Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 25;13(6):20. doi: 10.1167/tvst.13.6.20

Table 2.

Quality Assessment for All 12 Included Studies

(A) RCTs
Internal Validity
Selection and Allocation Administration of Intervention Assessment, Detection, and Measurement of Outcome Participant Retention Statistical Validity
Citation Outcome 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Cehajic-Kapetanovic et al.18 Number of retinotomies Yes Yes Yes Unclear No Yes Unclear Yes Unclear Yes No Yes Yes
Volume of tPA injected Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Duration of tPA injection Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Duration of surgery Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes
BCVA Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Successful displacement of submacular hemorrhage Unclear Yes Unclear Yes No Yes
Frequency of microtraumatic events Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Edwards et al.8 Surgical success Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Unclear Yes Unclear Yes Yes N/A Yes
Duration of surgery No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Time required to position instrument No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Time required to initiate membrane flap No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Frequency of microtraumatic events No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Surgeons’ descriptive experiences No Yes Unclear Yes Yes N/A
Faridpooya et al.20 Feasibility No No Yes No No Yes Unclear Yes Unclear Yes No N/A Yes
Duration of surgery (and substeps) Unclear Yes Yes Yes No N/A
Mean distance traveled by forceps Unclear Yes Yes Yes No N/A
Change in BCVA Unclear Yes No Yes No N/A
Change in central retinal thickness Unclear Yes Unclear Yes No N/A
Frequency of adverse events Unclear Yes Unclear Yes No N/A
(B) Case series
Citation 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Bourcier et al.17 No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Cereda et al.19 No No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes No Not applicable
Gijbels et al.21 No Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear No No No No Not applicable
Mattheis et al.23 No Yes Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes No Not applicable
Turgut et al.24 No Unclear Unclear Unclear Yes No No No No Not applicable
Wang et al.7 Yes Yes Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Willekens et al.25 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
(C) Case reports
Citation 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Bourcier et al.9 No No Yes Yes Yes No No Yes
Jeannon et al.22 Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Unclear No Yes

Joanna Briggs Tools for Critical Appraisal were used for quality assessment; different instruments were employed for each study design observed. Quality of reporting ranged from fair to good, but sample size was ubiquitously low. BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity.