Skip to main content
. 2024 May 9;24:352. doi: 10.1186/s12884-024-06383-5

Table 3.

Mapping of posttraumatic (PTS) factors

Not statistically significant FACTORS Statistically significant
Parent demographic factors

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Garfield 2015 [27]

n = 113

Greene 2019 [29]

n = 69

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

Vinall 2018 [43]

n = 36

age

Misund 2013 & 2014 [36, 37]

n = 29

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Garfield 2015 [27]

n = 113

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

education

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

Vinall 2018 [43]

n = 36

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Pace 2020 [39]

n = 105

sex

Moreyra 2021 [47]

n = 150

Naeem 2019 [38]

n = 160

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Moreyra 2021 [47]

n = 150

ethnicity
parents ‘area deprivation

Greene 2019 [29]

n = 69

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

housing and access to transport
family income

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

employment status

Naeem 2019 [38]

n = 160

Malin 2020 [46]

n = 164

single parent

Pace2020 [39]

n = 105

family social risk
Pregnancy and birth factors

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

parity

Greene 2015 [28]

n = 69

Kim 2015 [33]

n = 120

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

Pace 2020 [39]

n = 105

multiple pregnancy

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

mode of birth

Misund 2013 & 2014 [36, 37]

n = 29

preeclampsia

Misund 2013 & 2014 [36, 37]

n = 29

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

threatened preterm labour

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

In vitro fertilization

Sharp 2021 [42]

n = 77

traumatic childbirth
Infant demographic factors

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Vinall 2018 [43]

n = 36

gestational age

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

birth weight

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Greene 2019 [29]

n = 69

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Williams 2021 [44]

n = 119

Apgar score

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Vinall 2018 [43]

n = 36

sex

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

age
Infant health and care factors

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

Garfield 2015 [27]

n = 113

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Malin 2020 [46]

n = 164

clinicians’ perception of infant health

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Pisoni 2020 [49]

n = 29

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

Williams 2021 [44]

n = 119

parents’ perception of infant health

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Williams 2021 [44]

n = 119

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

mother-infant contact

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

number of NNU visits

Pisoni 2020 [49]

n = 29

mother-infant relationship

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

mother-nurse relationships

Rodriguez 2020 [40]

n = 146

Sharp 2021 [41]

n = 77

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Vinall 2018 [43]

n = 36

length of stay in NNU

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

intraventricular haemorrhage

Misund 2013 & 2014 [36, 37]

n = 29

ventilation support

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

severe bronchopulmonary dysplasia

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

vasopressors support

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Clark 2021 [25]

n = 67

number of invasive procedures

Vinall 2018 [45]

n = 36

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

palliative care consultation

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

seizures

Pisoni 2020 [49]

n = 29

infant’s general development

Kim 2015 [50]

n = 120

rehospitalisation or emergency visits
Parental history of mental health and trauma factors
history of mental health problems

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

family history of depression / mental health

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Malin 2022 [46]

n = 245

Sharp 2021 [41]

n = 77

previous traumatic events

Greene 2015 2019 [28, 29]

n = 69

Naeem 2019 [38]

n = 160

Sharp 2021 [41]

n = 77

traumatic childbirth
Parental postnatal mental health factors
postnatal depression

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Holditch-Davis 2009 [31]

n = 117

Jubinville 2012 [32]

n = 40

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Salomè 2022 [48]

N = 40

postnatal anxiety

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Garfield 2015 [27]

n = 113

Holditch-Davis 2009 [31]

n = 117

Moreyra 2021 [47]

n = 150

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

early PTS symptoms

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

other mental health symptoms

Chang 2016 [24]

n = 102

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Parent stress, coping and support factors

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

parental stressor scale total score

Sharp 2021 [41]

n = 77

Salomè 2022 [48]

N = 40

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

stress related to infant’s appearance

Holditch-Davis [31] 2009

n = 117

stress related to NNU sights and sounds

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

stress related to role alteration

Holditch-Davis [31] 2009

n = 117

Shaw 2009 [42]

n = 38

stress relating to staff relationships
concurrent stressors

Lefkowitz 2010 [34]

n = 130

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

forward-focused coping style
maternal optimism

Lotterman 2018 [45]

n = 91

Williams 2021 [44]

n = 119

worry about infant’s death
social support

Eutrope 2014 [26]

n = 100

Salomè 2022 [48]

n = 40

Brunson 2021 [23]

n = 50

psychological support
Other factors

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

military geographic separation

Anchan 2021 [22]

n = 106

active military service
spiritual activity

Hawthorne 2016 [30]

n = 165

Hawthorne 2016 [30]

n = 165

religious activities