Table 2.
Reference | Study design (quality assessment, %) | Platform | Social media approach | Social media application | Ethical considerations | Data collection | ||
Data extraction tool | Searching key terms | Number of posts/videos/articles | ||||||
Salmi et al (2020)44 | Qualitative study (85) | As a secondary data source | To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts | ‘Non-Human Subjects Research’ determined by the Institution Review Board. | Symplur | #BTSM, #HPM | 772 tweets | |
Padmanabhan et al (2021)45 | Cross-sectional study (85) | As a secondary data source | To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts and and to investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Exempt from ethical review determined by the Institution Review Board. | Symplur Signals | #palliativeCare | 182 661 tweets | |
Cutshall et al (2020)57 | Qualitative methods (65) | As a secondary data source | To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts | Not Human Subjects Research determined by the institutional review board. | Manually collected | #BTSM | 536 tweets | |
Taylor and Pagliari (2018)49 | Qualitative study (80) | As a secondary data source | To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts | Ethics approval was provided by the Institutional Review Board. Written agreement was sought and obtained. | Manually collected | @GrangerKate | 550 tweets | |
Claudio et al (2018)50 | Cross-sectional study (75) | YouTube, Facebook and Twitter | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Exempt from ethical review determined by the institutional review board. | Manually collected | “palliative care” (YouTube), “#palliativecare”, “#pallcare”, and “#palcare” (Twitter) | 25 tweets, 25 Facebook, 10 videos |
Mitchell et al (2017)58 | Mix-method study (70) | YouTube | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Not reported | Manually collected | ‘Advance Care Directive’ OR ‘ACP’ OR ‘Advance Care Plan’ | 42 videos |
Nwosu et al (2015)15 | Retrospective analysis (quantitative study) (83) | As a secondary data source | To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Non-human subjects, therefore ethics committee approval was not deemed to be necessary. | TopsyPro | #hpm #hpmglobal #eolc #Hospice care Liverpool care pathway | 683 500 tweets | |
Zhao et al (2020)13 | Quantitative study (64) | As a secondary data source | To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Not reported | Twitter API | “palliative care” and “palliative medicine” etc. | 371 880 tweets | |
Buis (2008)46 | Qualitative content analysis (90) | Yahoo! | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Was approved by a university institutional review board and adhered to guidelines for ethical research. | Manually collected | hospice | 443 posts |
Singh et al (2021)51 | Qualitative content analysis (75) | As a secondary data source | To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts | Ethical approval was obtained from the institutional ethics committee. Consent was waived. | Manually collected | #pallicovid and #COVID-19, palliative care OR COVID-19 OR death OR dying | 33 online articles and blogs | |
Guidry and Benotsch (2019)52 | Mix-method study (80) | As a secondary data source | To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Institutional review board approval was not required. | Manually collected | Chronic Pain | 502 pins | |
Patel et al (2022)53 | Mixed-method study (75) | As a secondary data source | To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Institutional review board approval was not required. | Twitter API | “DNR”, “DNI”,“advance directives,” “ECMO,” “CPR,” “dialysis,” and “ventilation,” “advance directives” etc. | 202 585 tweets about LSIs and 67 162 tweets about ACP | |
Easwar et al (2022)54 | Mixed-method study (74) | TikTok | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Not reported | Manually collected | ‘palliative.’ | 146 videos |
Lattimer et al (2022)59 | Mixed-method study (65) | As a secondary data source | To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation | Not reported | Twitter API | #nhdd, #advancecareplan, and #goalsofcare, healthcare decision day, advance care plan, goals of care. | 9713 tweets | |
Liu et al (2019)12 | Review (73) | YouTube | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Institutional review board approval was not required. | Manually collected | palliative care | 84 videos |
Wittenberg-Lyle et al (2014)55 | Review (75) | YouTube | As a secondary data source | To explore the quality and features of online resources | Not reported | Manually collected | pain and cancer; pain and hospice; pain and PC palliative care | 43 videos |
Levy et al (2019)47 | Experimental study (82) | Pixstori | As an information sharing platform | To deliver intervention | Was approved by the institutional review board. Written consent and media waiver were obtained. | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Taubert et al (2018)48 | Mixed-method design (88) | YouTube, Facebook and Twitter | As an information sharing platform | For promotion, education and training | No ethics approval was required. Consent and agreement were obtained. | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Akard et al (2015)10 | Survey (quantitative study) (79) | As an information sharing platform | To enhance recruitment opportunities | Was approved by the institutional review board. Consent was obtained online. | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
Biswas et al (2021)61 | Cross-sectional study (75) | Not reported | As an information sharing platform | To enhance recruitment opportunities | Was approved by the ethical review committee. Informed consent was obtained. | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Beringer et al (2017)60 | Qualitative methodology (45) | Self-built platform | As an information sharing platform | For promotion, education and training | Not reported | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
API, application programming interface.