Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 11;19(6):e0304560. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0304560

Table 11. The effect of academic freedom (AF) on innovation output (forward citations) when only considering years after 1980.

Model (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Dependent variable Forward citationst+5 (ln) Forward citationst+5 (ln) Forward citationst+5 (ln) Forward citationst+5 (ln) Forward citationst+5 (ln)
Statistic Coeff. (SE) Coeff. (SE) Coeff. (SE) Coeff. (SE) Coeff. (SE)
Independent variables
    AF (z) 0.137 (0.033)***
    AF (IV: Democracyt-5, z) 0.637 (0.086)***
    AF (IV: Democracy stockt-10, z) 0.650 (0.083)***
    AF (IV: AFt-5, z) 0.335 (0.052)***
    AF (IV: AF stockt-10, z) 0.372 (0.051)***
Controls
    Patent applications (ln) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
    Year/country dummies Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Countries (observations) 157 (4,719) 157 (4,571) 157 (4,453) 156 (4,576) 156 (4,424)
R2 (R2 adjusted) 0.913 (0.909) 0.907 (0.903) 0.907 (0.903) 0.913 (0.909) 0.912 (0.909)

Notes: The estimates are obtained from pooled OLS regressions. All variables are described in Table 1. Robust standard errors in parentheses.

* p < 0.10

** p < 0.05

*** p < 0.01.