Table.
Aromatherapy and bright light treatment as interventions for behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia
Study
|
Intervention and delivery method
|
Design
|
Patient group
|
Outcome
|
Other key points
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aromatherapy | |||||
Holmes et al6 | 2% Lavender oil via aromatherapy stream daily | Double blind placebo controlled crossover (alternate days) for 10 days | Severe dementia in NHS continuing care (n=15) | Significant improvement in Philadelphia agitation scale (P=0.02), with 60% of patients having some benefit | No adverse events Compliance: 100% |
Smallwood et al7 | Twice weekly | Two week single blind randomised controlled trial. Aromatherapy+massage v aromatherapy+conversation v massage alone | Inpatients with severe dementia (n=21) | Significant improvement (P<0.056) in motor behaviour (34% reduction with aromatherapy +massage) | — |
Ballard et al8 | Melissa oil (10% by weight combined with base lotion) via cream applied to hands twice daily (200 mg oil) | Double blind placebo controlled trial. Melissa oil v sunflower oil | Severe dementia in NHS continuing care (n=72) | Significant (P<0.0001) improvement in Cohen Mansfield agitation inventory (median improvement of 22 points after active treatment) | No major adverse effects. 97% of people assigned to active treatment completed the trial |
Bright light treatment | |||||
Haffmanns et al9 | Bright light 30 +/–morning (2.5 mg) melatonin or placebo | Double blind placebo controlled crossover trial (n=10; 6 completed) | DSM-IV dementia with motor restless behaviour | Treatment reduced motor restlessness | — |
Lyketsos et al10 | 1 hour bright light, morning | Randomised controlled crossover trial (n=15; 8 completed) | Dementia agitation | Treatment increased total sleep time, no change in behaviour | — |
Graf et al11 | Evening bright light v dim light therapy | Randomised bright light or dim light therapy (n=23) | Dementia | Treatment increased mini-mental state examination scores and led to a phase shift in body temperature rhythm | — |