Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 20;3:14. [Version 1] doi: 10.12688/openreseurope.15293.1

Table 4. Summary results on health system inputs.

Egypt Germany Jordan Lebanon Sweden Switzerland The Netherlands Türkiye
Leadership and
governance
Mental health
policy
Yes Yes Yes Unknown Yes No Yes Yes
Mental health plan Yes No Yes Unknown Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mental health
legislation
Yes No (covered in
other laws)
No Yes Decentralised to
municipalities
No (covered in
other laws)
Yes Yes
Financing
% GDP on health 5.6% 11.4% 7.7% 6.0% 10.8% 11.9% 9.9% 4.1%
% health
expenditure on
mental health
0.5% 11.0% Unknown 4.8% Unknown Unknown 10.7% Unknown
% mental health
expenditure
towards mental
hospitals
Unknown 11.3% Unknown 54.0% Unknown Unknown 59.2% Unknown
% funding sources
for health system
Unknown 77% social
security
8.8% social
security, 30.7%
out-of-pocket
52.5% social
security, 36.4%
out-of-pocket
Regional taxes,
13.8% out-of-
pocket
71.5% social
security, 26.8%
out-of-pocket
93.0% social security,
10.1% out-of-pocket
Unknown
Costs utilising
MHPSS services for
refugees
None None, but
coverage varies
Same as
uninsured
Jordanians and
coverage varies;
no cost at UNHCR
facilities
LBP 3,000 – 5,000
(1.75 – 3 EUR) for
consultation at
UNHCR facilities
Largely none, same
cost as for Swedish
citizens; can apply
for reimbursement
of out-of-pocket
fees
None if approved
by a doctor or
psychiatrist
Same as Dutch
citizens, pay the cost
of monthly insurance
premiums and out-of-
pocket costs
Once
registered,
same as
Türkiye’s
citizens.
Facilities and
services
Ministry of
Health main
mental health
service provider.
MHPSS is
not yet fully
integrated into
PHC, and so
refugees either
pay specialists
or utilise NGO
services in the
parallel system.
All psychosocial
services are
available in the
public sector.
Alternatively,
refugees have
access to the
parallel system
in which many
organisations
offer
counselling.
Syrian refugees
can access
MHPSS through
primary care,
which is
increasingly
integrated, or
through UNHCR
and NGO
facilities that are
accessible at no
cost.
NGOs are
extensively
involved in care
provision (in
2006, over 80%
of the 110 PHC
centres and 734
dispensaries are
owned by NGOs).
A variety of
MHPSS is offered
to the general
population.
Refugees are
identified and
treated for mild
mental health
issues within PHC;
Syrian refugees
may be referred
to providers
who specialise in
treating this group,
who may be in a
parallel system.
Syrian refugees
with mental health
needs are referred
by nurses/social
workers in asylum
centres to PHC,
where GPs can
diagnose, treat,
and refer. Referral
is possible to
general socio-
psychiatric facilities,
outpatient clinics
for traumatised
migrants, or tertiary
care.
Early detection of
mental health issues
through prevention/
refugee integration
programmes in
the social domain;
screenings at
asylum centres;
PHC providers in
asylum centres or
communities. GPs can
treat or refer patients
to secondary or
tertiary care levels.
Syrians with
temporary
protection
status can
access
PHC and
community
mental health
centres for
diagnosis,
treatment,
and referral.
Those without
temporary
protection
status can
access
emergency
care in
hospitals.
Medicines
Essential drugs list Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes, determined at
the county level
Yes No, but registered
drugs list available
and measures to keep
them affordable.
Yes
Psychotherapeutic
medicines included
in the list
Yes Yes, under ‘neurological diseases’ Yes Yes Dependent on
county
Yes, under
‘neurological
diseases’
N/A N/A
Cost of
psychotherapeutic
medicines
Unknown;
80.0% of the
population have
free access
Covered by
insurance
Unknown Not covered by
social insurance
schemes, free at
UNHCR facilities
(but must pay
consultation fee)
Up to €109
annually for drugs
within the national
insurance scheme,
or €218 for drugs
not covered
Unknown Up to €385 annually Unknown
PHC doctors
authorised
to prescribe
psychotherapeutic
medicines
Unknown Yes Unknown Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Health
workforce
Mental health
workers per
100,000
8.40 mental
health workers,
1.6 psychiatrists,
0.26
psychologists,
4.8 mental
health nurses,
0.45 social
workers
27.45
psychiatrists,
49.55
psychologists,
56.06 mental
health nurses
7.8 mental health
workers, 1.125
psychiatrists,
1.266
psychologists,
3.297 mental
health nurses,
0.218 social
workers
1.21 psychiatrists,
3.8 psychologists,
3.14 mental
health nurses,
1.33 social
workers
20.86 psychiatrists,
0.93 psychologists,
50.57 mental health
nurses, 18.42 social
workers
41.42 psychiatrists,
40.78 psychologists
24.23 psychiatrists,
90.76 psychologists,
2.87 mental health
nurses
1.64
psychiatrists,
2.54
psychologists,
0.76 social
workers
Distribution of
mental health
professionals
between urban
and rural areas
Uneven Uneven Relatively even Unknown Uneven Unknown Unknown Unknown
Mental health
or cultural
competency
training
Covers
psychological
first aid and
basic mental
health care
None for
undergraduate;
majority of PHC
doctors have
not received
official in-service
mental health
training in last 5
years
Insufficient 3% of training
for doctors, and
6% of training
for nurses, is
dedicated to
mental health
Unknown, although
nurses receive
theoretical and
clinical training in
mental illness
Cultural
competency
training is provided
in under- and
postgraduate
curricula for
medical students
and residents
Care for patients with psychological complaints is part of GP training; nurses can specialise in mental health Majority of
PHC doctors
have not
received
official in-
service mental
health training
in last 5 years
Information
Data on the
epidemiology of
mental disorders
collected at the
national level
Unknown Yes Unknown Yes Yes No Yes Unknown
Mental health data
disaggregated
refugees
Unknown No Future plans to
disaggregate
health data by
refugee status;
Unknown if
includes mental
health
No Unknown No No Unknown
NGO collection of
refugee mental
health data
Unknown Unknown Unknown Database of the
Lebanon Crisis
Response Plan
encourages
partners to collect
disaggregated
data for displaced
Syrians, although
includes limited
data on mental
health indicators
NGOs involved in
MHPSS for refugees
publish data within
their annual reports
Unknown NGOs involved in
social support do
not consistently
publish data, aside
from the Dutch
Refugee Council.
Knowledge centres
Pharos and ARQ
active in gathering
and distributing
information on
refugee mental health
Unknown

Sources: WHO (especially Mental Health Atlas and WHO-AIMS reports), UNHCR, World Bank, Eurostat, reports by national governments. See Supplementary File 6 for more detailed overview of findings on context and inputs, including sources used.