Table 2.
Commercial IVD/IVDR/FDA assaya | Laboratory-developed test (in-house/custom) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Process | Tools, material | Steps to be fulfilled | Steps to be fulfilled | Specifications and TP53-CLL-specific notes | ||
Test familiarization | Explore the clinical and analytical needs | Define turnaround time, costs, number of samples, instrumentation, personnel, etc. | Standalone or panel assay | |||
Test development | Study available technologies | Choose a commercial method | Test design |
Regions to be sequenced Library preparation method Sequencing technology Bioinformatics |
||
Determine required test performance metrics and sequencing settings |
Aim to detect low-VAF variants Consider: DNA input, coverage (each base of TP53 gene has to meet the minimum read depth) |
|||||
Prepare SOP | ||||||
Optimization |
Perform pilot run(s) Reference material Non-DNA controls |
General assessment of method applicability for the purpose | Identify and solve errors and weaknesses | |||
Check if the required parameters are met | ||||||
Set the critical values (pass/fail criteria) |
Output library quality and quantity Sequencing performance (level of background noise/overall error rate, coverage non-uniformity, low/high coverage, base call quality metrics etc.) |
|||||
Verification/validation | Reference material (different from the material used during optimization) | Verification | Prepare verification protocol | Validation | Prepare validation protocol | |
Test the ranges provided by the manufacturer and technical variables in the laboratory | Include variables influencing assay performance |
Amount of input DNA Number, type of samples in sequencing run Sequencing machine and other instruments Personnel |
||||
Verify the values provided by the manufacturer | Assess parameters describing the test performance |
Limit of blank, limit of detection Repeatability, reproducibility Proportion of true/false positives/negatives, etc. (See Supplementary Table 3) |
||||
Quality control (QC) and continuous monitoring |
Diagnostic samples Regularly analyzed positive and negative controls |
Monitor of specimen parameters | Sample purity, DNA quality, etc. | |||
Check variant profile | Proportion of TP53-mut/del(17p) and low-burden TP53 mutations, variant profile (Figs. 1, 4, 6) | |||||
Samples supplied by EQA provider | External quality assessment (EQA) | |||||
Samples provided by independent laboratory | Interlaboratory comparison |
aWhen using commercial research-use-only tests, the steps of test development and optimization are the same as for IVD/IVDR assays, but full validation must be performed.