Table 1.
Details of all paediatric migrant hepatitis B studies
Study | Year | Country | Study Setting | Study Purpose | Study Type | Study Population & country/region of origin | Inclusion Age Range (years) | How identified | Sample size | Prevalence Chronic HBV (%) | Vaccination Coverage (%) | Susceptible (%) | Age of Sample/at diagnosisa | Gender Split of HBV + ve (%male) | Gender Split of Sample (% male) | Screening/care pathway information | Data on complications, late severe disease |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Belhassen-Garcia et al., | 2015 | Spain | Salamanca | Assess imported transmissible diseases in migrants from low income areas | Cross-sectional (medical records and physical exam) | Immigrant children and adolescents from E/W/S/C Africa, North Africa and Latin America | 0–18 | Screening in immigrants < 18 yrs | 350 | 4.3 | 39.7 | 32 | 15 | 86.7 | 53.4 | 7/15 patients with CHB had detectable HBV viral loads | |
Bergevin et al., | 2021 | France | Dedicated migrant medical consultation service in 1 hospital, Paris | Describe health issues of newly arrived UAMs managed in a dedicated paediatric consultation service | Cross-sectional (single-centre retrospective) | UAM from Africa or Afghanistan | 0–18 | Visiting dedicated consultation service | 90 | 8.0 | 89.0 | Average time to 1st consult =3 months. UMs have free healthcare until adulthood | |||||
Finnegan et al., | 2015 | Ireland | Specialist clinic for children born to HBV infected mothers | Describe long-term follow up of children born to HBV infected mothers | Cross-sectional (retrospective) | Children with chronic HBV infection attending specialist clinic (from Africa, Central Asia, Eastern Europe) | 0–18 | Children born to HBV infected mothers are referred | 57 | 6 m-17 yr | 60 | 60 | 69% born in Ireland received adequate prophyl. 0% born outside received adequate prophy l. 19% received vaccine alone. | 7% (n = 4) developed complication of CHB. n = 3 had fibrosis n = 3 received antivirals |
|||
Fougere et al., | 2018 | Switzerland | Hospital reference centre for the children of asylum seekers in region. More than 90% of migrant children in Lausanne/surroundings followed in this setting. | Estimate HB vaccine protection (using post booster serology). Those with anti-HBs ≥ 100 post booster were assumed to be vaccinated. | Prospective single-centre cohort | Migrant children from Eritrea, Iraq, Syria | 1–18 | Research study | 200 | <1% | 81 | 9 yr*/ 12 yr -one case |
51 | Migrants should have 2 visits (for first dose of vaccine and serology 4–6 weeks later) | |||
Genton et al., | 2019 | Switzerland | Migrant care facility clinic in canton of Vaud (service for asylum seekers)—but data across multiple healthcare structures primarily used by this cohort | Describe the overall clinical profile and the care pathways of unaccompanied minor asylum seekers | Cross-Sectional (retrospective study, information extracted from medical records) | UAM (asylum seekers). Afghanistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Syria | 0–18 | Routine screening of newly arrived children. | 109 | 2.8 | 87.2 | Screening of newly arrived UAMs takes place | |||||
Giordano et al., | 2018 | Italy | University hospital of Palermo, Sicily | Examine immunisation status of IAC and compare it with vaccination certificates, focusing on measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) and hepatitis B (HBV) | Cross-sectional | Internationally adopted children (IAC). Country/region of origin not specified | 0–18 | Screening of internationally adopted children | 79 (for HBV) | 0.0 | 65.8 | 34 | 84 mon | 62 | Concordance between serology and vaccination records is 71% | ||
Hahne et al., | 2012 | Netherlands | Population study | Assess differences in prevalence of HBV infection in The Netherlands between 1996 and 2007, and identify risk factors for HBV infection in 2007 | Cross-sectional (seroprevalence) | Representative sample of Dutch population (with oversampling or largest migrant groups from Suriname, Turkey, Morocco, Dutch Antilles, Aruba, Indonesia | 0–79 | Prevalence study (no data if already aware or not prior to study) | 2007: 6246 (0–14 = 1476, 14–29 =1002) | 2007 1st gen: 0–14: 2.3% 15–29: 22.3% 2nd gen 0–14: 1.7% 15–29: 2.4% |
|||||||
Hampel et al., | 2016 | Germany | 5 initial refugee reception centres in Northern Germany | Assess prevalence of hepatitis B and the vaccination status of refugee population | Cross-sectional (retrospective descriptive data analysis) | Refugees. Country/region or origin not reported |
0–17 | Every refugee (newly arrived) who sought medical treatment for acute complaints offered testing | 62 (aged under 18 yrs) | 1.6 | 50 | 0% | 80.6 | Initial screening is offered but loss to follow-up and lack of joined up care is common | |||
Hourdet et al., | 2020 | France | Health care access centre for vulnerable populations, Paris | Assess the health status of this population | Cross-sectional (retrospective, observational, monocentric) | Patients self-reporting as UAM but not recognised as such by the state from Guinea, Ivory Coast, Mali | 0–18 | Screening offered when visiting a dedicated consultation service | 301 -total 1035 consultations | 12.8 | 16 | 95 | Jurisdictional framework around this status unclear. Precarious access to care | ||||
Hübschen et al., | 2012 | Luxembourg | Unclear | Investigate prevalence of IgG antibodies against different vaccine-preventable diseases in newcomers to Luxembourg | Cross-sectional | Refugees or asylum seekers (newly arrived) from Albania, Montenegro, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Middle East, Asia, Africa, Russia | 13–25 | Vaccine coverage study | 131 (age 13–25) | 25 | Majority of migrants lacked antibodies to one or more VPDs | ||||||
Jablonka et al., | 2015 | Germany | single reception centre | Determine seroprevalence of antibodies against hepatitis A–E in an unselected cohort of refugees and asylum seekers during Middle East crisis | Cross-sectional | Refugees and asylum seekers from Africa, East MediterraneanEurope, SE Asia | 0–17 | On arrival screening (mandatory) | 91 | 0.0 | 40.7 | 32 | 74.7 | ||||
Janda et al., | 2020 | Germany | Single paediatric consultation service for UMs, Municipal area Southwest Germany | Understanding frequency and clinical presentation of IDs among minor refugees, evaluate the performance and practicability of screening recommendation | Cross-sectional | UAM (refugee) from Africa (93.6%), Asia and Southern Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 776 with HBV (of 890) | 7.7 | 16* | 94 | Problems with follow-up and retention in HBV service. Unable to offer antivirals | 75% of URMs with active HBV were HBeAg -ve and had low viral loads in blood (<10 IU/ml) | |||
Kloning et al., | 2018 | Germany | 2 paediatric practices and one collective housing for refugees in region of Bavaria, Germany | Investigate the morbidity profile and the sociodemographic characteristics of unaccompanied refugee minors (URM) | Cross-sectional (retrospective data derived from medical data records of routine first medical exam) | UAM (refugee) from Afghanistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Syria | 0–18 | On arrival screening (mandatory) | 113 | 8 | 3.2 | 58 | 16* | 93.5 | No standardised pathway. Follow-up challenges due to frequent relocations | ||
Maasen et al., | 2017 | Germany | On arrival screening | Describe microbiological screenings for infection control in unaccompanied minor refugees undertaken by the German Armed Forces Medical Service | Cross-sectional | UAM (refugee) from Afghanistan, Algeria, Benin, Egypt, Ghana, Guinea, Iran, Iraq, Libya, Morocco, Palestine, Pakistan | 0–18 | On arrival screening (mandatory) | 190 (from total sample of 219) | 1.6 | 13–18 | 100 | 100 | ||||
Marquardt et al., | 2016 | Germany | On arrival screening in a private outpatient clinic for internal and tropical medicine, Bielefeld | Investigate the physical and mental disease burden of unaccompanied asylum-seeking adolescents | Cross-sectional | UAM (asylum-seeking adolescents) from Africa, Asia (mostly Afghanistan, Guinea, Morocco) | 12–18 | On arrival screening | 101 tested for HBV (of 102) | 7.9 | 14.9 | 16 | 100 | 76.5 | On arrival screening available | Two children required antivirals | |
Marrone et al., | 2020 | Italy | Reception centres, Rome | Address prevalence of infectious diseases in a population of unaccompanied immigrant minors | Cross-sectional | UAM from Africa, SE Asia, Eastern Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 879 | 2.5 | 18.2 | 76 | 17 | 100 | 97.6 | On arrival screening available | |
Mockenhaupt et al., | 2016 | Germany | Berlin travel and tropical medicine clinic GeoSentinel site | Present results of screening a cohort of unaccompanied Syrian minors (UAMs) | Cross-sectional | UAM from Syrian | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 488 | 0.0 | 94 | ||||||
Monpierre et al., | 2016 | France | Regional system for isolated foreign minors in Gironde | Describe data on overall health status obtained from a systematic medical check-up offered to URMs | Cross-sectional (data descriptive) | UAM (refugee) from Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening (systematic) | 235 | 6.0 | 16 | 89.8 | On arrival screening available | ||||
Norman et al., | 2021 | Spain | Migrant referral centre, Madrid | Describe seroprevalence rates for potentially transmissible viral infections in migrants attended at a referral centre in a major European city | Cross-sectional | Migrants from Africa | 0–20 | Attended for the first time (symptomatic or asymptomatic referred for a health exam) Unclear if screening was standardised. | 96 | 10.4 | 24 | 30 | |||||
Olivan-Gonzalvo et al., | 2021 | Spain | UAM protection centres | Examine the health status and infectious diseases in a cohort of unaccompanied immigrant minors from Africa to Spain | Cross-sectional (retrospective) | UAM (Male, from Africa) | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 622 | 2.6 | 16 | 100 | 100 | Screening on admission to residential care | |||
Pauti et al., | 2016 | France | Migrant clinics: Drs of the World Clinics in Lyon, Nice, Paris and Saint-Denis | Present degree of lack of knowledge of the HBV and HCV status of people encountered in 2014, identify socio-demographic factors related to this lack of knowledge. HBV vaccination coverage rate analysed. | Cross-sectional | Persons in precarious conditions for primary health care - 94.5% are migrants from Africa, non-EU European countries, Asia | <15 | Attendance at clinic | Unclear | 58.1 | 61.8 | Lack of systematic checking of HBV serology/ vaccination status | |||||
Pavlopoulou et al., | 2017 | Greece | Migrant outpatient clinic of a tertiary Children’s hospital, Athens | Describe demographic, clinical and laboratory characteristics and identify possible determinants among newly arriving immigrant and refugee children | Cross-sectional | Migrant and refugee children mainly from Asia (Afghanistan, Bangladesh), Africa, Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 300 | 0.0 | 57.7 | 42 | 58.7 | Health evaluation for migrant children on arrival and refugees are often referred by NGOs or social services. | |||
Pohl et al., | 2017 | Switzerland | Tertiary health care facility in Switzerland in 2015 | Describe epidemiology and spectrum of infections of admitted paediatric refugees and asylum seekers | Cross-sectional (retrospective analysis using electronic patient records) | Paediatric refugees and asylum seekers (UAMs = 19.4%) from Africa, Eastern Europe and Asia | 0–18 | Admitted to hospital | 93 patients (105 admissions) | 5.7 | 62 | Missed opportunities to offer catch-up vaccinations during admission | |||||
Sollai et al., | 2017 | Italy | Tertiary health care setting, Italy | Evaluate infectious diseases prevalence in a large cohort of IAC | Cross-sectional | IAC from Africa, Asia and Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 1612 | 0.8 | 64.9 | 35 | 60 | IAC are screened on arrival | |||
Theuring et al., | 2016 | Germany | Institute of Tropical Medicine and International Health, Charité- Universitätsmediz Berlin 2014–2015 | Screening for infectious diseases among unaccompanied minor refugees | Cross-sectional | UAM (refugees) from Africa, Middle East, Asia, Southern and Eastern Europe | 0–18 | On arrival screening | 1248 | 1.7 | 16 | ||||||
Tiittala et al., 2018 | 2018 | Finland | Finland asylum seeker population study | Evaluate public health response to a large influx of asylum seekers to Finland in 2015–2016 re: national guidelines on initial health services and infectious disease screening | Cross-sectional (retrospective register-based) | Asylum Seekers – (accompanied and UAM) from Africa and Asia | 0–17 | On arrival screening (voluntary) | 9031 (3400 of which UAM) | 0.8 | Screening for Hep B, HIV, syphilis within should occur within 3 m after arrival (but 33% not reached) | ||||||
Williams et al., | 2020 | UK | 2 paediatric infectious disease clinics, London | Evaluate a screening programme for infection in UAM children and young people against national guidance and describe rates of identified infection in cohort | Cross-sectional (retrospective, routinely collected healthcare data) | UAM (asylum seeking) | 0–18 | Voluntary screening (on the basis of an individual risk assessment) | 252 attendees, 211 (84%) tested for hepatitis B | 4.8 | 17* | 88.6 | All UAMs receive a statutory health check and are referred to infectious disease clinic for screening |
Age is expressed as mean. * = denotes median age.
UAM, unaccompanied migrant.
VPD, vaccine preventable diseases.