Table 1.
Study | Study origin | Type of study | n/ M:F (%) |
Mean age (yrs) | Type of EAS | Summary of EAT programme | Duration and Frequency | PTSD outcome measure |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Johnson et al. 2018 [19] | USA | RCT |
38/ 84:16 |
54 | THR | THR classes held at a Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship accredited riding centre. Staff focused on horsemanship, tacking up, safety and grooming | One 50–60 min session per week for 6 weeks | PCL-M |
Fisher et al. 2021 [20] | USA | Clinical Open Trial |
63/ 63:37 |
50 | PIH |
Session co-led by licensed mental health professional and qualified equine specialist. Mental health professional to facilitate reflection, observation and direction. Psychoeducation, interaction with horses in the round pen. Grounding exercises, grooming, leading horses, team work exercises with the horse in different situations, followed by team feedback and closing circle for discussions All sessions were videotaped by researchers |
One 90 min session per week for 8 weeks |
PCL-5 CAPS-5 |
Arnon et al. 2020 [21] | USA | Clinical Open Trial |
8/ 75:25 |
45 | PIH | Session co-led by mental health professional and equine specialist. Sessions included grounding exercise, relaxation exercises, ‘join up’ activity, team work exercises and reflection opportunities | One 90 min session per week for 8 weeks |
PCL-5 CAPS-5 |
Zhu et al. 2020 [22] | USA | Clinical Open Trial |
19/ 47:53 |
46 | PIH | Grounding exercise, teaching on EAS rationale, psychoeducation, round pen meeting with horses. Team feedback and direction | One 90 min session per week for 8 weeks | PCL-5 (no numbers presented) |
Romaniuk et al. 2018 [23] | Australia | Evaluation Study |
36/ 81:19 |
46 | PIH | Session co-led by Equine Psychotherapy Institute (Australia) Program Model of Equine Assisted Learning/Psychotherapy and a registered Psychologist. Sessions involved groundwork techniques and elements of natural horsemanship, learning new skills to create social engagement. Therapeutic work to explore issues, challenges, behaviours and build awareness of responses. Opportunities to reflect. Trail walks, mindfulness and group discussions | Five day residential programme | PCL-5 |
Burton et al. 2019 [24] | USA | Clinical Open Trial |
20/ 80:20 |
47 | PIH | Sessions co-led by Equine Assisted Growth and Learning Association (USA) and licensed occupational therapist. Sessions included ground based exercises using horses at metaphors, leading and obstacle exercises. Pre-session discussions with an occupational therapist. Targeted psychotherapy activity, goal setting and focus on positive lifestyle choices to manage PTSD symptoms. Post-activity discussions | One session per week for 6 weeks | PCL-M |
Rosing et al. 2022 [25] | Israel | Evaluation Study |
12/ Not stated |
41 | PIH and EAL | Providers of the programme not stated. PIH and EAL (equine-assisted learning) which had elements of teaching skills; grooming and tacking up, riding activities, vaulting, mounted basketball and more. Groundwork included sharing stories and beliefs and interpretation of self through tasks with the horses. Ending with group conversation to share experiences | One 3 h session per week over a 6 month period | Qualitative measures used |
Sylvia et al. 2020 [26] | USA | Evaluation Study |
62/ 83:17 |
37 | PIH and EAL | Certified team of providers including licensed clinicians, a therapeutic riding instructor and equine specialist in mental health learning. PIH along with mindfulness- based activities. Therapeutic riding, driving, EAL, groundwork, horse-human energy, herd observation and equine care | 2 week intensive programme, with an EAT weekend. 3 × 2 h long sessions | PCL-5 |
Johnson et al. 2021 [27] | USA | RCT |
20/ 90:10 |
52 | THR | Sessions provided by a certified riding instructor and a licensed occupational therapist. Grooming, riding, exercises built upon over the six weeks | One session per week for 6 weeks | Qualitative measures used |
Ferruolo 2016 [28] | USA | Pilot Programme |
8/ 100:0 |
Not stated | PIH | Sessions provided by clinical social work graduate and 2 equine-facilitated mental health experts at an established therapeutic horse farm. Sessions consisted of 70 min of psychoeducation, 285 min of guided experimental equine activities, 315 min of group processing and personal reflection | Two day intensive option | Qualitative measures used |
Malinowski et al. 2018 [29] | USA | Original Research |
7/ 86:14 |
58 | PIH | Sessions were led by a team including a licensed psychologist and a PATH licensed therapeutic riding instructor and equine specialist in mental health and learning. EAS and PIH sessions included horsemanship, obstacle course and mindfulness, horse chalking and active feeling exercises and grounding exercises mixed with association between positive feelings | 5 × 1 h EAT sessions over 5 consecutive days | PCL-5 |
Marchland et al. 2023 [30] | USA | Observational Study |
18/ Not stated |
46 | THR | Session adhered to PATH safety standards in a university equine facility. Intervention included two sessions of horsemanship and two sessions of trail rides lasting 45 min each. Session one and two focused on learning basic equine ground skills and mounting. Sessions three and four consisted of ride preparation, riding and debriefs | One session per week over 4 weeks. First two sessions 4 h in length, final two lasted 2 h | PCL-V |
Marchland et al. 2023 [31] | USA | Evaluation Study |
33/ 51.5:48.5 |
46 | PIH | Sessions were provided by a licensed mental health clinician and an equine specialist. Activities focused on mindfulness, grooming, equine behaviour and communication, leading, group discussions (self-compassion, psychological safety, psychological resilience, ‘how would I treat a friend’, approaches to difficult and emotions and a guilt and shame discussion) and meditation | One session per week for 6 weeks lasting 90 min | PCL-V |
CAPS-5 clinician administered PCL, EAL equine-assisted learning, EAS equine-assisted Services, PCL-5 post-traumatic stress disorder checklist (standard), PCL-V post-traumatic stress disorder checklist (Veteran), PCL-M post-traumatic stress disorder checklist (Military), PTSD posttraumatic stress disorder, RCT randomised controlled trial, THR therapeutic horseback riding, N number of participants, M:F male: female ratio, PATH Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship (USA), PIH psychotherapy involving horses