Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 4;13(6):692. doi: 10.3390/antiox13060692

Table 1.

Characteristics of the 250 studies included in the meta-analysis.

Author Publication Year Specific Study Characteristics Country of
Study
Assay Measuring Unit Assay Values SEM Extract/Chemical Compounds Group
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 110.36 3.08 Aqueous
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 78.00 0.87 Hydroalcoholic/12% ethanol
Chaiyana et al. [93] 2021 Thailand TPC mg GAE/g 9.40 0.12 Aqueous
Gullian-Klanian et al. [127] 2021 Canada TPC mg GAE/g 10.39 0.13 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2016 India TPC mg GAE/g 16.75 0.24 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2017 India TPC mg GAE/g 18.25 0.29 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Tavarini et al. [126] 2020 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 74.88 1.73 Aqueous
Ahmad et al. [85] 2020 China TPC mg GAE/g 6.97 1.65 Organic/DMSO
Zorzenon et al. [106] 2020 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 72.21 0.72 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 China Poland TPC mg GAE/g 22.28 0.01 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Poland Poland TPC mg GAE/g 16.14 0.07 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 India Poland TPC mg GAE/g 26.27 0.04 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Malaysia Poland TPC mg GAE/g 26.27 0.05 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Paraguay Poland TPC mg GAE/g 27.81 0.03 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Morocco Poland TPC mg GAE/g 14.91 0.24 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Egypt Poland TPC mg GAE/g 15.88 0.11 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Pakistan Poland TPC mg GAE/g 25.25 0.04 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Australia Poland TPC mg GAE/g 24.61 0.01 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Nigeria Poland TPC mg GAE/g 15.83 0.09 Organic/methanol
Kovačević et al. [92] 2018 100 °C Croatia TPC mg GAE/g 7.50 0.60 Aqueous
Kovačević et al. [92] 2018 130 °C Croatia TPC mg GAE/g 7.90 0.16 Aqueous
Kovačević et al. [92] 2018 160 °C Croatia TPC mg GAE/g 7.74 0.96 Aqueous
Atas et al. [87] 2017 Turkey TPC mg GAE/g 105.00 3.80 Organic/methanol
Barroso et al. [88] 2018 Frozen—dried Portugal TPC mg GAE/g 85.17 0.33 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Barroso et al. [88] 2018 Dried Portugal TPC mg GAE/g 126.65 1.22 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Formigoni et al. [98] 2018 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 5.54 0.09 Aqueous
S. Latha et al. [114] 2017 India TPC mg GAE/g 126.50 1.24 Hydroalcoholic/50% methanol
Milani et al. [105] 2017 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 23.61 0.10 Aqueous
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—maceration Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 4.456 0.01 Organic/ethanol
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—soxhlet Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 30.267 0.06 Organic/ethanol
Milani et al. [105] 2017 MeOH—soxhlet Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 41.63 0.19 Organic/methanol
Milani et al. [128] 2017 Brazil TPC mg GAE/g 187.66 0.11 Phenols/fraction
Yu et al. [107] 2017 China TPC mg GAE/g 71.46 1.44 Aqueous
Moselhy et al. [123] 2016 Saudi Arabia TPC mg GAE/g 30.00 0.87 Aqueous
Moselhy et al. [123] 2016 Saudi Arabia TPC mg GAE/g 85.00 1.44 Organic/acetone
Torri et al. [108] 2017 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 76.60 3.93 Aqueous
Javed et al. [102] 2017 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 4.52 0.02 Organic/acetone
Ruiz-Ruiz et al. [115] 2015 Mexico TPC mg GAE/g 28.40 0.87 Aqueous
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—9 Jul Italy TPC mg GAE/g 75.00 5.77 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—21 Jul Italy TPC mg GAE/g 40.00 0.58 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—10 Sep Italy TPC mg GAE/g 70.00 0.58 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Powder-leaf Italy TPC mg GAE/g 17.49 1.39 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Powder-leaf-organic Italy TPC mg GAE/g 89.49 1.44 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-company1 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 195.30 2.40 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-company2 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 149.06 6.58 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-Peru Italy TPC mg GAE/g 60.19 1.44 Aqueous
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Aqueous Poland TPC mg GAE/g 3.85 0.06 Flavonoids/fraction
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Ethanol Poland TPC mg GAE/g 7.65 0.06 Flavonoids/fraction
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Glycol–aqueous Poland TPC mg GAE/g 15.50 0.23 Flavonoids/fraction
Periche et al. [119] 2015 90 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 93.41 2.89 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 50 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 80.00 1.44 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 Microwave Spain TPC mg GAE/g 81.00 3.35 Aqueous
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying—180 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 76.80 1.02 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Shade-drying Spain TPC mg GAE/g 39.10 0.61 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying—100 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 31.50 0.41 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Freeze-drying Spain TPC mg GAE/g 26.20 1.14 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 MoritaII Mexico TPC mg GAE/g 28.70 0.88 Organic/methanol
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 Criolla Mexico TPC mg GAE/g 28.40 0.87 Organic/methanol
Periche et al. [117] 2014 50 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 65.20 1.15 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 70 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 71.02 1.21 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 90 °C Spain TPC mg GAE/g 92.07 1.15 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 1 min Spain TPC mg GAE/g 71.70 2.25 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 5 min Spain TPC mg GAE/g 75.71 1.73 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 20 min Spain TPC mg GAE/g 77.34 2.02 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 40 min Spain TPC mg GAE/g 79.63 2.05 Aqueous
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2009 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 52.23 2.25 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2009 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 48.12 3.97 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2010 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 66.90 5.83 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2010 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 54.91 4.66 Organic/methanol
Shivanna et al. [113] 2013 India TPC mg GAE/g 91.00 1.77 Organic/methanol
Shukla et al. [111] 2012 India TPC mg GAE/g 56.73 2.25 Aqueous
Shukla et al. [111] 2009 India TPC mg GAE/g 2.77 0.10 Organic/ethanol
Alshawwa et al. [86] 2022 Chloroform–methanol Saudi Arabia TPC mg GAE/g 26.25 0.12 Organic/chloroform–methanol
Alshawwa et al. [86] 2022 Acetone Saudi Arabia TPC mg GAE/g 2.38 0.04 Organic/acetone
Alshawwa et al. [86] 2022 Ethyl acetate Saudi Arabia TPC mg GAE/g 18.00 0.09 Organic/ethyl acetate
El-Hadary et al. [96] 2021 Egypt TPC mg GAE/g 12.80 0.36 Hydroalcoholic/80% ethanol
Judickaitė et al. [103] 2022 Lithuania TPC mg GAE/g 13.00 0.05 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Sheikhalipour et al. [125] 2021 Iran TPC mg GAE/g 30.50 0.50 Hydroalcoholic/85% methanol
Oviedo-Pereira et al. [124] 2022 Mexico TPC mg GAE/g 20.00 1.39 Hydroalcoholic /75% ethanol
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt TPC mg GAE/g 21.50 0.75 Organic/methanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-1 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 155.00 6.60 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-2 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 175.95 2.40 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-3 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 117.72 2.88 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-4 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 93.39 4.17 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-5 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 63.01 2.48 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-6 Italy TPC mg GAE/g 64.39 0.50 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Judickaitė et al. [104] 2023 Lithuania TPC mg GAE/g 81.07 9.37 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Kaushik et al. [121] 2010 India TPC mg TAE/g 42.00 5.77 Organic/acetonitrile
Tavarini et al. [126] 2020 Italy TFC mg CE/g 71.13 1.38 Aqueous
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—9 Jul Italy TFC mg CE/g 70.00 3.61 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—21 Jul Italy TFC mg CE/g 31.00 6.99 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—10 Sep Italy TFC mg CE/g 71.00 4.68 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Periche et al. [119] 2015 90 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 58.00 2.94 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 50 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 43.00 1.62 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 Microwave Spain TFC mg CE/g 45.00 4.33 Aqueous
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying—180 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 45.10 0.61 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Shade-drying Spain TFC mg CE/g 20.30 0.31 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying—100 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 17.20 0.20 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Freeze-drying Spain TFC mg CE/g 9.90 0.20 Hydroalcoholic/60% ethanol
Periche et al. [117] 2014 50 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 32.47 1.15 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 70 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 47.53 1.04 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 90 °C Spain TFC mg CE/g 56.72 1.21 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 1 min Spain TFC mg CE/g 44.64 0.58 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 5 min Spain TFC mg CE/g 45.93 1.01 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 20 min Spain TFC mg CE/g 45.77 1.07 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 40 min Spain TFC mg CE/g 44.26 1.04 Aqueous
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-1 Italy TFC mg CE/g 128.08 0.81 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-2 Italy TFC mg CE/g 150.24 4.57 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-3 Italy TFC mg CE/g 105.34 5.80 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-4 Italy TFC mg CE/g 39.46 0.94 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-5 Italy TFC mg CE/g 31.04 0.09 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-6 Italy TFC mg CE/g 28.32 0.97 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil TFC mg QE/g 71.79 0.01 Aqueous
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil TFC mg QE/g 56.66 0.53 Hydroalcoholic/12% ethanol
Chaiyana et al. [93] 2021 Thailand TFC mg QE/g 8.10 0.06 Aqueous
Gullian-Klanian et al. [127] 2021 Canada TFC mg QE/g 71.30 1.10 Hydroalcoholic/80% ethanol
Ahmad et al. [85] 2020 China TFC mg QE/g 4.44 0.90 Organic/DMSO
Atas et al. [87] 2017 Turkey TFC mg QE/g 95.00 2.37 Organic/methanol
Formigoni et al. [98] 2018 Brazil TFC mg QE/g 1.53 0.05 Aqueous
Milani et al. [105] 2017 Brazil TFC mg QE/g 176.33 10.00 Aqueous
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—maceration Brazil TFC mg QE/g 17.16 1.22 Organic/ethanol
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—Soxhlet Brazil TFC mg QE/g 19.60 0.10 Organic/ethanol
Milani et al. [105] 2017 MeOH—Soxhlet Brazil TFC mg QE/g 21.45 3.06 Organic/methanol
Milani et al. [128] 2017 Brazil TFC mg QE/g 0.14 0.04 Phenols/fraction
Moselhy et al. [123] 2016 Saudi Arabia TFC mg QE/g 40.00 2.94 Aqueous
Moselhy et al. [123] 2016 Saudi Arabia TFC mg QE/g 80.00 4.68 Organic/acetone
Javed et al. [102] 2017 Italy TFC mg QE/g 3.81 0.04 Organic/acetone
Ruiz-Ruiz et al. [115] 2015 Mexico TFC mg QE/g 36.70 2.94 Aqueous
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Phenols Poland TFC mg QE/g 2.03 0.06 Phenols/fraction
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Phenols Poland TFC mg QE/g 2.25 0.03 Phenols/fraction
Gaweł-Bęben et al. [99] 2015 Phenols Poland TFC mg QE/g 3.85 0.06 Phenols/fraction
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 MoritaII Mexico TFC mg QE/g 39.30 3.00 Organic/methanol
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 Criolla Mexico TFC mg QE/g 36.70 2.94 Organic/methanol
Shivanna et al. [113] 2013 India TFC mg QE/g 23.00 1.13 Organic/methanol
El-Hadary et al. [96] 2021 Egypt TFC mg QE/g 2.31 0.31 Hydroalcoholic 80% ethanol
Oviedo-Pereira et al. [124] 2022 Mexico TFC mg QE/g 16.25 1.21 Hydroalcoholic 75% ethanol
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt TFC mg QE/g 3.60 0.10 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 China Poland TFC mg RUE/g 10.19 0.11 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Poland Poland TFC mg RUE/g 12.94 0.19 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 India Poland TFC mg RUE/g 6.60 0.29 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Malaysia Poland TFC mg RUE/g 6.51 0.10 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Paraguay Poland TFC mg RUE/g 5.87 0.14 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Morocco Poland TFC mg RUE/g 12.99 0.23 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Egypt Poland TFC mg RUE/g 12.50 0.14 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Pakistan Poland TFC mg RUE/g 7.32 0.04 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Australia Poland TFC mg RUE/g 9.18 0.05 Organic/methanol
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Nigeria Poland TFC mg RUE/g 12.38 0.16 Organic/methanol
S. Latha et al. [114] 2017 India TFC mg RUE/g 128.30 5.02 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Torri et al. [108] 2017 Italy TFC mg RUE/g 34.30 2.94 Aqueous
Judickaitė et al. [103] 2022 Lithuania TFC mg RUE/g 4.30 0.01 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Judickaitė et al. [103] 2023 Lithuania TFC mg RUE/g 56.17 2.14 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
El-Hadary et al. [96] 2021 Egypt ABTS % 42.33 0.55 Hydroalcoholic/80% ethanol
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil ABTS µmol TE/g 680.00 5.77 Aqueous
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil ABTS µmol TE/g 660.00 34.64 Hydroalcoholic/12% ethanol
Gullian-Klanian et al. [127] 2021 Canada ABTS µmol TE/g 510.90 2.50 Hydroalcoholic/80% methanol
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 MoritaII Mexico ABTS µmol TE/g 311.20 10.00 Organic/methanol
Ruiz et al. [116] 2015 Criolla Mexico ABTS µmol TE/g 316.60 11.00 Organic/methanol
Chaiyana et al. [93] 2021 Thailand DPPH % 89.00 0.58 Aqueous
Gullian-Klanian et al. [127] 2021 Canada DPPH % 19.50 1.30 Hydroalcoholic
Ahmad et al. [85] 2020 China DPPH % 48.03 2.50 Organic
Zorzenon et al. [106] 2020 Brazil DPPH % 87.47 0.11 Hydroalcoholic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 China Poland DPPH % 24.04 0.17 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Poland Poland DPPH % 48.16 0.29 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 India Poland DPPH % 21.05 0.08 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Malaysia Poland DPPH % 32.69 0.30 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Paraguay Poland DPPH % 29.10 0.27 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Morocco Poland DPPH % 43.25 0.33 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Egypt Poland DPPH % 47.04 0.24 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Pakistan Poland DPPH % 20.58 0.08 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Australia Poland DPPH % 20.23 0.11 Organic
Dyduch-Siemińska et al. [95] 2020 Nigeria Poland DPPH % 45.08 0.25 Organic
Atas et al. [87] 2017 Turkey DPPH % 35.00 0.33 Organic
Formigoni et al. [98] 2018 Brazil DPPH % 88.72 0.66 Aqueous
S. Latha et al. [114] 2017 India DPPH % 77.13 1.00 Hydroalcoholic
S. Latha et al. [114] 2017 India DPPH % 67.23 1.00 Glycosides/stevioside
Milani et al. [105] 2017 Brazil DPPH % 42.26 0.64 Aqueous
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—maceration Brazil DPPH % 80.00 1.00 Organic
Milani et al. [105] 2017 EtOH—Soxhlet Brazil DPPH % 87.00 1.00 Organic
Milani et al. [105] 2017 MeOH—Soxhlet Brazil DPPH % 93.00 1.00 Organic
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2009 Italy DPPH % 87.61 0.66 Organic
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2009 Italy DPPH % 87.12 0.47 Organic
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2010 Italy DPPH % 88.84 0.47 Organic
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2010 Italy DPPH % 88.41 0.45 Organic
Shukla et al. [111] 2012 India DPPH % 72.37 1.00 Aqueous
Shukla et al. [112] 2009 India DPPH % 68.76 0.64 Organic
El-Hadary et al. [96] 2021 Egypt DPPH % 44.15 0.64 Hydroalcoholic
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt DPPH % 78.00 1.00 Organic
Ahmad et al. [85] 2020 China DPPH mg AAE/g 13.70 1.73 Organic
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—9 Jul Italy DPPH mg AAE/g 14.44 0.15 Hydroalcoholic
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—21 Jul Italy DPPH mg AAE/g 14.09 0.13 Hydroalcoholic
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—10 Sep Italy DPPH mg AAE/g 14.26 0.14 Hydroalcoholic
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt DPPH mg AAE/g 3.50 0.50 Organic
Judickaitė et al. [103] 2022 Lithuania DPPH mg RUE/g 48.00 0.10 Hydroalcoholic
Judickaitė et al. [104] 2023 Lithuania DPPH mg RUE/g 32.15 0.93 Hydroalcoholic
Gullian-Klanian et al. [127] 2021 Canada DPPH mg TE/g 24.49 0.51 Hydroalcoholic
Tavarini et al. [126] 2020 Italy DPPH mg TE/g 40.30 0.29 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 90 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 131.00 2.89 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 50 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 81.00 5.77 Aqueous
Periche et al. [119] 2015 Microwave Spain DPPH mg TE/g 96.00 2.60 Aqueous
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying at 180 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 126.00 0.31 Hydroalcoholic
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Shade-drying Spain DPPH mg TE/g 75.90 0.05 Hydroalcoholic
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Drying at 100 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 64.90 0.33 Hydroalcoholic
Periche et al. [118] 2015 Freeze-drying Spain DPPH mg TE/g 48.50 0.29 Hydroalcoholic
Periche et al. [117] 2014 50 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 62.45 0.46 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 70 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 106.68 0.43 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 90 °C Spain DPPH mg TE/g 119.12 0.43 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 1 min Spain DPPH mg TE/g 87.96 2.60 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 5 min Spain DPPH mg TE/g 89.26 2.60 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 20 min Spain DPPH mg TE/g 102.64 2.89 Aqueous
Periche et al. [117] 2014 40 min Spain DPPH mg TE/g 104.48 2.89 Aqueous
Chaiyana et al. [93] 2021 Thailand FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 210.00 2.89 Aqueous
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2009 Italy FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 495.54 107.7 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2009 Italy FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 471.70 24.18 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 Jesi-2010 Italy FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 690.33 75.95 Organic/methanol
Tavarini et al. [109] 2013 PieveCesato-2010 Italy FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 621.89 62.19 Organic/methanol
Devi et al. [94] 2023 India FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 154.79 0.69 Organic/methanol
Devi et al. [94] 2023 India FRAP μmol Fe2+/g 149.64 1.73 Organic/chloroform
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 220.00 5.77 Aqueous
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 230.00 1.73 Hydroalcoholic/12% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [126] 2020 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 532.00 11.55 Aqueous
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—9 Jul Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 580.00 7.51 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—21 Jul Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 251.00 18.48 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [110] 2015 Harvest time—10 Sep Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 460.00 15.01 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-1 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 1510.00 80.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-2 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 2310.00 100.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-3 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 1250.00 60.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-4 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 940.00 30.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-5 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 680.00 20.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Bugliani et al. [91] 2022 Chemotype-6 Italy FRAP μmol ΤΕ/g 590.00 10.00 Hydroalcoholic/70% ethanol
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 510.35 8.34 Aqueous
Andrade et al. [120] 2021 Brazil ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 454.89 0.63 Hydroalcoholic/12% ethanol
Tavarini et al. [126] 2020 Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 2231.19 61.31 Aqueous
Torri et al. [108] 2017 Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 648.00 3.67 Aqueous
Lemus-Mondaca et al. [28] 2016 Chile ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 222.59 4.60 Hydroalcoholic/50% ethanol
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Powder-leaf Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 275.70 11.55 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Powder-leaf organic Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 958.80 54.96 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-company1 Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 971.10 8.66 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-company2 Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 1040.00 25.98 Aqueous
Bender et al. [89] 2015 Leaf-Peru Italy ORAC μmol ΤΕ/g 1071.00 4.62 Aqueous
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2016 India SOD U/g 79.00 0.50 Fresh leaf extract
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2017 India SOD U/g 104.00 1.00 Fresh leaf extract
Borbély et al. [90] 2021 Portugal SOD U/g 112.50 2.00 Fresh leaf extract
Sheikhalipour et al. [125] 2021 Iran SOD U/mg protein 3.30 0.05 Fresh leaf extract
Ghorbani et al. [101] 2023 China SOD U/mg protein 98.00 0.45 Fresh leaf extract
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2016 India CAT U/g 22.00 1.00 Fresh leaf extract
Gerami et al. [100] 2020 Iran CAT U/g 550.00 40.41 Fresh leaf extract
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt CAT U/g 0.15 0.01 Fresh leaf extract
Sheikhalipour et al. [125] 2021 Iran CAT U/mg protein 5.50 0.10 Fresh leaf extract
Ghorbani et al. [101] 2023 China CAT U/mg protein 99.00 0.41 Fresh leaf extract
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2016 India POX U/g 21.00 1.00 Fresh leaf extract
Mahajan et al. [122] 2021 2017 India POX U/g 40.00 1.00 Fresh leaf extract
Elsayed et al. [97] 2022 Egypt POX U/g 0.34 0.01 Fresh leaf extract
Gerami et al. [100] 2020 Iran MDA mM/g 1.70 0.12 Fresh leaf extract
Sheikhalipour et al. [125] 2021 Iran MDA mM/g 1.80 0.15 Fresh leaf extract
Ghorbani et al. [101] 2023 China MDA mM/g 2.35 0.12 Fresh leaf extract

TPC: total phenolic content; TFC: total flavonoid content; ABTS: {2,2′–azinobis-(3-ethyl-benzothiazoline-6-sulphonicacid)}; DPPH: 2,2-Diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl; FRAP: ferric reducing antioxidant power; ORAC: oxygen radical absorbance capacity; SOD: superoxide dismutase; CAT: catalase; POX: peroxidase; MDA: malondialdehyde; GAE: gallic acid equivalent; TAE: tannic acid equivalent; CE: catechin equivalent; QE: quercetin equivalent; RUE: rutin equivalent; ΤΕ: Trolox equivalent; EtOH: ethanol; Hydroalcoholic: a solvent mixture of water and alcohol.