Skip to main content
. 2024 Jul 18;2024:1–13. doi: 10.46471/gigabyte.130
Reviewer name and names of any other individual's who aided in reviewer Phred Benham
Do you understand and agree to our policy of having open and named reviews, and having your review included with the published papers. (If no, please inform the editor that you cannot review this manuscript.) Yes
Is the language of sufficient quality? Yes
Please add additional comments on language quality to clarify if needed Generally yes, the language is sufficiently clear. However, a number of places could be refined and extra words removed.
Are all data available and do they match the descriptions in the paper? No
Additional Comments Additional data is available on fig share. I do not see any of the tables that are cited in the manuscript and contain legends. Am I missing something. Also there is no legend for the GenomeScope profile in figure 3. The assembly appears to be on genbank as a scaffold level assembly, can you list this accession info in the data availability section in addtion to the project number..
Are the data and metadata consistent with relevant minimum information or reporting standards? See GigaDB checklists for examples <a href="http://gigadb.org/site/guide" target="_blank">http://gigadb.org/site/guide</a> Yes
Additional Comments
Is the data acquisition clear, complete and methodologically sound? Yes
Additional Comments
Is there sufficient detail in the methods and data-processing steps to allow reproduction? Yes
Additional Comments
Is there sufficient data validation and statistical analyses of data quality? No
Additional Comments Overall fine, but some additional analyses would aid the paper. Comparison of the spoonbill genome to other close relatives using a synteny plot would be helpful. It would also be useful to put heterozygosity and inbreeding coefficients into context by comparing to results from other species.
Is the validation suitable for this type of data? Yes
Additional Comments
Is there sufficient information for others to reuse this dataset or integrate it with other data? Yes
Additional Comments
Any Additional Overall Comments to the Author Hui et al. report a chromosome level genome for the black-faced spoonbill, a endangered species of coastal wetlands in East Asia. This genome will serve as an important genome for understanding the biology of and conserving this species. Generally, the methods are sound and appropriate for the generation of genomic sequence. Major comments: This is a highly contiguous genome in line with metrics for Vertebrate Genomics Project genomes and other consortia. The authors argue that they have assembled 31 Pseudo-molecules or chromosomes. It would be nice to see a plot showing synteny of these 31 chromosomes and a closely related species with a chromosome level assembly (e.g. Theristicus caerulescens; GCA_020745775.1) The tables appear to be missing from the submitted manuscript? Minor comments: Line 49: delete its Line 49-51: This sentence is a little awkward, please revise. Line 64: delete 'the' Line 67: replace 'with' with 'the spoonbil as a' Line 68: delete 'Interestingly' Line 70: can you be more specific about what kind of genetic methods had previously been performed? Line 79: can you provide any additional details on the necessary permits and/or institutional approval Line 78: what kind of tissue? or were these blood samples? Line 110: do you mean movies? Line 143: replace data with dataset Line 163: it may be worth applying some additional filters in vcftools, e.g. minor allele freq., min depth, max depth, what level of missing data was allowed?, etc. Line 171: delete 'resulted in' Line 172: do you mean scaffold L50 was 8? Line 191-195: some context would be useful here, how does this level of heterozygosity and inbreeding compare to other waterbirds? Line 217: why did you use the Metazoan database and not the Aves_odb10 database for Busco? Figure 1b: Number refers to what, scaffolds? Be consistent with capitalization for Mb. It seems like the order of scaffold N50 and L50 were reversed. Figure 3 is missing a legend.
Recommendation Major Revision