Skip to main content
. 2024 Jul 4;15:1425445. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1425445

Table 2.

Incidence rate of effort-reward imbalance by demographic characteristics.

Subgroups Categories No. of studies Sample size Heterogeneity Incidence rate (%) 95%CI Q p
I2 (%) p
Gender Male 4 2030 55.2 0.08 65.4 (59.0, 71.7) 0.31 0.58
Female 4 16,369 97.3 <0.001 69.4 (56.5, 82.3)
Age(year) ≤25 3 3,802 95.1 <0.001 61.1 (45.4, 76.9) 2.24 0.33
26–35 3 11,264 48.5 0.14 62.4 (59.5, 65.2)
>35 5 3,871 84.4 <0.001 69.3 (60.6, 77.9)
Educational level Junior college and below 7 11,158 96.8 <0.001 59.5 (50.1, 68.9) <0.01 0.97
Undergraduate or above 7 9,168 92.9 <0.001 59.2 (52.2, 66.3)
Years of service ≤5 5 10,847 85.2 <0.001 62.6 (55.4, 69.9) 5.23 0.07
6–10 4 4,861 70.6 0.02 68.3 (61.9, 74.4)
>10 5 2,974 92.1 <0.001 77.8 (66.9, 88.6)
Marital status Unmarried/other 5 11,933 98.3 <0.001 64.7 (51.3, 78.1) 0.56 0.46
Married 5 7,181 70.0 0.01 59.1 (53.3, 64.9)
Publication year <2010 4 22,284 98.9 <0.001 26.6 (6.8, 46.4) 15.45 0.001
2010–2015 22 20,651 99.7 <0.001 42.4 (32.1, 52.8)
2016–2020 23 9,915 99.4 <0.001 60.2 (49.6, 70.7)
2021–2023 11 26,794 99.8 <0.001 65.0 (51.5, 78.4)
Continent Asia 39 41,622 99.3 <0.001 57.4 (51.8, 63.1) 9.54 0.02
Europe 7 32,706 99.7 <0.001 38.8 (28.0, 49.6)
North America 6 1,139 99.0 <0.001 49.0 (24.2, 73.7)
South America 8 4,461 99.9 <0.001 42.7 (13.8, 71.6)
Sampling method Convenient sampling 35 65,439 99.9 <0.001 51.9 (42.0, 61.9) 0.01 0.91
other 25 14,205 99.8 <0.001 52.9 (39.9, 65.9)
Type of nurses Department of emergency 4 21,363 96.3 <0.001 68.7 (62.9, 74.5) 21.99 <0.001
Operation room 3 464 63.8 0.06 71.8 (64.5, 79.0)
Department of pediatrics 3 459 99.2 <0.001 65.8 (32.2, 99.3)
ICU 3 715 98.7 <0.001 64.6 (27.7, 100.0)
No categories 47 53,930 99.8 <0.001 49.0 (41.4, 56.6)