Table 1.
Delivery method | Carrier | Target | Human cells | References | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lipid-based delivery systems |
↑ Easy to prepare ↑ Cost-effective ↓ Cytotoxicity ↓ Low efficiency ↓ Immunoresponse |
INTERFERin™ | Collagen I, HTRA1 | Chondrocytes | [36] |
Oligofectamine™ | ANGPTL4 | MSCs | [37] | ||
Lipofectamine 2000™ |
MMP13 | Chondrocytes | [117] | ||
miR-30a | Chondrocytes | [38] | |||
circRNA-CER | Chondrocytes | [108] | |||
SLUG | MSCs | [61] | |||
ADAMTS5 | Chondrocytes | [118] | |||
Lipofectamine RNAiMax™ |
NR1D1, BMAL1 | Chondrocytes | [119] | ||
miR-222 | MSCs | [102] | |||
Raptor | MSCs | [120] | |||
miR-221 | MSCs | [32, 60] | |||
Lipofectamine LTX™ |
miR-495 | MSCs | [94] | ||
XtremeGENE™ | AIMP1 | Chondrocytes | [23] | ||
Electroporation |
↑ Very effective ↑ Reproducible ↓ Cell damage |
Amaxa Nucleofector™ Technology |
RUNX2 | Chondrogenic progenitor cells | [53] |
MEK5, ERK5 | Multipotent progenitor cells | [66] | |||
Nanoparticles (NP) |
↑ Very effective ↑ Limited toxicity ↓ High costs |
LNCs, Span 80™ | REST | MSCs | [121] |
PLGA | RUNX2 | MSCs | [21, 42] | ||
p5RHH peptide | NF-kB | Chondrocytes | [43] | ||
Chitosan | MMP3/13 | Chondrocytes | [122] | ||
MNP/PEI | miR-335 | MSCs | [123] | ||
Quantum dot (QD) |
↑ Very effective ↑ Traceability ↓ Cytotoxicity |
QD-SMCC | SOX9 | MSCs | [46] |
RGD-β-CD-QD | RUNX2 | MSCs | [45] | ||
Extracellular vesicles (EV) |
↑ Non-immunogenic ↑ Stability ↓ Expensive |
HEK293T (EV) | GFP | HUVEC, MSCs | [47] |