Skip to main content
. 2024 May 19;14(8):3150–3177. doi: 10.7150/thno.96270

Table 1.

Summary of experiments investigating the biophysical impacts of therapeutic ultrasound, where all effects are compared to a non-US group (i.e. LIPUS compared to SHAM, LPS+LIPUS compared to SHAM+LIPUS). For a more extensive compilation of the effect of LIPUS across cell types, see the review by Xu et al. 7.

Model Experiment LIPUS Parameters Biological effect
in vitro 76

macrophages: bone marrow derived
HUS
measured gene expression 3h post-US
LPS: 100ng/mL
measured inflammatory response to LPS 3h post-US, 1.5h with LPS (4.5h from start of US)
fc: 1 MHz
fR: 100 Hz
ISPTA: 3 W/cm2

Duration: 5 min
Duty cycle: 20%
Burst length: N/A
Transducer: plane
US: - apoptosis, ↑Irg1 (mRNA), ↑itaconate (mRNA), ↑Nrf2 (mRNA)
US+LPS: ↓IL-1b (mRNA), ↓IL-6 (mRNA), ↓Tnfα (mRNA)
Verified cell media did not exceed 37 oC
in vitro 81
microglia: BV-2
astrocytes: CTX TNA2
LIPUS
LPS: 1 μg/mL
LIPUS 12h post-LPS
Evaluation at 4, 8, 12, 24 h post-LIPUS
fc: 1 MHz
fR: 100 Hz
ISPTA: 10, 20, 30 mW/cm2

Duration: 15 min (3x5/5 on/off)
Duty cycle: 50%
Burst length: 5 ms
Transducer: plane
Microglia
LIPUS: ↑BDNF, ↑GDNF, ↑VEGF, ↑p-CREB/CREB, ↑p-Akt/Akt, ↑p-TrkB/TrkB
LPS+LIPUS:
↑BDNF, ↑GDNF, ↓VEGF, ↓TNFa, ↓IL-1b, ↓IL-6, ↑p-CREB/CREB, ↑p-Akt/Akt, ↑p-TrkB/TrkB, ↓TLR4, ↓MyD88, ↓p-JNK/JNK, ↓p-p65/p65, ↓iNOS
TrkB/Akt/CREB/BDNF pathway required for BDNF production
Akt inhibits JNK
Astrocytes
LIPUS: ↑BDNF, ↑GDNF, ↑VEGF,
in vitro 84
astrocytes: CTX TNA2
LIPUS
Evaluation at 4, 8, 12, 24 h post-LIPUS fc: 1 MHz
fR: 10 Hz
ISPTA: 110 mW/cm2

Duration: 15 min (3x5/5 on/off)
Duty cycle: 50%
Burst length: 50 ms
Transducer: plane
LIPUS: ↑BDNF, ↑p-TrkB/TrkB, ↑p-Akt/Akt, ↑Ca2+ influx, ↓p-CREB/CREB, ↑p-NF-kB p65/NF-kB p65, ↑p-p65/p65
in vitro 76

preosteoblasts: MC3T3-E1
LIPUS
mRNA measurement 0, 6, 24, 48h post-LIPUS fc: 1.5 MHz
fR: 1 kHz
ISATA: 30 mW/cm2

Duration: 20 min
Duty cycle: 25%
Burst length: 0.2 s
Transducer: N/A
LIPUS: ↑CD200 (mRNA) at 24h, ↑bone morphology genes
in vitro 190
osteoblasts: MC3T3-E1
LIPUS
LPS: 1 μg/mL
LIPUS/sham simultaneous with LPS
fc: 1.5 MHz
fR: 100 kHz
ISATA: 30 mW/cm2

Duration: 2 h
Duty cycle: N/A
Burst length: 0.2 ms
Transducer: N/A
LPS: ↑CCL2 (mRNA), ↑CXCL1 (mRNA), ↑ CXCL10 (mRNA), ↑RANKL (mRNA), ↑NF-kB (mRNA)
LPS+LIPUS: - CCL2 (mRNA), ↓CXCL1 (mRNA), ↓CXCL10 (mRNA), ↓RANKL (mRNA), ↓NF-kB (mRNA), ↓ERK/Akt/IKK/IRF3, ↓TLR4/MyD88 association
in vitro 114
endothelial: ECV 304
Applied laminar fluid shear stress to endothelial cell line Laminar fluid shear stress: 15 dynes/cm2 (1.6 Pa)

Duration: 5, 15, 30, 60 mins
Shear Stress: prolonged shear stress led to increased association between eNOS and HSP90, but did not lead to an increase in HSP90
in vivo 77

Female Sprague-Dawley rats
LIPUS
6-OHDA: 12μg
2μL of 6-OHDA injected into right striatum
6-OHDA model of Parkinson's Disease
Cellular evaluation at 8 weeks post-injection
fc: 1 MHz
fR: 1 Hz
ISPTA: 528 mW/cm2

Duration: 15 min (3x5/5 on/off)
Duty cycle: 5%
Burst length: 50 ms
Transducer: focused, single hemisphere
6-OHDA+LIPUS: ↓GFAP+ astrocytes, ↓Iba1+ microglia, ↓IL-1b, ↓p-NF-kB, ↑GDNF, - BDNF (insignificant increase), ↑BBB stability (ZO-1, claudin-5)


LIPUS started 2 weeks following 6-OHDA injection, LIPUS administered 5 days/week for next 6 weeks
Observed no tissue damage with LIPUS regimen
in vivo 97

Beagles (2-8 years old)
LIPUS
Wound healing in mucoperiosteal flap surgery fc: 1.5 MHz
fR: 1 kHz
I: 30 mW/cm2

Duration: 20 min/day
Duty cycle: N/A
Burst length: 0.2 ms
Transducer: 13 mm diameter
LIPUS: ↑HSP70 expression in gingival tissues (absent in control), ↑cementum and mandibular bone regeneration
LIPUS continued for period of 4 weeks following surgery
in vivo 78

Female C57BL/6 mice (7 weeks old)
LIPUS
LIPUS in model of repetitive restraint stress (RRS): 22 days
LIPUS in cuprizone (0.2% in chow) model of demyelination: 35 days
Analysis 24 hours following last LIPUS treatment
fc: 1.5 MHz
fR: 1 kHz
ISPTA: 25 mW/cm2

Duration: 20 min/day
Duty cycle: 20%
Burst length: N/A
Transducer: plane
LIPUS: ↑BDNF (hippocampus)

RRS+LIPUS: ↓anhedonia, ↑BDNF (hippocampus)
CUPRIZONE+LIPUS: ↑MBP (myelin basic protein, cortex), ↑NG2 (neural/glial antigen 2, cortex)
NG2 expressed in oligodendrocyte progenitors, and microglia
in vivo 79

Male C57BL/6 mice (8 weeks old)
LIPUS
LPS: 250 μg/kg
LPS administration from days 5-11
LIPUS treatment from days 7-13
Biological analysis at 4 (GFAP, Iba1, BDNF, CREB) and 48 h post-LIPUS
fc: 1 MHz
fR: 1 Hz
ISPTA: 528 mW/cm2

Duration: 15 min (3x5/5 on/off)
Duty cycle: 5%
Burst length: N/A
Transducer: focal, (D: 38 mm, ROC:63.5 mm; half-max pressure amplitude of focal zone - D: 3 mm, L: 26 mm)
LPS+LIPUS: ↑spatial learning and memory (Morris water maze, novel object recognition), ↓Aβ (hippocampus, but not cortex), ↓cleaved caspase-3, ↓GFAP, - Iba1 (non-significant decrease), ↓TNFa, ↓IL-1b, ↓IL-6, ↓p-NF-kB, ↓TLR4, ↑BDNF, ↑p-CREB
LIPUS: ↑BDNF, ↑p-CREB, ↑p-NF-kB (cortex), ↑TLR4
Increase in TLR4 and p-NF-kB in LIPUS group did not correspond to a significant increase in TNFa, IL-1b, or IL-6
in vivo 64
Vascular Dementia
Male C57BL/6 mice (10-12 weeks old), eNOS-/- (C57BL/6 background)
Alzheimer's Disease
Male 5XFAD transgenic mice (14-16 weeks old, C57BL/6 background)
LIPUS
LIPUS applied every other day following surgery (i.e. 1, 3, 5; BCAS or sham for vascular dementia)
LIPUS applied on days: 1, 3, 5, 28, 30, 32, 56, 58, 60, 84, 86 for AD model, testing on day 86
fc: 1.875 MHz
fR: 6 kHz
ISPTA: 90 mW/cm2

Duration: 20 min (x3: right, midline, left)/day
Duty cycle: 5%
Burst length: 17μs
Transducer: focal, (focus: 9 cm, beam width: 3.6-4 mm)
VaD+LIPUS - Molecular (day 3/7): ↓WM lesions, ↑angiogenesis and OPC genes (mRNA), ↑eNOS (both inactivated and activated; correlated with increased NGF, BDNF, VEGF), ↑GFAP, ↑Olig2+

VaD+LIPUS - Behavioural (day 28): ↑cognitive function (Y-maze, passive avoidance, novel object recognition, not all significant)

VaD+LIPUS - CBF: ↑CBF with LIPUS over time (start at day 2, continues to day 28)
VaD+LIPUS+eNOS-/- (with respect to VaD): - behavioural, - CBF, - WM lesions, - NGF, - BDNF, - VEGF
5XFAD+LIPUS: ↑HSP90, ↑CBF, ↑immune and angiogenesis genes (mRNA), ↑cognitive function (Y-maze), ↓Iba1+, ↑eNOS, ↑BDNF, ↓Aβ
Note: HSP90 not measured in VaD group, only 5XFAD
in vivo 80

Male C57BL/6 mice (8 weeks old)
LIPUS
Cortical Impact Injury (CCI) - model of traumatic brain injury (TBI)
LIPUS applied 5 mins post-CCI, daily thereafter
Analysis at day 1, 4, and 148
fc: 1 MHz
fR: N/A
ISPTA: 528 mW/cm2

Duration: 5 min/day
Duty cycle: N/A
Burst length: N/A
Transducer: focal, (focal diameter: 3 mm, focal width: 26 mm, diameter: 38 mm, ROC: 63.5 mm)
TBI+LIPUS (day 1): -MMP-9, ↓neutrophils, ↓Iba1+, -p-Foxo1, ↓neurological deficits
TBI+LIPUS (day 4): ↓MMP-9, ↓neutrophils, ↓Iba1+, ↑p-Foxo1, ↓neurological deficits
TBI+LIPUS (day 148): insignificant ↑BDNF+ neurons, ↑neurons, ↓T2w edema volume, ↓neurological deficits