Skip to main content
. 2015 May 7;2015(5):CD007428. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007428.pub3

NCT00871468.

Trial name or title Does anterior‐inferior clavicle plating have a lower rate of soft tissue irritation compared to superior plating? A prospective randomized trial
Methods Study design: parallel randomised controlled trial
Random sequence generation: not reported
Allocation concealment: not reported
Masking: double‐blind (just before surgery)
Participants Location: Texas, US
Target sample size: 90 participants
Inclusion criteria:
  • Active duty, reservists, National Guard service members

  • Completely displaced shaft fracture of the clavicle (no cortical contact between the main proximal and distal fragments)

  • Fracture involving the middle third of the clavicle (a fracture amenable to plate fixation with a minimum of 3 screws in each proximal and distal fragment)

  • Chronic non‐union and malunion fractures

  • No medical contraindications to general anaesthesia

  • Provided informed consent


Exclusion criteria:
  • Aged < 18 or > 65 years

  • Fracture in the proximal or distal third of the clavicle not amenable to plating

  • Pathological fracture

  • Associated head injury (a Glasgow Coma Scale score of < 15 at 21 days after injury)

  • Inability to comply with follow‐up

  • Medical contraindication to surgery or anaesthesia, or both (such as heart disease, renal failure, or active chemotherapy)

  • Lack of consent

Interventions Intervention 1 (Anterior‐inferior plate):
  • Open reduction and internal fixation with anterior‐inferior plate


Intervention 2 (Superior plate):
  • Open reduction and internal fixation with superior plate

Outcomes Outcomes: function or disability measured by: Constant score and DASH score; adverse events measured by: symptomatic hardware and hardware irritation requiring removal
Timing of outcomes measurement: 24 months
Starting date Main ID: NCT00871468
Date of registration: 26 March 2009
Last refreshed on: 31 March 2014
Date of first enrolment: 1 October 2008
Status: active, not recruiting
Contact information Name: not reported
Address: William Beaumont Army Medical Center ‐ El Paso, TX, US, 79920‐5001
Telephone: not reported
Email: not reported
Affiliation: William Beaumont Army Medical Center
Notes