Table 4. Summary results on health system inputs.
| Egypt | Germany | Jordan | Lebanon | Sweden | Switzerland | The Netherlands | Türkiye | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Leadership and
governance |
||||||||
|
Mental health
policy |
Yes | Yes | Yes | Unknown | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Mental health plan | Yes | No | Yes | Unknown | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
|
Mental health
legislation |
Yes | No (covered in
other laws) |
No | Yes | Decentralised to
municipalities |
No (covered in
other laws) |
Yes | Yes |
| Financing | ||||||||
| % GDP on health | 5.6% | 11.4% | 7.7% | 6.0% | 10.8% | 11.9% | 9.9% | 4.1% |
|
% health
expenditure on mental health |
0.5% | 11.0% | Unknown | 4.8% | Unknown | Unknown | 10.7% | Unknown |
|
% mental health
expenditure towards mental hospitals |
Unknown | 11.3% | Unknown | 54.0% | Unknown | Unknown | 59.2% | Unknown |
|
% funding sources
for health system |
Unknown | 77% social
security |
8.8% social
security, 30.7% out-of-pocket |
52.5% social
security, 36.4% out-of-pocket |
Regional taxes,
13.8% out-of- |
71.5% social
security, 26.8% out-of-pocket |
93.0% social security,
10.1% out-of-pocket |
Unknown |
|
Costs utilising
MHPSS services for refugees |
None | None, but
coverage varies |
Same as
uninsured Jordanians and coverage varies; no cost at UNHCR facilities |
LBP 3,000 – 5,000
(1.75 – 3 EUR) for consultation at UNHCR facilities |
Largely none, same
cost as for Swedish citizens; can apply for reimbursement of out-of-pocket fees |
None if approved
by a doctor or psychiatrist |
Same as Dutch
citizens, pay the cost of monthly insurance premiums and out-of- pocket costs |
Once
registered, same as Türkiye’s citizens. |
|
Facilities and
services |
Ministry of
Health main mental health service provider. MHPSS is not yet fully integrated into PHC, and so refugees either pay specialists or utilise NGO services in the parallel system. |
All psychosocial
services are available in the public sector. Alternatively, refugees have access to the parallel system in which many organisations offer counselling. |
Syrian refugees
can access MHPSS through primary care, which is increasingly integrated, or through UNHCR and NGO facilities that are accessible at no cost. |
NGOs are
extensively involved in care provision (in 2006, over 80% of the 110 PHC centres and 734 dispensaries are owned by NGOs). A variety of MHPSS is offered to the general population. |
Refugees are
identified and treated for mild mental health issues within PHC; Syrian refugees may be referred to providers who specialise in treating this group, who may be in a parallel system. |
Syrian refugees
with mental health needs are referred by nurses/social workers in asylum centres to PHC, where GPs can diagnose, treat, and refer. Referral is possible to general socio- psychiatric facilities, outpatient clinics for traumatised migrants, or tertiary care. |
Early detection of
mental health issues through prevention/ refugee integration programmes in the social domain; screenings at asylum centres; PHC providers in asylum centres or communities. GPs can treat or refer patients to secondary or tertiary care levels. |
Syrians with
temporary protection status can access PHC and community mental health centres for diagnosis, treatment, and referral. Those without temporary protection status can access emergency care in hospitals. |
| Medicines | ||||||||
| Essential drugs list | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes, determined at
the county level |
Yes | No, but registered
drugs list available and measures to keep them affordable. |
Yes |
|
Psychotherapeutic
medicines included in the list |
Yes | Yes, under ‘neurological diseases’ | Yes | Yes | Dependent on
county |
Yes, under
‘neurological diseases’ |
N/A | N/A |
|
Cost of
psychotherapeutic medicines |
Unknown;
80.0% of the population have free access |
Covered by
insurance |
Unknown | Not covered by
social insurance schemes, free at UNHCR facilities (but must pay consultation fee) |
Up to €109
annually for drugs within the national insurance scheme, or €218 for drugs not covered |
Unknown | Up to €385 annually | Unknown |
|
PHC doctors
authorised to prescribe psychotherapeutic medicines |
Unknown | Yes | Unknown | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
|
Health
workforce |
||||||||
|
Mental health
workers per 100,000 |
8.40 mental
health workers, 1.6 psychiatrists, 0.26 psychologists, 4.8 mental health nurses, 0.45 social workers |
27.45
psychiatrists, 49.55 psychologists, 56.06 mental health nurses |
7.8 mental health
workers, 1.125 psychiatrists, 1.266 psychologists, 3.297 mental health nurses, 0.218 social workers |
1.21 psychiatrists,
3.8 psychologists, 3.14 mental health nurses, 1.33 social workers |
20.86 psychiatrists,
0.93 psychologists, 50.57 mental health nurses, 18.42 social workers |
41.42 psychiatrists,
40.78 psychologists |
24.23 psychiatrists,
90.76 psychologists, 2.87 mental health nurses |
1.64
psychiatrists, 2.54 psychologists, 0.76 social workers |
|
Distribution of
mental health professionals between urban and rural areas |
Uneven | Uneven | Relatively even | Unknown | Uneven | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown |
|
Mental health
or cultural competency training |
Covers
psychological first aid and basic mental health care |
None for
undergraduate; majority of PHC doctors have not received official in-service mental health training in last 5 years |
Insufficient | 3% of training
for doctors, and 6% of training for nurses, is dedicated to mental health |
Unknown, although
nurses receive theoretical and clinical training in mental illness |
Cultural
competency training is provided in under- and postgraduate curricula for medical students and residents |
Care for patients with psychological complaints is part of GP training; nurses can specialise in mental health | Majority of
PHC doctors have not received official in- service mental health training in last 5 years |
| Information | ||||||||
|
Data on the
epidemiology of mental disorders collected at the national level |
Unknown | Yes | Unknown | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Unknown |
|
Mental health data
disaggregated refugees |
Unknown | No | Future plans to
disaggregate health data by refugee status; Unknown if includes mental health |
No | Unknown | No | No | Unknown |
|
NGO collection of
refugee mental health data |
Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Database of the
Lebanon Crisis Response Plan encourages partners to collect disaggregated data for displaced Syrians, although includes limited data on mental health indicators |
NGOs involved in
MHPSS for refugees publish data within their annual reports |
Unknown | NGOs involved in
social support do not consistently publish data, aside from the Dutch Refugee Council. Knowledge centres Pharos and ARQ active in gathering and distributing information on refugee mental health |
Unknown |
Sources: WHO (especially Mental Health Atlas and WHO-AIMS reports), UNHCR, World Bank, Eurostat, reports by national governments. See Supplementary File 6 for more detailed overview of findings on context and inputs, including sources used.