Table 1.
Characteristics of the Diagnostic Delay Literature | Findings (N) |
---|---|
Top 10 genetic diseases investigated | Hereditary angioedema 26 |
Full list in the Supplemental Table 1 for other diseases | Familial Mediterranean fever 16 Inborn errors of immunity 12 Genetic autoinflammatory diseases 11 Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency 9 Pompe disease 8 Fabry disease 8 Duchenne muscular dystrophy 7 Severe Combined Immunodeficiency 6 Wilson disease 6 |
Number of patients in the studies | 3-18182 (range) 446 (mean) 68.5 (median) |
Top 10 countries investigated in diagnostic delay literature. | Multinational 46 Turkey 21 |
Full list in the Supplemental Table 1 | USA 21 Iran 15 UK 13 China 13 Italy 13 France 11 Spain 9 Germany 9 |
Economic development status of the countries as per OECD data | Multinational 46 Developed 132 Developing 81 Least economically developed 0 |
Study settings | Singel academic medical center 124 National registry 41 Multiple academic medical centers 37 International registry 18 Literature 14 Patient support group 9 National lab 4 Commercial Study 3 Newborn screening network 2 Billing data 2 Drug outcome survey 1 Not specified 1 National network 1 Diagnostic lab 1 National biobank 1 |
Diagnostic delay ascertainment method | Retrospective chart review 135 Patient questionnaire 35 Clinical assessment 28 Physician questionnaire 19 Literature 13 Retrospective chart review plus questionnaire 8 Not mentioned 5 EMR records 2 Patient and physician survey 2 Retrospective chart review + literature 2 Billing data 2 Clinical assessment and chart review 2 Biobank data 1 Multiple registries 1 Literature and clinical assessment 1 Patient assessment and interview 1 Prospective data collection 1 Patient questionnaire and assessment 1 |
Diagnostic criteria | Billed data 2 Biochemical 13 Biochemical and clinical 2 Biochemical and genetic 40 Clinical 46 Clinical, biochemical, and genetic 2 Clinical and genetic 10 Clinical or genetic 2 Demographic 12 Demographic and genetic 1 Genetic 41 Literature 3 Not reported 66 Self-diagnosed 3 Society criteria 12 Treated patients 4 |
Diagnostic delay definition | Symptom onset to diagnosis 226 Self-reported 8 Presentation to diagnosis 6 Birth to dx 4 Referral to diagnosis 4 Not reported 4 Literature 2 Billing event to diagnosis 1 Suspicion to diagnosis 1 Symptom onset to differential diagnosis 1 Disease related visit to diagnosis 1 Newborn screen date to diagnosis 1 |
Statistics to report diagnostic day | Median 114 Mean 102 Mean and Median 15 Not reported 9 Range 10 Average 9 |
Studies that reported disease specific diagnostic delay value | 203 |
Studies that reported disease specific diagnostic delay as a range | 7 |
Studies that report stratified sub analysis by characteristics of disease (eg, phenotype or genotype). | 49 |
Studies that measured diagnostic delay over time | 37 |
Studies that reported that diagnostic delay improved with time | 25 |
Studies that tested an intervention | 5 |
Studies suggested intervention. Improved diagnostic delay | 2 |
Interventions suggested | NONE 139 Awareness 44 NBS 23 Systems changes to clinical practice 19 More research 14 More genetic testing 10 Test family members 3 Multiple 3 Improved biochemical diagnosis 2 Algorithms 1 Study delay more as a concept 1 |