Table 1.
Summary of studies examining LTP phenotypes in littermate and non-littermate Fmr1 KO mice. (Studies examining LTP in Fmr1 KO mice were subdivided into three groups: (i) littermate, (ii) non-littermate mice, and (iii) undefined (breeding scheme could not be determined). Only the Fmr1 KO and Fmr1 KO2 (missing Fmr1 mRNA) mouse models of FXS are included. The LTP genotype and brain area studied are shown. Abbreviations: mPFC, medial pre-frontal cortex; LA, lateral amygdala; DG, dentate gyrus; ACC, anterior cingulate cortex; LPP, lateral perforant pathway; MPP, medial perforant pathway; TA, temporoammonic; aud cortex, auditory cortex; MF, mossy fibre; PP, pairing protocol; β-AR, β-adrenoceptors; HFS, high-frequency stimulation; TBS, theta-burst stimulation; mGluR, metabotropic glutamate receptor; STDP, spike timing-dependent plasticity; TBSP, TBS pairing protocol; NOR, novel object recognition; C/A, commissural/associational; LFS, low-frequency stimulation.)
| LTP phenotype | studies | ref. | brain area | induction protocol; notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| littermate | increase | Pilpel et al. 2009a ,b | [55] | CA1 | PP (age- and protocol- dependent effects); Fmr1 KO2 |
| Connor et al. 2011a | [58] | CA1 | β-AR-dependent heterosynaptic plasticity | ||
| Martin et al. 2023 | [51] | Cerebellum | 100 stimuli, 10 Hz; presynaptic LTP mediated by β-AR (low [Ca]) | ||
| no change | Godfraind et al. 1996 | [53] | CA1 | HFS | |
| Paradee et al. 1999 | [54] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Li et al. 2002c | [12] | CA1 | TBS (brain area-dependent effect) | ||
| Pilpel et al. 2009 | [55] | CA1 | PP (age-dependent) / TBS (protocol-dependent); Fmr1 KO2 | ||
| Zhang et al. 2009a , b | [56] | CA1 | HFS / Fmr1 KO; littermate: Fmr1+/− mother and Fxr2−/y father | ||
| Auerbach & Bear 2010 | [57] | CA1 | HFS | ||
| Connor et al. 2011a | [58] | CA1 | HFS-induced synaptic tagging and capture | ||
| Franklin et al. 2014ac | [29] | CA1 | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Bostrom et al. 2015c | [32] | CA1 | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Ghilan et al. 2015c | [33] | CA1 | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Martin et al. 2016c | [36] | mPFC | TBS (area dependent); Fmr1 KO2 | ||
| reduction | Li et al. 2002c | [12] | cortex | TBS (brain area-dependent effect) | |
| Suvrathan et al. 2010 | [20] | LA | HFS; mGluR-dependent LTP | ||
| Eadie et al. 2012 | [23] | DG | HFS | ||
| Padmashri et al. 2013 | [26] | cortex | chemical LTP | ||
| Boda et al. 2014 | [27] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Franklin et al. 2014ac | [29] | DG | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Franklin et al. 2014b | [30] | DG | HFS | ||
| Bostrom et al. 2015c | [32] | DG | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Ghilan et al. 2015c | [33] | DG | HFS (hippocampal region-dependent effect) | ||
| Neuhofer et al. 2015 | [35] | accumbens | STDP | ||
| Martin et al. 2016b | [36] | mPFC | TBS (age-dependent effect); Fmr1 KO2 | ||
| Yau et al. 2016 | [37] | DG | HFS; Female Fmr1 HET mice | ||
| Feuge et al.2019 | [41] | CA1 | chemical LTP; no increase in mEPSC amplitude | ||
| Hwang et al. 2022 | [46] | CA1 | PP; interneurons | ||
| Martin et al. 2023a | [51] | cerebellum | 100 stimuli, 10 Hz; presynaptic LTP mediated by β-AR (high [Ca]) | ||
| non-littermate | increase | Brager et al. 2012 | [60] | CA1 | TBSP |
| Routh et al. 2013 | [61] | CA1 | TBSP | ||
| Borreca et al. 2023a | [49] | DG | HFS; 24 hour post NOR / protocol-dependent | ||
| no change | Lauterborn et al. 2007a | [15] | CA1 | TBS (protocol-dependent effect) | |
| Seese et al. 2012 | [59] | CA1 | TBS; reported 5 min post-induction | ||
| Lundbye et al. 2018b | [38] | CA1 | TBS (protocol-dependent effect) | ||
| Wang et al. 2018a | [40] | DG | Optogenetic induction protocol; C / A pathway | ||
| Banke & Barria 2020b | [42] | CA1 | LFS; 3 Hz, 2 min (age dependent) | ||
| Borreca et al. 2023a | [49] | DG | HFS; No NOR (protocol-dependent effect) | ||
| reduction | Lauterborn et al. 2007a | [16] | CA1 | TBS (protocol-dependent effect) | |
| Meredith et al. 2007 | [17] | PFC | STDP; increased threshold | ||
| Wilson & Cox 2007 | [18] | Neocortex | HFS | ||
| Lee et al. 2011 | [21] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Xu et al. 2012a | [24] | ACC | PP | ||
| Xu et al. 2012b | [25] | ACC | PP | ||
| Lundbye et al. 2018b | [38] | CA1 | TBS (protocol-dependent effect) | ||
| Martinez & Tejada-Simon 2018 | [39] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Wang et al. 2018a | [40] | DG | HFS/ pairing protocol; both MPP and LPP | ||
| Banke & Barria 2020b | [42] | CA1 | LFS; 3 Hz, 2 min (age-dependent effect) | ||
| Ostrovskaya et al. 2020 | [52] | CA1 | TBS; Lower probability of late-LTP in P21 KOs (studied < 2 to 5 week) | ||
| Seese et al. 2020 | [43] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Zhan et al. 2020 | [44] | Cerebellum | TBS | ||
| Ordemann et al. 2021 | [45] | CA1 (TA) | TBS | ||
| Jeon et al. 2022 | [47] | CA1 | TBS | ||
| Borreca et al. 2023a | [49] | DG | HFS; 1 hour post NOR (protocol-dependent effect) | ||
| Li et al. 2023 | [50] | mPFC | TBS | ||
| undefined | no change | Larson et al. 2005b | [13] | APC / CA1 | TBS (age-dependent lack of effect; APC) |
| reduction | Larson et al. 2005b | [13] | APC | TBS (age-dependent effect) | |
| Zhao et al. 2005 | [14] | ACC/LA | PP | ||
| Hu et al. 2008 | [18] | CA1 | PP; acute and cultured slices | ||
| Shang et al. 2009 | [19] | CA1 | Chemical LTP | ||
| Yun & Trommer 2011 | [22] | DG | TBS | ||
| Chen et al. 2014 | [28] | ACC | TBS | ||
| Yang et al. 2014 | [31] | Aud cortex | HFS; mGluR dependent LTP | ||
| Koga et al. 2015 | [34] | ACC | LFS; 2 Hz, 2 min; Presynaptic LTP | ||
| Monday et al. 2022 | [48] | DG | 25 Hz, 3X + d-APV; conditional KO of FMRP in Granule Cells |
Diverging results within paper due to induction protocol difference.
Diverging results within paper due to age differences.
Diverging results within paper due to brain area differences.