Table 2.
Author (s) and date | Study details and data collection | Focus/population | Measurement tools | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Starkey et al. (2019) United States of America |
Descriptive cross-sectional study. Participants recruited through nursing professional organisation. 12 weeks of weekly surveys. Sample: 146 nurses, 91.1 % female, M age 44 years, 63 % worked full time. |
Focus: How receiving expressions of gratitude predicts physical health outcomes in acute care nurses Population: Nurses |
· Self-developed ‘Gratitude expression and reception’ scale · Life Orientation Test · Quality Care Scale · Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index · Health Event Checklist |
Gratitude predicted sleep quality, sleep adequacy, headaches, and attempts to eat healthily. |
Kim et al. (2019) South Korea |
Descriptive cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point Sample: 360 nurses. Participants recruited from a single tertiary hospital. M age 34.1 years old, 99 % female. |
Focus: To estimate the influence of resilience and gratitude disposition on psychological well‐being in Korean clinical nurses in variety of surgical, medical, and mixed wards Population: Nurses |
· Gratitude Resentment and Appreciation Test · Dispositional Resilience Scale – 15 · Job Satisfaction Scale · Psychological Wellbeing Scale |
Gratitude disposition had significant direct effect on psychological well‐being. Gratitude disposition had significant indirect effects through the effect on burnout, compassion satisfaction and job satisfaction. |
Lau (2017) Hong Kong |
Cross-sectional study. Participants recruited from 9 local non-government organisations who support providers of dementia-related care. Sample: 101 participants completed a face-to-face verbal questionnaire. Data collection on a single time point. M age 57.6 years, 82 % female. Participants were excluded if undergoing cancer treatment or structured counselling programs. |
Focus: Investigate the role of gratitude in the coping process among familial caregivers of People With Dementia. Population: Caregivers |
· Gratitude Adjective scale · Gratitude Questionnaire · Caregiver competence · Social support measures · Brief Coping Orientation to Problems Experienced scale · Caregiver burden- Zarit Burden Interview · Center for Epidemiological Studies – Depression Scale |
Gratitude adjective positively related to social support and emotion-focused coping. Gratitude was associated with problem-focused coping as well as emotion-focused coping and associated with greater use of planning. |
Lee et al. (2019) United States of America |
Study 1: Experience sampling methodology. Sample: 51 employees, also enrolled as a part time Master of Business Administration student in a large United States of America university over 10 consecutive days. Demographic data collected 1 week before the daily surveys. 49 % were female, 80.4 were Caucasian, and worked an average of 50.6 h per week. Study 2: Critical Incident Technique, single time-point survey to capture two samples both a helper's perspective (sample 1) and receiver (sample 2) of help's perspective. Sample 1: 400 full time employees, 44.9 % female, 85 % Caucasian, 72.1 % aged between 20 and 39 years old Sample 2: 250 full-time employees, 41.3 female, 79.4 % Caucasian, 76.7 % aged between 20 and 39 years. |
Focus: Association of receiving gratitude with prosocial impact and work engagement. Population: Employees in North America |
· Likert scale. | Receipt of gratitude is associated with increases in perceived prosocial impact and work engagement the following day. |
Author (s) and date | Study details and data collection | Focus/population | Measurement tools | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Petrocchi and Couyoumdjian (2016) Italy |
Descriptive Cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point, Sample: 410 participants. Participants recruited from mailing lists of a university and professional organisations and web advertising. M age 33.35 years old, 61.46 % female. |
Focus: To evaluate possible mediation models for the relationship between gratitude and symptoms of depression and anxiety Population: Students, employed, unemployed adults. |
· Gratitude Questionnaire · Forms of Self-Criticizing /attacking and Self-Reassuring Scale · Center for Epidemiological Studies – Depression Scale · Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory – Trait Form |
Gratitude negatively correlated with self-criticising and self-attacking scales, and positively with the self-reassuring scale. Direct effect of gratitude on anxiety but partially mediated by self-criticising and self-reassuring pathway. |
Lin (2015) Taiwan |
Descriptive Cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point. Sample: 375 participants. Participants recruited from undergraduates studying at 9 universities in Taiwan. M age 20.3 years old, 65 % female. |
Focus: To examine simultaneously the effect of gratitude on social, cognitive, physical, and psychological resources. Population: Undergraduate students |
· Gratitude Questionnaire-6 (Chinese version) · Inventory of coping style · Inventory of social support · Inventory of negative emotions · Inventory of positive emotions · Satisfaction with Life Scale |
Gratitude: · Was significantly associated with social support, emotional-companion support, and informational-tangible support. · Had significant effect on coping style, on problem-focused active coping, on problem-focused passive coping, on emotion-focused passive coping. · In high levels with problem focused active coping and emotion-focused active coping strategies · had a significant positive effect on negative emotions, specifically shame, anger, and on life satisfaction. · In low levels was associated with negative emotions of shame and anger Positive emotion partially mediates the association between gratitude and life satisfaction. |
Author (s) and date | Study details and data collection | Focus/population | Measurement tools | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sirois and Wood (2017) United Kingdom |
Longitudinal associations study. Data collection – paired survey, two time points, 6 months apart. Arthritis sample: Timepoint 1 423 participants, M age 44.5 years, 88.1 % female, Timepoint 2. 163 participants, M age 46.9, 91.6 % female. Inflammatory Bowel Disease sample: Timepoint 1: 427 participants, M age 35.6 years, 76.8 % female, Timepoint 2: 144 participants, M age 38.3 years, 77.8 % female. Participants from North America, United Kingdom, and other countries via support groups for arthritis and Inflammatory Bowel Disease, web advertisements, classified advertisements, and support foundation resource pages. |
Focus: To evaluate associations between gratitude and depressive symptoms in chronic illness. Population: Adults with arthritis or Inflammatory Bowel Disease |
· Gratitude questionnaire -6 · Center for Epidemiological Studies – Depression Scale · Medical Outcomes Survey 36 item short form · Arthritis Impact Measurement Scales · Inflammatory Bowel Disease Questionnaire · Perceived Stress Scale · Duke-University of North Carolina Functional Social Support · Illness Cognition Questionnaire · Psychological thriving scale (based on Carver's 1998 model of psychological thriving) |
Gratitude was associated with lower depressive symptoms |
Leppma et al. (2018) United States of America |
Descriptive Cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point, 7 years after traumatic event. Sample: 113 participants. Participants recruited from one police department in New Orleans. M age 43.2 years old, 23.89 % female. |
Focus: Role of gratitude in Post-traumatic Growth (post-Hurricane Katrina). Population: Police Officers |
· Gratitude Questionnaire-6 · Satisfaction With Life · Recent Stressful Life Changes Questionnaire · Post-Traumatic Growth Inventory · Interpersonal Support Evaluation List |
Gratitude was positively correlated with Post-Traumatic Growth (r = 0.20, p < .05), Satisfaction with life (r = 0.64, p < .001) and Social support (r = 0.69, p < .001) |
Author (s) and date | Study details and data collection | Focus/population | · Measurement tools | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Vieselmeyer et al. (2017) United States of America |
Descriptive Cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point, 4 months after a traumatic event. Sample: 359 participants, recruited from staff and students at a university where an on-campus shooting occurred. M age 27.26 years old, 75 % female, 66 % were undergraduate, 5 % postgraduate, 11 % faculty and 17 % staff members. |
Focus: To investigate relationship between trauma and mental health outcomes following university campus shooting. Population: University students and staff |
· Gratitude Questionnaire-6 · The Brief Trauma Questionnaire · Trauma exposure measures · Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist – Civilian · Posttraumatic Growth Inventory · Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale- 25 |
Gratitude moderated effect of post-traumatic stress on post-trauma growth. High gratitude associated with high levels of post-trauma growth |
McCanlies et al. (2014) United States of America |
Descriptive Cross-sectional study. Data collection – survey, single time point, 7 years after traumatic event. Sample: 114 participants. Participants recruited from one police department in New Orleans. M age 43.0 years old, 26.3 % female. |
Focus: To evaluate if higher levels of resilience, gratitude, life satisfaction, and posttraumatic growth were associated with lower Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms among law enforcement officers Population: Police Officers |
· Gratitude Questionnaire · Post-Traumatic Growth Inventory · Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Checklist – Civilian version · Connor-Davidson resilience scale · Satisfaction With Life Scale |
Gratitude may be protective or mitigate symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. Expressing gratitude or having a grateful disposition is positively associated with increased life satisfaction, hope, and happiness |
Author (s) and date | Study details and data collection | Focus/population | Measurement tools | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Jans-Beken et al. (2018) Netherlands |
Four-wave prospective survey design. Data collection – survey, four time points, at Time 0, 6, 18, and 30 weeks from Time 0. Sample: 706 participants commenced, 280 completed. Adult participants recruited from the public in multiple advertisements. From completions, M age 48 years old, 71 % female. |
Focus: To evaluate if a grateful trait influences psychopathology and subjective wellbeing. Population: Adults (general population) |
· Dutch Short Gratitude, Resentment, and Appreciation Test · Dutch version of Symptom Check List -90 · Satisfaction With Life Scale · Positive and Negative Affect Scale |
The grateful trait did not predict symptoms of psychopathology. Gratitude predicted subjective wellbeing. |
Note: n = number, M= Mean, SD = Standard Deviation, p = Probability Value, r = correlation coefficient.