Table 3. Colour coding definitions when responding to NPT questions using the evidence provided in publications.
Colour coding | Closed question | Open question |
---|---|---|
Green | Clear evidence in the publication that the question can be answered with a ‘yes’*. | Evidence in one or more publications that the impact of the implementation has been positive with respect to the question. |
Amber | Partial evidence that the question can be answered with a ‘yes’* OR Evidence for both ‘yes’* and ‘no’ responses. |
Partial evidence that the impact of the implementation was positive OR Evidence that there were positive and negative impacts of the implementation |
Red | Clear evidence in the publications that the question can be answered with a ‘no’*. | Evidence in one or more publications that the impact of the implementation has been negative with respect to the question. |
Grey | No evidence can be found to answer with either ‘yes’* or ‘no’. | No evidence in any of the publications of the impact with respect to the question. |
Yes answers range from 6% to 69%, with a median value of 38%. ‘Not reported’ ranges from 0% to 69%, with a median value of 31%. Dugdale et al (X) and Jefferies et al (CC) scored the highest, with 69% positive responses.
NPT, normalisation process theory.