Skip to main content
. 2024 May 23;10(11):e31720. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31720

Table 6.

Advantages and disadvantages of steel and FRP tendons.

Type of Tendon Advantages Disadvantages
CFRP
  • 1

    Compared to other FRP it has the maximum strength

  • 2

    High resistance to elevated temperature

  • 3

    Moisture, acid, and solvent resistance at normal temperature

  • 4

    Cheaper than other FRP

  • 1

    The production process and techniques associated with CFRP composites are comparatively complicated.

  • 2

    CFRP tendons are more costly than steel tendons

GFRP
  • 1

    They are corrosion resistance

  • 2

    They don't have any kind of metal so they are not magnetic materials

  • 3

    They don't rust

  • 4

    GFRP rebars are lighter than steel rebars

  • 1

    They have poor rigidity

  • 2

    Their stiffness is low

  • 3

    At a temperature over 300 °C their application is limited.

AFRP
  • 1

    Low flammability

  • 2

    Perfect resistance to heat

  • 3

    Low electrical conductivity

  • 4

    High resistance to organic solvents

  • 1

    Their compression resistance is low

  • 2

    Under UV they will degrade

  • 3

    Low absorption of moisture

  • 4

    Weak adhesion of the resins

  • 5

    Their production cost is high

BFRP
  • 1

    Rust-proof and non-corrosive

  • 2

    Sustainable

  • 3

    The tensile strength of the BFRP tendons is 2.5 times greater than steel tendons while their weight is 4 times lighter than steel tendons

  • 4

    Durability performance

  • 1

    They have higher density compared to other FRP composite

  • 2

    Their production cost is usually higher than other FRP materials.

Steel Tendons
  • 1

    High impact load resistance

  • 2

    Their ductility is extreme

  • 3

    They have the same coefficient of thermal expansion as concrete.

  • 4

    The resistance capacity of steel materials is high against rough conditions.

  • 5

    They have a high MoE.

  • 6

    Without any problem, steel can be recycled.

  • 1

    Steel is a heavy-weight material.

  • 2

    Steel is a corrosive material, especially when in contact with water or air.

  • 3

    They also have the potential to rust and therefore the strength of RC will reduce.

  • 4

    Steel has a sensitivity to melt in badly high temperatures. Because of this, the steel is bound and not welded.