Skip to main content
. 2024 Aug 6;7:e52582. doi: 10.2196/52582

Table 4.

Key findings from studies that used the Kinect.

Study Primary features Main results
Cimolin et al (2022) [24]
  • Gait cadence, mediolateral sway, and step width

  • Strong positive correlation between Kinect and Vicon systems for gait cadence and mediolateral sway (ICCa 0.94-0.97) and a weak correlation for step width (ICC 0.44) in people with PDb

Kondragunta et al (2020) [19]
  • Gait cycle (dynamic time warping)

  • SVMc for classifying between controls, persons with possible MCId, and persons with MCI: 74.6%-87.3%

Lai et al (2022) [28]
  • Stride length, straight walking speed, and turning speed

  • Mediation analysis demonstrates decreased stride length, walking speed, and turning speed are associated with increased falls prediction model score (r=–0.58, r=–0.52, and r=–0.46, respectively; P<.001)

  • UPDRSe negatively correlated with features (r=–0.65, r=–0.56, and r=–0.37, respectively; P<.001) but positively with fall prediction model score (r=.53, P<.001)

  • UPDRS serves as a mediator for features and higher fall prediction model scores

Mehdizadeh et al (2021) [9]
  • Gait stability, step time, step length, step time variability, and step length variability

  • Mixed effects models over 10 weeks show:

    • Decrease in primary features and an increase in variability over time for people with dementia

    • Gait stability decreased more in men

    • Mediolateral range of motion decreased in those with mild neuropsychiatric symptoms but increased in those with more severe symptoms

Mehdizadeh et al (2021) [15]
  • Gait stability.

  • Cox proportional hazard regressions show gait stability predicts time to fall in people with dementia (ROCf 0.80 at 7 days, 0.67 at 30 days)

Muñoz-Ospina et al (2022) [31]
  • Left and right arm and ankle swing (magnitude and speed), stance time, gait speed, total time, and number of steps

  • Random forest model was most accurate for discriminating between people with PD and controls (85% using all gait features)

Ng et al (2020) [16]
  • Gait: cadence, symmetry, CVg of step time, step width (average and CV), and eMOSh

  • Univariate linear regression: cadence associated with POMAi-gait scores (P<.001)

  • Poisson regression: cadence, eMOS, average step width associated with the number of future falls (P<.001)

Ospina et al (2021) [32]
  • Arm swing: magnitude, time, and arm swing asymmetry

  • Age influenced arm movement

  • People with PD showed significant reductions in arm swing magnitude (left, P=.002; right, P=.006) and speed (left, P=.002; right, P=.004)

  • Arm swing asymmetry differentiated people living with PD from controls (ROC: 78%)

Otte et al (2020) [33]
  • Cadence, knee amplitude, asymmetry, average step time, longest step time, arrhythmicity, average stance time, and longest stance time

  • Knee amplitude and longest stance time correlated with UPDRS (–0.51, P=.003 and 0.52, P=.002, respectively)

  • Postural instability (pull test) correlated with longest stance time (0.47, P=.008)

  • Knee amplitude, asymmetry, and average step time differed between on- and off-medication states (P=.002, P=.007, and P=.007, respectively)

Pedro et al (2020) [34]
  • Step length

  • In comparison with the GAITRite (CIR Systems, Inc) system, the Kinect camera overestimated the average variation in step length for the 2 people with PD potentially due to inherent smoothing

Procházka et al (2015) [35]
  • Average step length

  • In total, 91.7% classification accuracy for determining between controls and those with people with PD. Decrease in step length (regression coefficient=–0.0082 m/year)

Sabo et al (2022) [18]
  • Number of steps, cadence, velocity, step length, CV of stride width, and step and swing time

  • Moderate or strong positive correlations between steps, cadence, step width from 2D pose-estimation, and Zeno in people with PD

  • Automated heel strike algorithm struggled to identify short steps

Sabo et al (2021) [17]
  • Cadence, steps, average step width, average margin of stability, CV of step width and time, and symmetry

  • ST-GCNj using 2D joint trajectories and gait features outperforms ST-GCN using only gait features

  • Regression models for predicting UPDRS-gait over 94% if off by 1 is allowed

Sabo et al (2020) [38]
  • 2D: steps, cadence, symmetry, and CV of step time

  • 3D: walking speed, step length or width, step width, step length symmetry angle, RMSk of MLl velocity, margin of stability, and CV step width

  • Multivariate ordinal logistic regression models achieved 61.4% and 62.1% for 2D and 3D features for predicting UPDRS-gait in people with dementia

Seifallahi et al (2022) [39]
  • Steps and stride

  • Adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system classifier accuracy >90% for differentiating between MCI and controls

Soltaninejad et al (2018) [41]
  • Stride and tremor

  • Random forest classifier accuracy for differentiating controls and people with dementia: 93.33% stride and 81% tremor

Tan et al (2019) [42]
  • Step length, step time, vertical pelvic displacement, and gait speed

  • Multivariable regression: step length during TUGm and vertical pelvic displacement during the gait speed were associated with postural instability and gait disorder (P=.01 and P<.05, respectively) in people with PD

Ťupa et al (2015) [43]
  • Step length and average speed

  • Combining gait features improves classification accuracy relative to single features

  • 2-layer neural network achieved an accuracy of 97.2% in classifying people with PD from controls

aICC: intraclass correlation coefficient.

bPD: Parkinson disease.

cSVM: support vector machine.

dMCI: mild cognitive impairment.

eUPDRS: Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale.

fROC: receiver operating characteristic.

gCV: coefficient of variation.

heMOS: estimated margin of stability.

iPOMA: Tinetti Performance Oriented Mobility Assessment.

jST-GCN: spatiotemporal graph convolutional networks.

kRMS: root mean squared.

lML: mediolateral.

mTUG: Timed Up and Go.