Table 2.
Authors | Selection | Comparability | Outcome | Overall quality |
---|---|---|---|---|
Airoldi et al 13 | ** | * | * | **/*/* |
Borggreven et al 14 | *** | * | ** | ***/*/** |
Bozec et al 15 | **** | * | ** | ****/*/** |
Bozec et al 16 | **** | ** | ****/ /** | |
Bozec et al 17 | ** | * | ** | **/*/** |
Bozec et al 18 | ** | ** | **/ /** | |
Chang et al 19 | *** | ** | ***/ /** | |
Dimovska et al 20 | ** | * | ** | **/*/** |
Elfring et al 21 | *** | * | * | ***/*/* |
Hartl et al 22 | ** | ** | **/ /** | |
Jimenez et al 23 | **** | * | ** | ****/*/** |
Klug et al 24 | *** | * | * | ***/*/* |
Lahtinen et al 25 | **** | * | ** | ****/*/** |
Markkanen-Leppänen et al 26 | ** | * | **/ /* | |
Momeni et al 27 | ** | ** | **/ /** | |
Oskam et al 28 | *** | * | * | ***/*/* |
Pierre et al 29 | *** | * | ** | ***/*/** |
Rhemrev et al 30 | **** | * | ** | ****/*/** |
Segna et al 31 | ** | * | * | **/*/* |
Smith et al 32 | *** | * | * | ***/*/* |
Tamer et al 33 | *** | * | ** | ***/*/** |
Yang et al 34 | ** | ** | **/ /** |
Each asterix represents the number of points accorded in each category. A maximum of 4 points could be given in the Selection category, a maximum of 2 points could be given in the Comparability category and a maximum of 3 points could be given in the Outcome category. Overall quality represents the number of points given in each category : Selection / Comparability / Outcome.