After a trial lasting two years and hearing 157 witnesses, a six member jury in a Miami court awarded $145bn (£97bn) in punitive damages against five major US tobacco companies.
The class action lawsuit, originally filed by a husband and wife legal team, Stanley and Susan Rosenblatt, in 1994 on behalf of an estimated 300000-700000 smokers in Florida, created a sensation as the largest punitive damages award in US history.
The courtroom drama was heightened by the testimony of Frank Amodeo, aged 61, a former woodworker who had had throat cancer and whose larynx was destroyed by radiotherapy; he has been fed through a gastrostomy opening for 13 years.
“No amount of money in the world can change the way I eat—15 cents or 15 million dollars,” said Mr Amodeo. “This wasn't about money. This was about sending a message.” Mr Amodeo and Mary Farnan, who has had tumours removed from both lungs and from her brain, were chosen to represent the entire class of plaintiff Florida smokers.
In his address to the jury, Stanley Rosenblatt, the leading lawyer for the sick smokers, borrowed from Winston Churchill: “Never have so few caused so much harm to so many for so long, and the day of reckoning has arrived and you're going to pay the price.”
At a press conference in New York, William Ohlemeyer, chief counsel for the Philip Morris company, against whom the largest award ($73.9bn) was levelled, said, “Today's verdict is truly a verdict for no one,” and claimed, “We believe the verdict is grossly excessive and also illegal.”
He said that the tobacco companies would proceed as vigorously as possible to appeal. Several law professors agreed that an appeal was inevitable. “There is no way a judgment can be levied until the appeal process is concluded … and that could take years,” said John Coffee, a professor of law at Columbia Law School.
Figure.
AP PHOTO/WILFREDO LEE
The victors celebrate: Frank Amodeo, second from left, told the court: “This wasn't about money. This was about sending a message.”

