Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 9;14(2):149–162. doi: 10.1136/spcare-2023-004579

Table 2.

Characteristics of included studies

Reference Study design (quality assessment, %) Platform Social media approach Social media application Ethical considerations Data collection
Data extraction tool Searching key terms Number of posts/videos/articles
Salmi et al (2020)44 Qualitative study (85) Twitter As a secondary data source To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts ‘Non-Human Subjects Research’ determined by the Institution Review Board. Symplur #BTSM, #HPM 772 tweets
Padmanabhan et al (2021)45 Cross-sectional study (85) Twitter As a secondary data source To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts and and to investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Exempt from ethical review determined by the Institution Review Board. Symplur Signals #palliativeCare 182 661 tweets
Cutshall et al (2020)57 Qualitative methods (65) Twitter As a secondary data source To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts Not Human Subjects Research determined by the institutional review board. Manually collected #BTSM 536 tweets
Taylor and Pagliari (2018)49 Qualitative study (80) Twitter As a secondary data source To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts Ethics approval was provided by the Institutional Review Board. Written agreement was sought and obtained. Manually collected @GrangerKate 550 tweets
Claudio et al (2018)50 Cross-sectional study (75) YouTube, Facebook and Twitter As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Exempt from ethical review determined by the institutional review board. Manually collected “palliative care” (YouTube), “#palliativecare”, “#pallcare”, and “#palcare” (Twitter) 25 tweets, 25 Facebook, 10 videos
Mitchell et al (2017)58 Mix-method study (70) YouTube As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Not reported Manually collected ‘Advance Care Directive’ OR ‘ACP’ OR ‘Advance Care Plan’ 42 videos
Nwosu et al (2015)15 Retrospective analysis (quantitative study) (83) Twitter As a secondary data source To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Non-human subjects, therefore ethics committee approval was not deemed to be necessary. TopsyPro #hpm #hpmglobal #eolc #Hospice care Liverpool care pathway 683 500 tweets
Zhao et al (2020)13 Quantitative study (64) Twitter As a secondary data source To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Not reported Twitter API “palliative care” and “palliative medicine” etc. 371 880 tweets
Buis (2008)46 Qualitative content analysis (90) Yahoo! As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Was approved by a university institutional review board and adhered to guidelines for ethical research. Manually collected hospice 443 posts
Singh et al (2021)51 Qualitative content analysis (75) Twitter As a secondary data source To engage stakeholders to understand their experiences or thoughts Ethical approval was obtained from the institutional ethics committee. Consent was waived. Manually collected #pallicovid and #COVID-19, palliative care OR COVID-19 OR death OR dying 33 online articles and blogs
Guidry and Benotsch (2019)52 Mix-method study (80) Pinterest As a secondary data source To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Institutional review board approval was not required. Manually collected Chronic Pain 502 pins
Patel et al (2022)53 Mixed-method study (75) Twitter As a secondary data source To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Institutional review board approval was not required. Twitter API “DNR”, “DNI”,“advance directives,” “ECMO,” “CPR,” “dialysis,” and “ventilation,” “advance directives” etc. 202 585 tweets about LSIs and 67 162 tweets about ACP
Easwar et al (2022)54 Mixed-method study (74) TikTok As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Not reported Manually collected ‘palliative.’ 146 videos
Lattimer et al (2022)59 Mixed-method study (65) Twitter As a secondary data source To investigate surveillance on the frequency, trend and features of public conversation Not reported Twitter API #nhdd, #advancecareplan, and #goalsofcare, healthcare decision day, advance care plan, goals of care. 9713 tweets
Liu et al (2019)12 Review (73) YouTube As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Institutional review board approval was not required. Manually collected palliative care 84 videos
Wittenberg-Lyle et al (2014)55 Review (75) YouTube As a secondary data source To explore the quality and features of online resources Not reported Manually collected pain and cancer; pain and hospice; pain and PC palliative care 43 videos
Levy et al (2019)47 Experimental study (82) Pixstori As an information sharing platform To deliver intervention Was approved by the institutional review board. Written consent and media waiver were obtained. Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable
Taubert et al (2018)48 Mixed-method design (88) YouTube, Facebook and Twitter As an information sharing platform For promotion, education and training No ethics approval was required. Consent and agreement were obtained. Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable
Akard et al (2015)10 Survey (quantitative study) (79) Facebook As an information sharing platform To enhance recruitment opportunities Was approved by the institutional review board. Consent was obtained online. Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable
Biswas et al (2021)61 Cross-sectional study (75) Not reported As an information sharing platform To enhance recruitment opportunities Was approved by the ethical review committee. Informed consent was obtained. Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable
Beringer et al (2017)60 Qualitative methodology (45) Self-built platform As an information sharing platform For promotion, education and training Not reported Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable

API, application programming interface.