Skip to main content
. 2024 Jul 30;14(7):e080609. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-080609

Table 1. Driver characteristics at the time of crash.

Characteristic Drivers deemed responsible for crash, count (%)n=434 119 Drivers deemed non-responsible for crash, count (%)n=374 313 Drivers with indeterminate responsibility, count (%)n=127 095 P values, responsible vs non-responsible
Median age (Q1, Q3) (years) 37 (23, 52) 40 (28, 52) 40 (27, 53) <0.001
Age categories <0.001
 ≤20 years 73 042 (16.8%) 35 696 (9.5%) 12 792 (10.1%)
 21 to 44 years 202 189 (46.6%) 185 292 (49.5%) 62 776 (49.4%)
 45 to 64 years 107 132 (24.7%) 120 604 (32.2%) 39 026 (30.7%)
 ≥65 years 51 756 (11.9%) 32 721 (8.7%) 12 501 (9.8%)
Male sex 283 487 (65.3%) 233 001 (62.2%) 80 882 (63.6%) <0.001
Residential neighbourhood household income quintile <0.001
 1 (lowest income) 82 859 (19.1%) 67 265 (18%) 23 573 (18.5%)
 2 86 632 (20%) 73 955 (19.8%) 25 944 (20.4%)
 3 85 237 (19.6%) 74 453 (19.9%) 25 207 (19.8%)
 4 84 086 (19.4%) 75 530 (20.2%) 25 161 (19.8%)
 5 (highest income) 76 160 (17.5%) 68 408 (18.3%) 22 325 (17.6%)
 Missing 19 145 (4.4%) 14 702 (3.9%) 4885 (3.8%)
Rural residence 210 543 (48.5%) 178 512 (47.7%) 51 953 (40.9%) <0.001
≥1 hospitalisation in prior year 49 490 (11.4%) 39 527 (10.6%) 13 416 (10.6%) <0.001
≥7 physician visits in prior year 20 649 (4.8%) 14 320 (3.8%) 5233 (4.1%) <0.001
Comorbidities
 Any psychiatric disorder 25 516 (5.9%) 17 747 (4.7%) 6378 (5%) <0.001
 Hypertension 19 876 (4.6%) 15 669 (4.2%) 5515 (4.3%) <0.001
 Alcohol use 5065 (1.2%) 2036 (0.5%) 852 (0.7%) <0.001
 Other drug use 8117 (1.9%) 3464 (0.9%) 1512 (1.2%) <0.001
 Diabetes 7860 (1.8%) 5438 (1.5%) 2038 (1.6%) <0.001
Active prescriptions at baseline <0.001
 0 or 1 351 528 (81.0%) 307 211 (82.1%) 103 684 (81.6%)
 ≥2 82 591 (19.0%) 67 102 (17.9%) 23 411 (18.4%)
Medications filled in prior 90 days
 Quetiapine 3360 (0.8%) 1759 (0.5%) 733 (0.6%) <0.001
 Risperidone 1127 (0.3%) 619 (0.2%) 211 (0.2%) <0.001
 Olanzapine 660 (0.2%) 278 (0.1%) 128 (0.1%) <0.001
 Aripiprazole 233 (0.1%) 168 (<0.1%) 58 (<0.1%) 0.086
 Clozapine 36 (<0.1%) 24 (<0.1%) 5 (<0.1%) 0.396
 Other antipsychotics 904 (0.2%) 455 (0.1%) 189 (0.1%) <0.001
 Benzodiazepines 28 330 (6.5%) 18 676 (5.0%) 6925 (5.4%) <0.001
 Opioids 34 990 (8.1%) 26 432 (7.1%) 9268 (7.3%) <0.001
Driver licence type <0.001
 Learner 8047 (1.9%) 2484 (0.7%) 1213 (1.0%)
 Novice 80 621 (18.6%) 42 973 (11.5%) 15 464 (12.2%)
 Full 342 706 (78.9%) 328 157 (87.7%) 110 041 (86.6%)
 No license 2745 (0.6%) 699 (0.2%) 377 (0.3%)
Active license in prior 3 years 429 365 (98.9%) 372 921 (99.6%) 126 374 (99.4%) <0.001
Median years with full license 10.4 13.9 13.5 <0.001
Police-attended crash in prior 3 years 48 207 (11.1%) 34 783 (9.3%) 12 340 (9.7%) <0.001
Any contravention in prior 3 years 214 693 (49.5%) 164 796 (44.0%) 57 685 (45.4%) <0.001
 Alcohol contravention 34 356 (7.9%) 16 415 (4.4%) 6664 (5.2%) <0.001
 Speed contravention 133 427 (30.7%) 105 679 (28.2%) 36 151 (28.4%) <0.001
 Distraction contravention 6508 (1.5%) 6165 (1.6%) 2365 (1.9%) <0.001

Our sample included 935 527 driver-crash combinations, of which 46% were deemed responsible for the crash and 2896 (0.31%) had a diagnosis of schizophrenia prior to the crash. Drivers with indeterminate responsibility were not included in analyses and are presented here for descriptive purposes only. Relative to non-responsible drivers, crash -responsible drivers were younger and more likely to have a novice driver’s license, recent medical visits for alcohol and other drug use, recent police-attended crashes, and recent traffic contraventions. The displayed p- values compare responsible drivers to non-responsible drivers. We note that the large sample size may produce p values <0.001 even in the absence of a clinically meaningful difference between groups.