TABLE 2.
Clinical Studies on the Otoprotective Effect of STS (with a control group)
Author, Year | Design | Patient Characteristics | No.: STS Group | No.: Comparison Group | Platinum Treatment | STS Specification | Audiometry | FU Time | Hearing Function Outcomes | P | Adverse Events | Survival | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
With STS | Without STS | ||||||||||||
Studies in adults | |||||||||||||
Zuur et al,60 2007 | RCT: phase 3 | HNSCC Median age: 55 years |
78: CIS + STS + radiotherapy (70 Gy) | 80: CIS only + radiotherapy (70 Gy) | CIS + STS CIS IA; 4× 150 mg/m2 CIS only CIS IV; 3× 100 mg/m2 |
STS IV 9 g/m2 for 30 minutes + 12 g/m2 for 2 hours Concurrent with CIS |
PTA 0.25-16 kHz |
Median: 8 weeks post-Tx | HTL shifts >10 dB over time Mean HTL shift up to 4 kHz: 5.3 dB, and up to 12.5 kHz: 20.4 dB |
HTL shifts >10 dB over time Mean HTL shift up to 4 kHz: 8.9 dB, and up to 12.5 kHz: 19.0 dB |
<.001 (≤4 kHz) | NA | NA |
Ishikawa et al,53 2015 | Prospective cohort study | HNSCC Age: 45-82 years |
7: CIS + STS + radiotherapy (60-70 Gy) | 11: CIS only + radiotherapy (60-70 Gy) | CIS + STS CIS IA; 2-5× 100-180 mg/m2 CIS only CIS IV; 1-3× 66-85 mg/m2 |
STS IV 14 g/m2 for 4 hours Concurrent with CIS |
PTA 0.125-12 kHz |
1-3 weeks post-Tx | From baseline HTL shifts of 20 dB at 10 and 12 kHz |
From baseline HTL shifts of 15-25 dB at 8 and 10 kHz |
.028 .039 .016 .027 |
NA | NA |
Studies in mixed cohorts of children and adults | |||||||||||||
Neuwelt et al,62 1998 | Cohort study STS group: prospective Comparison group: retrospective |
Brain tumors Age: 2-68 years |
15: CARBO + STS 16 or 20 mg/m2 4: CARBO + STS 4 or 8 mg/m2 |
19: CARBO only | BBBD + CARBO IA over 10-min 400 mg/m2 per month 4-12 courses |
STS IV over 15 minutes 4-20 mg/m2 2 hours after CARBO |
PTA 0.25-8 kHz |
Each month during Tx | HL in 33% with STS 16 or 20 mg/m2a Average loss after first cycle: 3.7 ± 2.0 dB at 8 kHz |
HL in 79% Average loss after first cycle: 20.8 ± 5.9 dB at 8 kHz |
<.05 | Mild nausea, vomiting HN, ↑ blood pressure |
NA |
Doolittle et al,61 2001 | Cohort study STS group: prospective Comparison group: retrospective |
Brain tumors Age: 4-67 years |
24: CARBO + STS after 2 hours 17: CARBO + STS after 4 hours |
19: CARBO only | BBBD + CARBO IA over 10-min 400 mg/m2 per month 1-7 courses |
STS IV over 15 minutes 16 or 20 mg/m2 2 or 4 hours after CARBO |
PTA 0.25-8 kHz |
Each month during Tx | STS2h: HL in 52% HTL shift at 8 and 4 kHz: 41.7 dB and 35.4 dB, respectively STS4h: HL in 29% HTL shift at 8 and 4 kHz: 34.1 dB and 28.6 dB, resp. |
HL in 84% HTL shift at 8 and 4 kHz: 64.4 dB and 51.6 dB, respectively |
.001 (at 8 kHz) .0075 (at 4 kHz) |
NA | NA |
Studies in children and adolescents | |||||||||||||
Freyer et al,41 2017 | RCT: multicenter, open-label, phase 3 | Any tumor Age: 1-18 years |
49: CIS + STS | 55: CIS only | CIS IV 6× CIS + STS: 393 mg/m2 (290-420) CIS only: 387 mg/m2 (305-466) |
STS IV over 15 minutes 16 g/m2 6 hours after CIS |
PTA 0.5-8 kHz |
4 weeks post-Tx EFS + OS: median 3.5 years |
HL in 29% | HL in 56% | .00022 | Nephrotoxicity HP, HK |
EFS + OS in both groups: P = .36 and .07, respectively EFS + OS in LD (N = 77): P = .73 and .88, respectively OS in DD (N = 47): P = .009 |
Brock et al,40 2018 | RCT | SR HBL Age: 0-8 years |
57: CIS + STS | 52: CIS only | CIS IV 6× 80 mg/m2 |
STS IV over 15 minutes 20 mg/m2 6 hours after CIS |
PTA 1-8 kHz |
During Tx EFS + OS: median 3.0 years |
HL in 33% | HL in 63% | .002 | Neutropenia, HM, HP, HK | 3-yr EFS in CIS + STS group: 82%, 95% CI 69%-90%; in CIS alone group 79%, 95% CI 65%-88% 3-yr OS CIS + STS: 98%, 95% CI 88%-100%; CIS alone 92%, 95% CI 81%-97% |
Abbreviations: BBBD, blood-brain barrier disruption; CARBO, carboplatin; CIS, cisplatin; DD, disseminated disease; EFS, event-free survival; FU, follow-up; HBL, hepatoblastoma; HK, hypokalemia; HL, hearing loss; HM, hypermagnesemia; HN, hypernatremia; HNSCC, head and neck squamous cell carcinoma; HP, hypophosphatemia; HTL, hearing threshold level; IA, intra-arterial; IV, intravenous; LD, localized disease; NA, not assessed; OS, overall survival; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SR, standard risk; STS, sodium thiosulfate; Tx, treatment.
Most patients who received 4 or 8 mg/m2 developed hearing loss.