Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 18;14(28):19658–19679. doi: 10.1039/d4ra03017f

Comparison of the greenness profiles of the reported methods determining favipiravir in biological samples using Analytical Eco-Scale (AES), Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI) and Analytical GREEnness (AGREE) metric.

Method Analytical eco-scale GAPI AGREE Ref.
1 Reagents PPsa graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u1.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u2.jpg 29
Polycaprolactone-block-polydimethylsiloxane-block-polycaprolactone polymer 0
Methyl trimethoxysilane 2
Acetone 4
Methylene chloride 2
Trifluoroacetic acid 4
Methanol 6
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
Conditioning device (50 C × h) 2
Ultrasonic bath 2
Magnetic stirring 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 0
Total PPs 29
Eco-scale 71
2 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u3.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u4.jpg 32
Acetonitrile 4
Formic acid 6
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
LC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 21
Eco-scale 79
3 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u5.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u6.jpg 16
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Potassium dihydrogen orthophosphate 0
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
UHPLC 0
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 9
Eco-scale 91
4 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u7.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u8.jpg 33
Acetonitrile 4
Formic acid 6
Sodium dihydrogen phosphate 0
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
Ultrasonic bath 0
HPLC-DAD 1
Solvent evaporator 2
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 5
Total PPs 27
Eco-scale 73
5 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u9.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u10.jpg 23
Methanol 6
Acetic acid 4
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
Solvent evaporator 2
LC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 20
Eco-scale 80
6 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u11.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u12.jpg 15
Tetrahydrofuran 6
Menthol 1
Trichloroacetic acid 4
Acetonitrile 4
Potassium dihydrogen phosphate 0
Phosphoric acid 2
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 21
Eco-scale 79
7 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u13.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u14.jpg 28
Acetonitrile 4
Formic acid 6
Ammonia 6
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 29
Eco-scale 71
8 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u15.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u16.jpg 18
Acetonitrile 4
Formic acid 6
NaCl 0
Anhydrous magnesium sulphate 0
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
UHPLC-MS/MS 2
Solvent evaporator 2
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 26
Eco-scale 74
9 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u17.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u18.jpg 27
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
UHPLC-UV 0
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 15
Eco-scale 85
10 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u19.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u20.jpg 13
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Gadolinium(iii) chloride hexahydrate 1
Trihexyl (tetradecyl)phosphonium chloride 4
Dichloromethane 4
Perchloric acid 4
Tetrahydrofuran 6
Instruments
Reflux 2
Vacuum evaporator (drying) 2
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 33
Eco-scale 67
11 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u21.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u22.jpg 25
Acetonitrile 4
Methanol 6
Phosphate buffer 0
Dichloromethane 4
Instruments
Solvent evaporator 2
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 5
Total PPs 25
Eco-scale 75
12 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u23.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u24.jpg 21
Methanol 6
Acetic acid 4
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
LC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 15
Eco-scale 85
13 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u25.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u26.jpg 25
Methanol 6
Formic acid 6
Ammonium format 1
Acetonitrile 4
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
LC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 22
Eco-scale 78
14 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u27.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u28.jpg 20
Acetonitrile 4
Formic acid 6
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
LC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 21
Eco-scale 79
15 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u29.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u30.jpg 14
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Perchloric acid 4
Tetrahydrofuran 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 20
Eco-scale 80
16 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u31.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u32.jpg 19
Acetonitrile 4
Ammonia 6
Methanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
UHPLC-MS/MS 2
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 24
Eco-scale 76
17 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u33.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u34.jpg 31
Acetonitrile 4
Phosphoric acid 2
HCl 4
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 0
Waste 3
Total PPs 14
Eco-scale 86
18 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u35.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u36.jpg 24
Methanol 6
Ethyl acetate 4
Phosphoric acid 2
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
Solvent evaporator 2
HPLC-UV 1
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 21
Eco-scale 79
19 Reagents PPs graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u37.jpg graphic file with name d4ra03017f-u38.jpg 30
Brij-35 4
Methanol 6
Sodium dodecyl sulfate 4
Sodium dihydrogen phosphate 0
Propanol 6
Instruments
Vortex 0
Centrifuge 0
Solvent evaporator 2
UPLC-UV 0
Occupational hazard 3
Waste 3
Total PPs 28
Eco-scale 72
a

PPs for analytical eco-scale were calculated as per ref. 37 as follows: (1) reagent amount PPs: <10 mL (g) = 1; 10–100 mL (g) = 2; >100 mL (g) = 3. (2) Reagent hazard PPs: none = 0; less severe = 1; more severe = 2. Then total PPs = amount PPs × hazard PPs. (3) Energy PPs: ≤ 0.1 kWh per sample = 0, ≤ 1.5 kWh per sample = 1, > 1.5 kWh per sample = 2. (4) Occupational hazard PPs: analytical process hermitization = 0; emission of vapors and gases to air = 3. (5) Waste PPs: none = 0; <1 mL (g) = 1; 1–10 mL (g) = 3; >10 mL (g) = 5.