Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 May 31.
Published in final edited form as: Genet Med. 2024 Jan 17;26(4):101074. doi: 10.1016/j.gim.2024.101074

Table 1.

A summary table of the features of the diagnostic delay literature in genetic disease

Characteristics of the Diagnostic Delay Literature Findings (N)
Top 10 genetic diseases investigated Hereditary angioedema 26
Full list in the Supplemental Table 1 for other diseases Familial Mediterranean fever 16
Inborn errors of immunity 12
Genetic autoinflammatory diseases 11
Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency 9
Pompe disease 8
Fabry disease 8
Duchenne muscular dystrophy 7
Severe Combined Immunodeficiency 6
Wilson disease 6
Number of patients in the studies 3-18182 (range)
446 (mean)
68.5 (median)
Top 10 countries investigated in diagnostic delay literature. Multinational 46
Turkey 21
Full list in the Supplemental Table 1 USA 21
Iran 15
UK 13
China 13
Italy 13
France 11
Spain 9
Germany 9
Economic development status of the countries as per OECD data Multinational 46
Developed 132
Developing 81
Least economically developed 0
Study settings Singel academic medical center 124
National registry 41
Multiple academic medical centers 37
International registry 18
Literature 14
Patient support group 9
National lab 4
Commercial Study 3
Newborn screening network 2
Billing data 2
Drug outcome survey 1
Not specified 1
National network 1
Diagnostic lab 1
National biobank 1
Diagnostic delay ascertainment method Retrospective chart review 135
Patient questionnaire 35
Clinical assessment 28
Physician questionnaire 19
Literature 13
Retrospective chart review plus questionnaire 8
Not mentioned 5
EMR records 2
Patient and physician survey 2
Retrospective chart review + literature 2
Billing data 2
Clinical assessment and chart review 2
Biobank data 1
Multiple registries 1
Literature and clinical assessment 1
Patient assessment and interview 1
Prospective data collection 1
Patient questionnaire and assessment 1
Diagnostic criteria Billed data 2
Biochemical 13
Biochemical and clinical 2
Biochemical and genetic 40
Clinical 46
Clinical, biochemical, and genetic 2
Clinical and genetic 10
Clinical or genetic 2
Demographic 12
Demographic and genetic 1
Genetic 41
Literature 3
Not reported 66
Self-diagnosed 3
Society criteria 12
Treated patients 4
Diagnostic delay definition Symptom onset to diagnosis 226
Self-reported 8
Presentation to diagnosis 6
Birth to dx 4
Referral to diagnosis 4
Not reported 4
Literature 2
Billing event to diagnosis 1
Suspicion to diagnosis 1
Symptom onset to differential diagnosis 1
Disease related visit to diagnosis 1
Newborn screen date to diagnosis 1
Statistics to report diagnostic day Median 114
Mean 102
Mean and Median 15
Not reported 9
Range 10
Average 9
Studies that reported disease specific diagnostic delay value 203
Studies that reported disease specific diagnostic delay as a range 7
Studies that report stratified sub analysis by characteristics of disease (eg, phenotype or genotype). 49
Studies that measured diagnostic delay over time 37
Studies that reported that diagnostic delay improved with time 25
Studies that tested an intervention 5
Studies suggested intervention. Improved diagnostic delay 2
Interventions suggested NONE 139
Awareness 44
NBS 23
Systems changes to clinical practice 19
More research 14
More genetic testing 10
Test family members 3
Multiple 3
Improved biochemical diagnosis 2
Algorithms 1
Study delay more as a concept 1