0) 9 36.7
(26.2 to 48.6)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ patient selection 17 35.1
(28.6 to 42.2)
17 37.4
(30.1 to 45.3)
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ patient selection 4 N/A* 3 N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ index test 20 37.5
(31.1 to 44.3)
20 39.2
(32.5 to 46.2)
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ index test 16 40.3
(32.9 to 48.2)
16 42.4
(35.3 to 49.9)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ reference standard 2 N/A* 2 N/A*
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ reference standard 20 37.5
(31.1 to 44.3) 20 39.2
(32.5 to 46.2)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ flow and timing 1 N/A* 1 N/A*
Summary estimate, excluding studies that used data obtained from birth defect registries 20 37.5
(31.1 to 44.3) 20 39.2
(32.5 to 46.2)
Summary estimate, excluding studies with fewer than 10 cases that had the target condition 17 37.6
(30.9 to 41.6) 18 39.3
(32.4 to 46.5)
Summary estimate, excluding studies with ≥ 10% lost to follow‐up 15 36.6
(29.1 to 44.7) 15 36.9
(29.0 to 45.5)
First + second‐trimester scan
Summary estimate of all included studies 18 83.8
(74.7 to 90.1) 17 84.5
(75.8 to 90.5)
Summary estimate of studies that reported complete 2 x 2 tables 10 82.6
(71.2 to 90.1) 8 84.0
(71.9 to 91.6)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ patient selection 15 82.4
(71.7 to 89.7) 14 83.0
(72.7 to 90.0)
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ patient selection 4 N/A* 3 N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ index test 18 83.8
(74.7 to 90.1) 17 84.5
(75.8 to 90.5)
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ index test 16 82.6
(72.3 to 89.7) 15 83.3
(73.3 to 90.1)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ reference standard 2 N/A* 2 N/A*
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ reference standard 18 83.8
(74.7 to 90.1) 17 84.5
(75.8 to 90.5)
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ flow and timing 1 N/A* 1 N/A*
Summary estimate, excluding studies that used data obtained from birth defect registries 18 83.8
(74.7 to 90.1) 17 84.5
(75.8 to 90.5)
Summary estimate, excluding studies with fewer than 10 cases that had the target condition 15 83.4
(73.3 to 90.2) 15 84.4
(74.9 to 90.8)
Summary estimate, excluding studies with ≥ 10% lost to follow‐up 14 84.3
(74.5 to 90.8) 14 85.2
(76.0 to 91.3)
Single second‐trimester scan
Summary estimate 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) 3 52.2
(33.2 to 70.7)
Summary estimate of studies that reported complete 2 x 2 tables 5 59.3
(42.4 to 74.2) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ patient selection 7 52.5
(38.6 to 66.1) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ patient selection 8 53.2
(40.8 to 65.2) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ index test 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ index test 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ reference standard 4 N/A* N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies with low applicability concerns ‐ reference standard 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate of studies at low risk of bias ‐ flow and timing 1 N/A* N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate, excluding studies that used data obtained from birth defect registries 8 52.2
(33.2 to 70.6) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate, excluding studies with fewer than 10 cases that had the target condition 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) N/A* N/A*
Summary estimate, excluding studies with ≥ 10% lost to follow‐up 9 50.5
(38.5 to 62.4) N/A* N/A*
*N/A: sensitivity analysis was not performed if four or fewer studies were available.