Table 13.
p−value of Wilcoxon signed−rank test between IRIME and advanced algorithms
| F1 | F2 | F3 | F4 | F5 | F6 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBOwithCMAR | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.4772761749E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 6.8922902968E-05 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 | 1.0246327833E-05 | 5.7096495243E-02 | 8.4660816904E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| ALCPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.5152372790E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| CLPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.4147041360E-03 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LSHADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.3534209951E-06 | 2.7652741970E-03 | 1.9645813713E-03 | 1.0246327833E-05 | 2.3534209951E-06 |
| SADE | 3.1123151154E-05 | 5.6061165275E-06 | 1.0201069525E-01 | 3.8811142877E-04 | 8.1877534396E-05 | 5.3069919381E-05 |
| JADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 5.3069919381E-05 | 5.7096495243E-02 | 2.5967125848E-05 | 2.1266360107E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| RCBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1816794110E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.8821823861E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| EPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.8909720230E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 |
| CBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 9.5899017214E-01 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LWOA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 9.3156585911E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| F7 | F8 | F9 | F10 | F11 | F12 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBOwithCMAR | 1.2380795615E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.1266360107E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1849060258E-01 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 3.7093530785E-01 | 1.6394463017E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.5152372790E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 5.7164578367E-01 |
| ALCPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.4052567233E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 5.4462503972E-02 | 2.6033283895E-06 | 4.2856858692E-06 |
| CLPSO | 3.7093530785E-01 | 3.3172583108E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 7.6908593028E-06 | 3.8203416302E-01 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LSHADE | 1.9861020995E-01 | 4.7292023374E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.8821823861E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 7.8126371015E-01 |
| SADE | 2.7652741970E-03 | 4.5335631776E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.6394463017E-05 | 2.6033283895E-06 | 6.1564062070E-04 |
| JADE | 1.9729484516E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.3601107968E-05 | 2.3534209951E-06 | 4.8602606067E-05 | 2.7029156618E-02 |
| RCBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| EPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1816794110E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 8.9443006475E-04 | 5.7924461898E-05 |
| CBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LWOA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.8821823861E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| F13 | F14 | F15 | F16 | F17 | F18 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBOwithCMAR | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1617649367E-03 | 8.9443006475E-04 | 2.6134309227E-04 | 3.5888445045E-04 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.3172583108E-04 | 2.2551238908E-03 | 1.1748106348E-02 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| ALCPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 4.4493372835E-05 | 6.4242118722E-03 | 4.0715116266E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| CLPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.0671113567E-02 | 1.6565526979E-02 | 6.8358564253E-03 | 1.9209211049E-06 |
| LSHADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1617649367E-03 | 2.8485956185E-02 | 4.5335631776E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| SADE | 3.4052567233E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.4519030932E-01 | 1.8325799472E-03 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.1748106348E-02 |
| JADE | 1.6502656562E-01 | 6.8922902968E-05 | 2.7029156618E-02 | 7.5136622549E-05 | 4.8969007053E-04 | 6.1564062070E-04 |
| RCBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.1266360107E-06 |
| EPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.1826721596E-02 | 1.7790738330E-01 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| CBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LWOA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 4.2856858692E-06 | 3.1816794110E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| F19 | F20 | F21 | F22 | F23 | F24 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBOwithCMAR | 2.2248266458E-04 | 6.2682812500E-02 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.0000000000E+00 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 1.3601107968E-05 | 1.3059163494E-01 | 2.8021440811E-01 | 2.9574621307E-03 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.8712393203E-06 |
| ALCPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.1816794110E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 5.4553418355E-06 |
| CLPSO | 3.8203416302E-01 | 3.1617649367E-03 | 6.3197567644E-05 | 2.4519030932E-01 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LSHADE | 2.6134309227E-04 | 6.5641143410E-02 | 1.5927015021E-03 | 4.8602606067E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7333066442E-06 |
| SADE | 7.6908593028E-06 | 6.4242118722E-03 | 1.2505680433E-04 | 8.5895825870E-02 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.0000000000E+00 |
| JADE | 1.0569503498E-04 | 7.8126371015E-01 | 3.8723026479E-02 | 1.9729484516E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.2062023719E-04 |
| RCBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.5152372790E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| EPSO | 1.0246327833E-05 | 8.1877534396E-05 | 9.3156585911E-06 | 1.0246327833E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 5.3372636003E-07 |
| CBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LWOA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| F25 | F26 | F27 | F28 | F29 | F30 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBOwithCMAR | 1.9209211049E-06 | 2.4414062500E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7333066442E-06 | 3.0009891313E-02 | 1.5885549929E-01 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.6947913156E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 6.3391355731E-06 | 4.9498046028E-02 |
| ALCPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.6741785257E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.9209211049E-06 |
| CLPSO | 1.9209211049E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.8434237746E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LSHADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.8434237746E-05 | 2.1826721596E-02 |
| SADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.2500000000E-01 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 6.8835929823E-01 | 1.8909720230E-04 |
| JADE | 1.7343976283E-06 | 3.9632291146E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7300371293E-06 | 3.3172583108E-04 | 6.8358564253E-03 |
| RCBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| EPSO | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.1320754352E-04 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 2.0671113567E-02 | 4.2843002855E-01 |
| CBA | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |
| LWOA | 2.1630223984E-05 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 | 1.7343976283E-06 |