Table 2.
Study | Sample | Method(s) | Measures | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Gonzalves et al. [23] | Sample: 1315 Spanish students (range age: 12–18) | Experimental study |
SRAS-R SDQ-II-Short Form |
Four different School Refusal Behaviour profiles: Moderately High School Refusal Behaviour(n 489, (37.2%)), Moderately Low High School Refusal Behaviour (n 433 (32.9%)) Mixed School Refusal Behaviour (n 177, (13.5%), Non-School Refusal Behaviour (n 216 - (16.4%). Mixed School Refusal Behaviour group was the most maladaptive profile and revealed the lowest mean scores on self-concept. |
Delgado et al. [26] | Sample: 1,102 Spanish high school students aged 12–18 years (mean age 14.30; SD 1.71). | Experimental study | SRAS-R |
Results showed 3 behaviour profiles: (1) SRB by negative reinforcements (419–38.02%) (2) SRB by positive reinforcements (389 -35.29%) (3) non-SRB students (267- 24.22%). The first group showed higher rates than the others in victimization, aggression, both, and observation of cyberbullying. |
Gonzalvez et al. [24] | Sample: 1,816 Spanish adolescents (range age: 15–18 years) | Experimental study |
PANAS-C-SF SRAS-R-C |
5 affective profiles: a) low affective profile (n = 40; 2.2%), b)self-fulfilling profile (n = 899; 49.5%),c) low positive affect profile (n = 698; 38.4%), d) self-destructive profile (n = 86; 4.7%), and e) high affective profile (n = 93; 5.1%). Statistically significant differences were found among profiles in the four conditions of SRAS-R-C (p < 0.001). |
Fujita et al. [25] | Sample: 227 students, aged 10–18 years, with any psychiatric disorder (except moderate-to-severe or profound intellectual disability), showing SRB, defined as at least 30 days of absence from classes, and Problematic Internet Use (PIU) | Observational cross-sectional analytical study |
IAT QCD GAD-7 PHQ9 |
46/112 (41.1%) students with SRB exhibited PIU, with an IAT score > 50. They showed lower CQD scores in each part of day except at night (p range 0,5 − 0,05) and significant higher scores in PHQ9 and GAD-7 tests and more frequently diagnosed with mood disorders. |
Ellen Kathrine Munkhaugen et al. [27] | Sample: 62 individuals (age range 9–16 y- mean age 12.3) whit ASD, without intellectual disability, divided into 2 groups: ASD plus SRB (n 33- 53.2%) and ASD without SRB (n 29) | Experimental study |
BRIEF SRS CBCL |
Significant difference between the two groups in: social functioning (p = 0.002) measured by SRB, in executive functions (p = 0.002) measured by BRIEF, in emotional and behavioural problems (p = 0.001) measured by CBCL. |
Vicki Bitsika et al. [28] | Sample: 67 mothers and their sons (age range 7–18 ), with ASD, bullying experience and school refusal (SR) | Experimental study | CASI-4 | Boys with SR had significantly higher GAD and MDD than boys without SR (p = 0.13) and the frequency of being bullied made a significant contribution to emerging SR (p = 0.004) |
Abbey j. McClemont et al. [29] | Sample: 97 parents with 154 children (age range 4–16 y) aged at least 18 with diagnosis of ASD (n = 36), ADHD (n = 16), ASD + ADHD (n = 31), other diagnosis (i.e., anxiety disorders, mood disorders, disruptive behaviour disorders, learning disorders, language/communication disorders, sensory/auditory processing disorders; n = 15), and no diagnosis (n = 56). | Brief Report | LIKERT scale | 35% of parents state that their child has never refused school because of bullying. A significant difference between groups in lifetime school refusal due to bullying (p < 0.001). Children with ASD + ADHD were more likely to have ever refused school because of bullying (68%) than children with ASD (28%) or no diagnosis (18%). |
Carpentieri et al. [30] | Sample: 103 adolescent with a mean age of 16.2 (SD ± 1.14), divided into two group: with school refusal (SRa) n = 28 and not school refusal (non-SRa) n = 75 | Experimental study |
HAM-A HAM-D YMRS GAF GFSS GFRS SWAP-200-A |
SRa showed higher anxious and depressive symptoms (HAM-A p = 0.036; HAM-D p = 0.031), lower level of global functioning (GAF < p < 0.001, GAF_past year p = 0.025), lower levels of social and role functioning (GFSS p = 0.003, GFRS p = 0.002), higher rates of Schizoid (p = 0.046) and Schizotypal (p = 0.034) personality disorders, lower Health Functioning (p = 0.001) and the Q Health Index (p = 0.002). |
Al Keilani and Delvenne [8] | Sample: 71 patients (age range: 8–16 years) from the Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Department of Queen Fabiola Children’s University Hospital, with an anxious school refusal behaviour (ASR) | Retrospective study | A checklist including: patient’s gender, status, age of onset of school refusal, age of assessment, duration of school refusal, associated events, life events, use of psychotropic medication, family psychiatric history and family composition, individual psychiatric history | Significant sex difference: 70.42% of male (p < 0.0003) with ASR. Risk factors: family separation (56.3%), conflict at home (27%), contact rupture with father (25.3%), maternal psychiatric illness (45.07%), paternal psychiatric illness (28.2%), academic difficulties (36.6%) and change school or moving home (19.7%). Concerning psychopathological diagnosis, anxiety (39.4%) and mood disorder (32.4%). |
Xavier Benarous et al. [31] | Sample: 191 adolescents aged 12–18 years (M = 15.0, 44% boys) | Retrospective chart review study |
C-GAF CGI-S DEP-ADO |
7% with SW/SR (n = 83) met HKM criteria (n = 14, M = 14.3, 64% boys), accounting for one in six adolescents with SW/SR. No significantly differ from the other forms or SW/SR in terms of demographic factors, academic performance or psychosocial factors. SW/SR and HKM + patients had higher rates of anxiety disorders (Odd Ratio, OR = 35.2) and lower rates of disruptive behavioural disorders (OR = 0.03). None of the HKM + reported use of illicit drugs, alcohol, compared to 25% of youths with other SW/SR. |
Behaviour Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF), Child and Adolescent Symptom Inventory-revision 4 (CASI-4), Children-Global Assessment of Functioning scale (C-GAF), Clinical Global Impressions-Severity scale (CGI-S), Child Behaviour Checklist (CBCL), General Anxiety Disorder-7(GAD-7), Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF), Global Functioning Social Scale (GFSS), Global Functioning Role Scale (GFRS), Hamilton Rating Scale for Anxiety (HAM-A), Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAM-D), Internet Use with Internet Addiction Test (IAT), Patient Health Questionnaire − 9 (PHQ9), Positive and Negative Affect Schedule Short Form (PANAS-C-SF), Questionnaire-Children with Difficulties (QCD), School Refusal Assessment Scale-Revised for Children (SRAS-R-C), Self-Description Questionnaire (SDQ-II-Short Form), Shelder-Westen Assessment Procedure for Adolescents (SWAP-200-A), Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS), Young Mania Rating Scale (YMRS)