Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 18;9(3):865–890. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12941

TABLE 2.

Comparison of in vitro patient derived cell culture models: practical aspects related to culturing procedures (non neural cell cultures e.g. fibroblasts/blood cells, iPSCs derived 2D neural cell cultures, 22 iPSCs derived 3D neural cell cultures, 22 direct reprogrammed neural cell cultures, 23 , 24 resected human brain tissue cultures. 25 , 26 , 27 , 28

Patient‐derived cell cultures Non neural cell cultures (fibroblasts/blood cells) IPSCs derived 2D neural cell cultures IPSCs derived 3D neural cell cultures Direct reprogrammed neural cell cultures Resected human brain tissue cultures
Basic characteristic Represents pathophysiology of general cellular processes, and metabolism, suitable for genetic screening Represents a broad range of neural cell types, providing a platform for disease modeling (synapses, electrical activity, neural proteins, neural networks, cell–cell interactions) Models in vivo like conditions, allows complex interactions, stuctural changes, cell type composition, neurogenesis, cell migration, neural connectivity, electrical activity Direct conversion to neural cells without going through the pluripotent state (synapses, electrical activity, neural proteins, basic properties of neural network, cell–cell interactions) Reflects in vivo conditions, preserves cytoarchitecture, cell type composition, neural connectivity, electrical activity of epileptogenic neural tissue, suitable for genetic screening
Primary cells or tissue sample Non neural cells Non neural cells Non neural cells Non neural cells Brain tissue

Presence of brain specific

de novo somatic variants

Limited (depends on primary cells) Limited (depends on primary cells) Limited (depends on primary cells) Limited (depends on primary cells) Yes (brainarea dependent)
Invasiveness of cell or tissue collection Non invasive (potentially invasive for obtaining skin fibroblasts) Non invasive (potentially invasive for obtaining skin fibroblasts) Non invasive (potentially invasive for obtaining skin fibroblasts) Non invasive (potentially invasive for obtaining skin fibroblasts) Invasive (brain surgery)
Developmental stage Patient's age Early stages of development Early stages of development Patient's age Patient's age
Demands for cell system establishment
Procedure Easy Challenging (requires iPSC generation from non neural cells and 2D neural differentiation) Challenging (requires iPSC generation from non neural cells and 3D neural differentation) Moderate Challenging (requires surgical resection of brain tissue; from a specific subgroup of patients)
Time Short (days–months)

Long (usually shorter than 3D cultures; 1–3 years)

Ref. [22]

Long (1–3 years)

Ref. [22]

Moderate (1–5 months)

Refs. [23, 24]

Short (days–months)

Refs. [25, 26, 27, 28]

Financial cost Low High (influenced by reprogramming and differentiation procedures) High (influenced by reprogramming and longer differentiation procedures) Moderate (influenced by direct reprogramming procedures) Low (excluding the financial cost of the surgery)

Abbreviations: 2D, two dimensional; 3D, three dimensional; iPSCs, induced pluripotent stem cells.