Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 10;43(8):1621–1630. doi: 10.1007/s10096-024-04866-z

Table 1.

Overview of the six service evaluation studies, including the demographic characteristics of the study populations

Study 1 Study 2 Study 3 Study 4 Study 5 Study 6 Total
Product MW951S Sigma Virocult Kit

Medline MD202003 dry swab with

vial of 0.85% saline

PROVIR Viral Transport Kit

(TS/5–34 A)

E&O BM1673-

M043-3 Vial + Medium, Alphalab SW1040

Combination kit with ISS PBT093 tube filled with 3 ml TF saline and Citotest

2122-0008 swab

BD Improve

Medical Instruments 8,110,111 vial, 550,040 A dry

swab

.
Inclusion criteria ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions ≥ 18 years old; read and understood self-swabbing instructions .
Location/site Chessington Regional Test Centre and UK Biocentre Manchester Airport Leicester (Birstall Park & Ride) Leicester (Birstall Park & Ride) Leicester (Birstall Park & Ride) Leicester (Birstall Park & Ride) .
N (recruited) 97 395 689 492 1,005 575 3,253
N (with PCR outcome) 90 348 654 458 892 491 2,933
Median age (years); (min–max) 43(19–67) 40(18–81) 37(18–84) 36(18–81) 38(18–81) 35(18–84) 37(18–84)
Sex: male (n,%) 4 (4) 113 (33) 286 (44) 212 (47) 447 (50) 239 (49) 1,301 (44)
Sex: female (n,%) 9 (10) 117 (34) 362 (55) 243 (54) 445 (50) 252 (51) 1,428 (49)
Sex: missing (n,%) 77 (86) 118 (34) 6 (1) 3 (1) 0 0 204 (7)
Previous swabbing experience (%) 39 20 23 20 56 n/a 29

The original study names were: Study 1: SE-SWTC1/SSES; Study 2: SE-SWTC3/COMBI006; Study 3: TS5-34 A; Study 4: COMBI021; Study 5: COMBI031; and Study 6: COMBI045. PCR, polymerase chain reaction