Skip to main content
. 2024 Jul 8;13:175. doi: 10.1186/s13643-024-02587-0

Table 1.

Pairwise-comparisons between active learning models (Bonferroni-corrected P values, test statistics, and effect sizes)

Model A Model B p-corr W Effect size
LR + Doc2Vec NB + TF-IDF  < .001 76.5 0.53
NB + TF-IDF SVM + Doc2Vec  < .001 79  − 0.63
LR + TF-IDF RF + TF-IDF  < .001 105.5  − 0.48
SVM + Doc2Vec SVM + TF-IDF  < .001 111 0.65
RF + SBERT SVM + Doc2Vec  < .001 114  − 0.73
LR + TF-IDF SVM + Doc2Vec  < .001 118  − 0.68
SVM + Doc2Vec SVM + SBERT  < .001 76 0.63
LR + SBERT SVM + Doc2Vec  < .001 126  − 0.68
LR + Doc2Vec LR + TF-IDF  < .001 129 0.58
RF + TF-IDF SVM + TF-IDF  < .001 137 0.44
RF + Doc2Vec SVM + Doc2Vec  < .001 140.5  − 0.23
LR + Doc2Vec SVM + TF-IDF  < .001 144 0.55
LR + Doc2Vec RF + SBERT  < .001 145 0.64
LR + Doc2Vec LR + SBERT  < .001 146.5 0.59
LR + Doc2Vec SVM + SBERT  < .001 156.5 0.53
NB + TF-IDF RF + TF-IDF  < .001 157.5  − 0.41
RF + SBERT RF + TF-IDF 0.001 152  − 0.55
NB + TF-IDF RF + Doc2Vec 0.002 195.5  − 0.32
RF + Doc2Vec RF + SBERT 0.002 198 0.40
LR + Doc2Vec SVM + Doc2Vec 0.038 257  − 0.13
RF + Doc2Vec SVM + TF-IDF 0.038 256.5 0.33
LR + TF-IDF RF + Doc2Vec 0.052 264.5  − 0.36
LR + SBERT RF + TF-IDF 0.066 270.5  − 0.48
LR + Doc2Vec RF + Doc2Vec 0.074 273 0.11
RF + TF-IDF SVM + Doc2Vec 0.229 303  − 0.32
RF + TF-IDF SVM + SBERT 0.292 309.5 0.41
LR + SBERT RF + Doc2Vec 0.465 324.5  − 0.35
LR + Doc2Vec RF + TF-IDF 0.528 327.5 0.18
RF + SBERT SVM + TF-IDF 0.810 323.5  − 0.13
RF + SBERT SVM + SBERT 1 346.5  − 0.14
RF + Doc2Vec SVM + SBERT 1 355.5 0.31
LR + TF-IDF SVM + SBERT 1 514  − 0.06
NB + TF-IDF SVM + TF-IDF 1 515.5 0.001
NB + TF-IDF SVM + SBERT 1 543  − 0.01
NB + TF-IDF RF + SBERT 1 381.5 0.12
LR + TF-IDF SVM + TF-IDF 1 355.5  − 0.04
LR + TF-IDF RF + SBERT 1 424.5 0.08
LR + TF-IDF NB + TF-IDF 1 480.5  − 0.04
LR + SBERT SVM + TF-IDF 1 492  − 0.03
LR + SBERT SVM + SBERT 1 527  − 0.05
LR + SBERT RF + SBERT 1 383 0.10
LR + SBERT NB + TF-IDF 1 484  − 0.03
LR + SBERT LR + TF-IDF 1 562 0.01
RF + Doc2Vec RF + TF-IDF 1 560 0.03
SVM + SBERT SVM + TF-IDF 1 554 0.02