Table 3.
Not statistically significant | FACTORS | Statistically significant | |||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Parent demographic factors | |||||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Garfield 2015 [27] n = 113 |
Greene 2019 [29] n = 69 |
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
Vinall 2018 [43] n = 36 |
age |
n = 29 |
||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Garfield 2015 [27] n = 113 |
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
education |
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
Vinall 2018 [43] n = 36 |
||||||||
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
Pace 2020 [39] n = 105 |
sex |
Moreyra 2021 [47] n = 150 |
Naeem 2019 [38] n = 160 |
||||||||
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
Moreyra 2021 [47] n = 150 |
ethnicity | ||||||||||||
parents ‘area deprivation |
Greene 2019 [29] n = 69 |
||||||||||||||
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
housing and access to transport | ||||||||||||||
family income |
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
||||||||||||||
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
employment status |
Naeem 2019 [38] n = 160 |
|||||||||||||
Malin 2020 [46] n = 164 |
single parent | ||||||||||||||
Pace2020 [39] n = 105 |
family social risk | ||||||||||||||
Pregnancy and birth factors | |||||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
parity |
Greene 2015 [28] n = 69 |
Kim 2015 [33] n = 120 |
||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
Pace 2020 [39] n = 105 |
multiple pregnancy | ||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
mode of birth |
n = 29 |
|||||||||||||
preeclampsia |
n = 29 |
||||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
threatened preterm labour | ||||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
In vitro fertilization | ||||||||||||||
Sharp 2021 [42] n = 77 |
traumatic childbirth | ||||||||||||||
Infant demographic factors | |||||||||||||||
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
Vinall 2018 [43] n = 36 |
gestational age |
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
||||||||
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
birth weight |
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Greene 2019 [29] n = 69 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
||||||||||
Williams 2021 [44] n = 119 |
Apgar score |
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
|||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Vinall 2018 [43] n = 36 |
sex | |||||||||||||
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
age | ||||||||||||||
Infant health and care factors | |||||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
Garfield 2015 [27] n = 113 |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Malin 2020 [46] n = 164 |
clinicians’ perception of infant health |
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Pisoni 2020 [49] n = 29 |
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
Williams 2021 [44] n = 119 |
||||||
parents’ perception of infant health |
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
Williams 2021 [44] n = 119 |
||||||||||
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
mother-infant contact | ||||||||||||||
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
number of NNU visits | ||||||||||||||
Pisoni 2020 [49] n = 29 |
mother-infant relationship | ||||||||||||||
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
mother-nurse relationships | ||||||||||||||
Rodriguez 2020 [40] n = 146 |
Sharp 2021 [41] n = 77 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
Vinall 2018 [43] n = 36 |
length of stay in NNU |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
|||||||||
intraventricular haemorrhage |
n = 29 |
||||||||||||||
ventilation support |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
||||||||||||||
severe bronchopulmonary dysplasia |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
||||||||||||||
vasopressors support |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
||||||||||||||
Clark 2021 [25] n = 67 |
number of invasive procedures |
Vinall 2018 [45] n = 36 |
|||||||||||||
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy | ||||||||||||||
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
palliative care consultation | ||||||||||||||
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
seizures | ||||||||||||||
Pisoni 2020 [49] n = 29 |
infant’s general development | ||||||||||||||
Kim 2015 [50] n = 120 |
rehospitalisation or emergency visits | ||||||||||||||
Parental history of mental health and trauma factors | |||||||||||||||
history of mental health problems |
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
||||||||||||
family history of depression / mental health |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Malin 2022 [46] n = 245 |
|||||||||||||
Sharp 2021 [41] n = 77 |
previous traumatic events |
n = 69 |
Naeem 2019 [38] n = 160 |
||||||||||||
Sharp 2021 [41] n = 77 |
traumatic childbirth | ||||||||||||||
Parental postnatal mental health factors | |||||||||||||||
postnatal depression |
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Holditch-Davis 2009 [31] n = 117 |
Jubinville 2012 [32] n = 40 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
Salomè 2022 [48] N = 40 |
||||||||
postnatal anxiety |
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Garfield 2015 [27] n = 113 |
Holditch-Davis 2009 [31] n = 117 |
Moreyra 2021 [47] n = 150 |
||||||||||
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
early PTS symptoms |
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
|||||||||||
other mental health symptoms |
Chang 2016 [24] n = 102 |
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
||||||||||||
Parent stress, coping and support factors | |||||||||||||||
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
parental stressor scale total score |
Sharp 2021 [41] n = 77 |
Salomè 2022 [48] N = 40 |
||||||||||||
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
stress related to infant’s appearance |
Holditch-Davis [31] 2009 n = 117 |
|||||||||||||
stress related to NNU sights and sounds |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
||||||||||||||
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
stress related to role alteration |
Holditch-Davis [31] 2009 n = 117 |
||||||||||||
Shaw 2009 [42] n = 38 |
stress relating to staff relationships | ||||||||||||||
concurrent stressors |
Lefkowitz 2010 [34] n = 130 |
||||||||||||||
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
forward-focused coping style | ||||||||||||||
maternal optimism |
Lotterman 2018 [45] n = 91 |
||||||||||||||
Williams 2021 [44] n = 119 |
worry about infant’s death | ||||||||||||||
social support |
Eutrope 2014 [26] n = 100 |
Salomè 2022 [48] n = 40 |
|||||||||||||
Brunson 2021 [23] n = 50 |
psychological support | ||||||||||||||
Other factors | |||||||||||||||
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
military geographic separation | ||||||||||||||
Anchan 2021 [22] n = 106 |
active military service | ||||||||||||||
spiritual activity |
Hawthorne 2016 [30] n = 165 |
||||||||||||||
Hawthorne 2016 [30] n = 165 |
religious activities |