Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 10;2014(1):CD007470. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007470.pub3
Characteristic
Study ID
Intervention(s) and control(s) Deaths
 [n/N] All adverse events
 [n/N (%)] Severe/serious adverse events
 [n/N (%)] Left study because of adverse events
 [n/N (%)]
Aloia 2005 I: vitamin D3, calcium 1/104 8/104 (7.7)
C: placebo 2/104 7/104 (6.7)
total:   222    
Avenell 2004 I: vitamin D3 4/70
C: no intervention 3/64
total:   8 (6)  
Avenell 2012 I: vitamin D3 836/2649 363/2649 (13.7)
C: matched placebo 881/2643 386/2643 (14.6)
total:     33 (0.6)
Baeksgaard 1998 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/80 2/80 (2.5)
C: matched placebo 1/80 2/80 (2.5)
Bischoff 2003 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 1/62 2/62 (3.2)
C: matched placebo plus calcium 4/60 0/60 (0.0)
Bjorkman 2007 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 27/150
C: calcium 9/68
Bolton‐Smith 2007 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/62
C: matched placebo 1/60
Brazier 2005 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 3/95 15/95 (15.8) 8/95 (8.4) 8/95 (8.4)
C: matched placebo 1/97 17/97 (17.5) 10/97 (10.3) 10/97 (10.3)
Broe 2007 I: vitamin D2 5/99
C: matched placebo 2/25
Brohult 1973 I: vitamin D3 1/25 3/25 (12.0) 1/25 (4.0) 0/25 (0.0)
C: placebo 0/25 0/25 (0) 0/25 (0) 0/25 (0.0)
Burleigh 2007 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 16/104 4/101 (4.0) 0/101 (0.0) 1/101 (1.0)
C: matched placebo vitamin D3 plus calcium 13/104 3/104 (2.9) 0/104 (0.0) 0/104 (0.0)
Campbell 2005 I: home safety programme 6/195
C: social visits 10/196
Chapuy 1992 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 893/1634 40/1634 (2.4) 40/1634 (2.4) 40/1634 (2.4)
C: double placebo 917/1636 28/1636 (1.7) 28/1636 (1.7) 28/1636 (1.7)
Chapuy 2002 I1: vitamin D3 plus calcium 70/389 27/389 (6.9) 3/389 (0.8)
I2: vitamin D3 plus calcium 46/194 16/194 (8.2) 0/194 (8.2)
C: double placebo     6/583 (1.0) 6/583 (1.0)
Chel 2008 I: vitamin D3
C: matched placebo
Cherniack 2011 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 1/23 4/23 (17.4) 3/23 (13.0) 3/23 (13.0)
C: matched placebo plus calcium 0/23 4/23 (17.4) 4/23 (17.4) 4/23 (17.4)
Cooper 2003 I: vitamin D2 plus calcium 0/93 8/93 (8.6) 8/93 (8.6)
C: calcium 1/94 1/94 (1.1) 1/94 (1.1)
total:     6/187 (3.2)  
Coreless 1985 I: vitamin D2 8/41 3/41 (7.3) 1/41 (2.4) 1/41 (2.4)
C: matched placebo 8/41 0/41 (0.0) 0/41 (0.0) 0/41 (0.0)
Daly 2006 I: calcium‐vitamin D3–fortified milk plus calcium 1/85 9/85 (10.6) 9/85 (10.6) 9/85 (10.6)
C: no intervention 0/82 2/82 (2.4) 2/82 (2.4) 2/82 (2.4)
Dawson‐Hughes 1997 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 2/187 6/187 (3.2) 6/187 (3.2) 6/187 (3.2)
C: placebo 2/202 3/202 (1.5) 3/202 (1.5) 3/202 (1.5)
Dukas 2004 I: alfacalcidol 1/192 75/192 (39.0) 0/192 (0.0) 0/192 (0.0)
C: placebo 1/186 82/186 (44.1) 0/186 (0.0) 0/186 (0.0)
Flicker 2005 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium
C: calcium
Gallagher 2001 I: calcitriol 2/123 87/123 (71.0) 55/123 (45.0)
C: matched placebo 1/123 56/123 (45.5) 46/123 (37.0)
Glendenning 2012 I: cholecalciferol 150,000 three‐monthly 2/353 24/353 (6.8) 19/353 (5.4)
C: placebo vitamin D three‐monthly 0/333 21/333 (6.3) 15/333 (4.5)
Grady 1991 I: calcitriol 1/50 7/50 (14.0) 7/50 (14.0)
C: placebo vitamin D 0/48 2/48 (4.2) 2/48 (4.2)
Grimnes 2011 I: vitamin D3 0/51 45/51 (88.0)
C: placebo 1/53 46/53 (87.0)
Harwood 2004 I: vitamin D2 plus calcium 24/113 0/113 (0.0)
C: no intervention 5/37 0/37 (0.0)
Jackson 2006 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 744/18176 449/18,176 (2.5) 449/18,176 (2.5)
C: matched placebo 807/18106 381/18,106 (2.1) 381/18,106 (2.1)
Janssen 2010 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/36
C: matched placebo vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/34
Komulainen 1999 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/116 5/116 (4.3)
C: placebo 1/116 4/116 (3.4)
Krieg 1999 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 21/124 21/124 10/124 (8.1)
C: no treatment 26/124 26/124 2/124 (1.6)
Kärkkäinen 2010 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 15/1718 17/1718 (0.99)
C: no intervention 13/1714 0/1714 (0.0)
Lappe 2007 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 4/446 1/446 (0.2) 13/446 (2.9)
C: calcium plus vitamin D placebo 18/733 4/733 (0.5) 20/733 (2.7)
Larsen 2004 I: home safety inspection 832/4957
C: vitamin D3 plus calcium 839/4648
Latham 2003 I: vitamin D3 11/121
C: matched placebo 3/122
Law 2006 I: vitamin D2 347/1762 28/1762 (1.6) 28/1762 (1.6)
C: no intervention 322/1955 1955 (0.0) 1955 (0.0)
Lehouck 2012 I: vitamin D3 9/91 4/91 (4.4)
C: matched placebo 6/91 0/91 (0.0)
Lips 1996 I: vitamin D3 282/1291
C: matched placebo 306/1287
Lips 2010 I: vitamin D3 1/114 24/114 (21.0) 3/114 (2.6) 3/114 (2.6)
C: matched placebo 0/112 26/112 (23.2) 2/112 (2.7) 2/112 (2.7)
Lyons 2007 I: vitamin D2 947/1725
C: matched placebo 953/1715
Meier 2004 I: vitamin D3 (500 IU) orally, daily 0/30
C: no intervention 1/25
Mochonis 2006 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/42 0/42 (0.0) 0/42 (0.0)
C: no intervention 1/70 4/70 (5.7) 4/70 (5.7)
Ooms 1995 I: vitamin D3 11/177 2/177 (1.1)
C: matched placebo 21/171 0/171 (0.0)
Ott 1989 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 0/43 11/43 (25.6)
C: matched placebo vitamin D plus calcium 1/43 1/43 (2.3)
Porthouse 2005 I: vitamin D3 plus calcium 57/1321
C: no intervention 68/1993
Prince 2008 I: vitamin D2 plus calcium 0/151
C: matched placebo tablet of vitamin D plus calcium 1/151
Sanders 2010 I: vitamin D3 40/1131 223/1131 (19.7) 244/1131 (19.7)
C: matched placebo tablet 47/1127 201/1127 (17.8) 207/1127 (17.8)
Sato 1997 I: vitamin D (alfacalcidol) plus calcium 1/45
C: matched placebo tablets of vitamin D and calcium 1/39
Sato 1999a I: vitamin D (alfacalcidol) 1/43
C: matched placebo tablet of vitamin D 0/43
Sato 1999b I: vitamin D (alfacalcidol) 0/34
C: matched placebo tablet of vitamin D 1/35
Sato 2005a I: vitamin D2 1/48
C: matched placebo tablet of vitamin D 2/48
Schleithoff 2006 I: vitamin D3 2000 IU plus calcium 500 mg orally, daily 7/61
C: matched placebo vitamin D plus calcium 6/62
Smith 2007 I: vitamin D2 355/4727
C: matched placebo intramuscular injection 354/4713
Trivedi 2003 I: vitamin D3 224/1345
C: matched placebo vitamin D 247/1341
Witham 2010 I: vitamin D2 (10,000 IU) orally, daily 4/53 20/53 (37.7)
C: matched placebo tablet 2/52 25/52 (48.1)
Zhu 2008 I: vitamin D2 plus calcium 0/39
C: calcium plus placebo vitamin D 2/81
Footnotes
"‐" denotes not reported
C: control; I: intervention