Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Trials. 2024 Apr 9;21(3):322–330. doi: 10.1177/17407745231221152

Table 1.

Summary of phase I dose-finding designs for late-onset toxicities. TITE: Time to Event; CRM: Continual Reassessment Method; PRT: Predicted Risk of Toxicity; EM: Expectation Maximization; DA: Data Augmentation; EWOC: Escalation with Overdose Control; IR: Isotonic Regression; CDP: Conaway, Dunbar, and Peddada; BOIN: Bayesian Optimal Interval; POD-i: Probability of Decision interval; CFO: Calibration Free Odds.

Authors Type of design Method for pending data Available software

Model-Based
Cheung & Chappell (2000) TITE-CRM Weighting scheme R package dfcrm, R shiny TITE-CRM
Braun (2006) Generalized TITE-CRM Weighting scheme None listed
Bekele et al. (2008) PRT Model predicted risk of toxicity Windows software mdanderson.org
Mauguen et al. (2011) TITE-EWOC Weighting scheme None listed
Yuan & Yin (2011) EM-CRM EM algorithm None listed
Liu et al. (2013) DA-CRM Data augmentation process Windows software mdanderson.org
Yin et al. (2013) Fractional CRM Kaplan-Meier estimator R shiny fCRM, Github fCRM
Tighiouart et al. (2014) EWOC-Time to toxicity Cox proportional hazards model Web tool EWOC
Zheng et al. 2016 Bayesian logistic model Weighting scheme None listed
Chapple et al. (2019) TITE-IR Weighting scheme R package titeir
Andrillon et al. (2020) Survival-CRM Survival exponential model Github SurvivalCRM
Zhu et al. (2021) Rolling-CRM Truncated piecewise exponential model R package crmPack
Wages et al. (2023) TITE-CDP Weighting scheme R shiny TITE-CDP
Model-Assisted

Yuan et al. (2018) TITE-BOIN Bayesian data imputation R shiny TITE-BOIN
Lin & Yuan (2020) TITE-Keyboard Weighting scheme R shiny TITE-KEYBOARD
Zhou et al. (2021) Late onset BOIN Poisson process None listed
Xu & Lin (2022) POD-i3+3 Weighting scheme R Shiny podi3
Jin & Yin (2023) TITE-CFO Imputation potential outcomes Github CFO