Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 10;29(4):239–254. doi: 10.1136/bmjebm-2023-112767

Table 1.

Study characteristics of included studies (N=41)

Count of studies % of studies
Year of publication ≤2010 8 20%
2011–2015 12 29%
2016–2020 15 36%
2021 6 15%
Geographical region USA 19 46%
Europe 6 15%
Asia 4 10%
Canada 1 2%
Russia 1 2%
Australia 1 2%
Multicountry 9 22%
Study centres Multicentre study 34 83%
Single-centre study 5 12%
Not reported 2 5%
Setting Community 20 49%
Nursing homes or long-term care 5 12%
Clinic 4 10%
Outpatient centres 1 2%
Research centres 1 2%
Not Reported 10 24%
Study design RCT 38 93 %
Cluster RCT 3 7 %
Frequency of interventions examined IIV3-HD/IIV3-SD 9 22%
IIV3-Adj/IIV3-SD 4 10%
IIV3-SD/Placebo 4 10%
IIV3-SD/IIV3-SD-CC 3 7%
IIV3-HD/IIV4-SD 2 5%
IIV3-SD/IIV4-SD 2 5%
RIV3/IIV3-SD 2 5%
IIV3-Adj/IIV3-HD 1 2%
IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Other-Adj/IIV3-Other-Adj/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj 1 2%
IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Adj 1 2%
IIV3-HD/IIV3-Adj/RIV4 1 2%
IIV3-SD+IIV3 HD/IIV3-SD+IIV3-Adj/IIV3-HD/IIV3-Adj 1 2%
IIV3-SD/IIV3-other/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-Other-Adj 1 2%
IIV3-SD/IIV3-SD 1 2%
IIV3-SD-CC/IIV4-SD-CC 1 2%
IIV4-Adj/Tdap 1 2%
IIV4-Adj/IIV3-Adj 1 2%
IIV4-HD/IIV4-HD/IIV4-SD 1 2%
IIV4-HD/IIV3-HD 1 2%
IIV4-HD/IIV4-SD 1 2%
IIV4-SD/IIV3-Adj/IIV3-HD/RIV4 1 2%
RIV4/IIV4-SD 1 2%
Funding Industry 23 56%
Public 11 27%
Public and industry 4 10%
Not reported 3 7%
Number of influenza seasons studies 1 season 31 76%
2 seasons 6 15%
3 seasons 1 2%
4 seasons 1 2%
Not reported 2 5%

Adj, adjuvanted; HD, high dose; IIV3, trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine; IIV4, IIV quadrivalent ; RCT, randomised controlled trial; SD, standard dose.