Table 1.
RESYST studies | WHO studies | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Country | Kenya | Nigeria | Vietnam | Burkina Faso | Morocco | Tunisia |
Data collection | Policy documentation review In-depth interviews Focus group discussion |
Policy documentation review In-depth interviews Focus group discussion |
Policy documentation review Review of facility data In-depth interviews Focus group discussion |
Policy documentation review In-depth interviews |
Policy documentation review In-depth interviews |
Policy documentation review In-depth interviews |
In-depth interviews | Total number: 36 Participants: County Department of Health officials, NHIF branch officials, doctors, clinical officers, pharmacists, nurses, hospital administrators, nursing officer in charge, medical superintendents |
Total number: 66 Participants: State Ministry of Health, State Health Board, NHIS, Health Maintenance Organizations, doctors and nurses, hospital administrators |
Total number: 10 Participants: Department of Health, Provincial Social Security office, District Social Security office |
Total number: 67 Participants: Ministry of Health, SHI Fund, non-government organizations (NGOs) and community-based health insurance (CBHI) schemes running community health insurance, public and private hospitals |
Total number: 32 Participants: Ministry of Health, Ministry of Finance, SHI Fund (Caisse Nationale de Sécurité Sociale (CNSS)), National Union of Mutual Insurance Agencies (Caisse Nationale des Organismes de Prévoyance Sociale (CNOPS)), district management teams, public and private hospitals |
Total number: 17 Participants: Ministry of Health, Ministry of Finance; Ministry of Social Affairs, NHIF (Caisse Nationale d’Assurance Maladie (CNAM)), public and private hospitals |
Focus group discussions | Total number: 4 Participants: service users |
Total number: 8 Participants: service users |
Total number: 12 Participants: doctors and nurses, service users |
Not applicable | Total number: 1 Participants: regional hospital staff |
Not applicable |